Dr. Michael McGinnis creator of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force and currently senior scholar at the Institute of Medicine.
Conversations on Health Care® focuses this week on the current issues we face in both clinical care and public health interventions. Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Dr. Michael McGinnis, a health policy leader who has served through the Carter, Reagan, Bush and Clinton Administrations as Deputy Assistant Secretary for Health, Assistant Surgeon General and Director of the Office of Disease Prevention. Dr. McGinnis is currently senior scholar at the Institute of Medicine, leading its initiative on evidence-based medicine.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare; I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: Margaret, we spoke about the launch of our National Childhood
Obesity campaign Recess Rocks last week. It was a huge success with
Connecticut Governor Jodi Rell and California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger
th
declaring September 8 , Recess Rocks Day. And now the program is available
for children in schools all across the country participate and you know they can
find out about both our contest and our program at www.recessrocks.com .
Margaret Flinter: Well, it's a coast to coast phenomena and we were very excited
to launch it last Wednesday and on the same day, First Lady Michelle Obama
outlined the next phase of her Let’s Move campaign. That’s her initiative to solve
the problem of childhood obesity within a generation. And as children across the
country began a new school year, this year the First Lady is focusing the
campaign on School Lunches, a subject that all of us parents who are very
familiar with. She is encouraging more schools to participate in the HealthierUS
Schools Challenge, that’s a program that requires schools to meet higher
standards for school foods for nutrition information and for physical education
and the improvements will lead to monetary rewards for schools which could be
used to fund health initiatives down the road. Mark, I read they are even crafting
a new online tool for expert chefs on how they can work with schools and do their
part to provide support for these changes.
Mark Masselli: That’s very exciting and with Congress back in session this week,
the First Lady is pressing the house to pass the childhood nutrition
reauthorization bill which will make it easier for children from low income families
to qualify for free or reduced cost lunches. Many of the priorities of the First
Lady’s campaign to fight childhood obesity were included in the bill’s
reauthorization like the adoption of National Food Nutrition Standards at all
schools and a funding increase that would result in healthier food options in
school cafeterias.
Margaret Flinter: Well Mark, I don’t know about you but this is one bill I am
willing to bet by money on, will pass easily. It's passed in the Senate, it's
received support from both the republicans and the democrats. The Institute of
Medicines recommendations call for a decrease in the amount of sugar and fat
and salt in school meals in five years and to increase whole grains and to double
the amount of fresh produce they serve within 10 years. So that’s a very
ambitious goal. Now speaking of the Institute of Medicine, our guest today is Dr.
Michael McGinnis, a senior scholar at the institute. Dr. McGinnis is a Health
Policy Expert who has served as the Deputy Assistant Secretary for Health as
Assistant Surgeon General and is Director of the Office of Disease Prevention.
That was a position in which he began the Healthy People initiative in the late
1970s that continues right on today setting a series of health goals for our nation
every decade. We are delighted Dr. McGinnis is going to join us today.
Mark Masselli: But no matter what the story, you can hear all of our shows on
our website www.chcradio.com . You can subscribe to iTunes to get our show
regularly download or if you would like to hang onto our every word and read a
transcript of one of our shows, come visit us at www.chcradio.com and now you
can find us on Facebook. You will find the button on our website or you can
search Conversations on Healthcare Radio Show.
Margaret Flinter: And as always, if you have feedback, email us at
www.chcradio.com , we would love to hear from you. Now before we speak with
Dr. McGinnis, let’s check in with our producer Loren Bonner for the headline
news.
Loren Bonner: I am Loren Bonner with this week’s headline news. President
Obama attempted to defend the new healthcare law last week after Medicare’s
Office of the Actuary found that the nation’s healthcare tab will go slightly up
instead of down to 2019 as a result of the healthcare overhaul. The president
who has insisted for months that reform with lower health costs said that the
finding spell out what is the consequence of ensuring an additional 30 million
more Americans.
President Barack Obama: At the margin that’s going to increase our cost we
knew that, we didn’t think that we were going to cover 30 million people for free.
But that the long-term trend in terms of how much the average family is going to
be paying for health insurance is going to be improved as consequence of
healthcare.
Loren Bonner: And president also took the opportunity speaking to a room full of
rd
reporters to applaud the first phase of implementation. September 23 marks
the six-month anniversary at the healthcare overhaul and several key provisions
take effect next week. Health Secretary Kathleen Sebellius has stuck by her
word to keep insurance companies accountable. She told the health insurance
lobby group America’s insurance plans that there will be zero tolerance for
insurers falsely blaming premium increases for 2011 on the patient protections in
the Affordable Care Act. She says the Government Urban Institute and Mercer
have estimated that the law should only impact premiums by 1 to 2.3%.
Appearing on Fox News AHIP President Karen Ignagni said that it's a basic law
of economics that additional benefits incur additional costs.
Karen Ignagni: Number of different interpretations about what's on the horizon
based on what are our underlying costs. So if you have an underlying cost
problem that we haven’t got in our hands around, number one, and you add new
benefits that’s going to require new cost.
Loren Bonner: And speaking of AHIP the groups Medicare and Medicaid
conferences underway in Washington this week, Don Berwick the newly
appointed head of CMS laid out some expected changes from Medicare under
healthcare reform including better care for patients at a lower price and better
health for the US population as a whole. Berwick also stressed the importance of
working in coordination with the insurance industry saying, my job at CMS is to
build relationships and partnerships where we can make healthcare better trust
will resurface.
Margaret Flinter: This week Conversations on Healthcare focuses on some of
the current issues facing clinical care. The human genome project has given rise
to clinicians’ ability to individualize healthcare through genetic testing. Test to
identify susceptibilities to common disease like cancer and diabetes may provide
a guide to preventive care or the use of genetic test to identify likely responses to
drugs may help to achieve safer and more effective drug therapy. This along with
engaging individuals and shared decision making captures the goal of
personalized medicine. The institute of medicine established its roundtable on
translating genomic based research for health in 2007. Although new genetic
testing technologies haven’t been widely adopted into the clinical setting and
research is still ongoing, the Institute of Medicine seeks to understand how these
advances are valued in the healthcare setting. The roundtable has brought to
the surface many of the diverse perspectives about genetic testing in the
healthcare setting and has tried to answer some of the fundamental questions
like how do stakeholders prioritize various aspects of genetic test when
determining value. And how do people access the relative value of genetic test
when making personal healthcare decisions. Next step on the roundtable’s
agenda may be a discussion about implementing genetic testing. Last week The
National Institutes of Health said it will expand its research network that’s been
focusing on how an individual’s genes affect responses to different medications
and treatment options. The NIH will invest a $161 million over the next 5 years in
its Pharmacogenetics Research Network. NIH director Dr. Francis Collins says
through these studies we are moving closer to the goal of using genetic
information to help prescribe the safest most effective medicine for each patient.
Let's turn now to our interview with Dr. Michael McGinnis Senior Scholar at the
Institute of Medicine and Executive Director of it's round table on value and
science driven healthcare.
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare. Today we are speaking
with Dr. Michael McGinnis the health policy leader who has served through the
Carter, Reagan, Bush and Clinton Administrations as Deputy Assistant Secretary
for Health, Assistant Surgeon General and Director of the Office of Disease
Prevention. Currently Dr. McGinnis is Senior Scholar at the Institute of Medicine,
welcome Dr. McGinnis.
Dr. Michael McGinnis: Thank you Mark and Margaret, pleasure to chat with you.
Mark Masselli: Yeah and congratulations on your many years of public service. I
am sure we will read in your memoirs how you survived such significant political
transitions from Carter to Reagan and Bush to Clinton. But today let's start
talking about your work at the Institute of Medicine. You are a pioneer of
evidence based medicine and you joined the institute in 2005 as they became
interested in looking at how evidences developed and used in healthcare. Could
you tell us about the roundtable on value in science driven healthcare that you
directed the institute and what are the goals of the project and why does the
Institute of Medicine support research in this area?
Dr. Michael McGinnis: Well thank you for that question. It's actually critically at
this stage. The roundtable value science drive healthcare began as your ramp
up indicated as the roundtable of evidence based medicine and the reason for
getting under where the outset was simply the fact that there is a huge gap and a
growing gap between what we know what's proven to work under which
circumstances in clinical care and what we need to know. The reason I say it's a
growing gap despite the fact that there is a fair amount of research in it is that
everyday we have new interventions, both diagnostic and treatment that are
developed that hold important prospects for treating disease. And everyday we
also learn more about people’s individual variation and responses to those
diagnoses and treatments. And so we clearly need to ramp up substantially the
pace in which we develop evidence about what works best for whom under what
circumstances. So the Institute of Medicine took on the special focus of attention
on trying to develop people’s awareness about this evidence gap and building
the momentum for action.
Margaret Flinter: Dr. McGinnis you have influenced health policy in so many
ways during your career and I would like to highlight just one of them. Dr. Julius
Richman the Surgeon General and Assistant Secretary for Health in the late 70s
and early 80s appointed you to head the Office of Disease Prevention and Health
Promotion where you jumpstarted what Dr. Richman called the Second Public
Health Revolution with the healthy people series, a series of health goals for the
nation every decade. Now when you embarked on this project in the late 70s
you were tackling then very contemporary health issues like smoking, diet,
sedentary living and safety practices which are still pretty contemporary in 2010.
And we have certainly made progress on some of them particularly smoking but
in other areas like obesity things just have gotten worse. Just that Healthy
People initiative go far enough in laying out a blueprint for what our goals and
actions ought to be or is it time for revision to that process?
Dr. Michael McGinnis: Well any process needs to be revised constantly. The
initial healthy people process which set goals to be achieved between 1980 and
1990, I think did a pretty good job for two of its aims. One was to draw people’s
attention to the importance of prevention essentially prevention is the absence of
a problem. And since we are as a society mostly focused on the squeaky wheel,
we had to find a way to celebrate things that don’t occur. So setting these goals
in effect help people understand what might be possible if we could apply
ourselves effectively over decades. But as you say the nature of the problems
change and the importance of reaching out to engage players outside the health
sector has become ever more a prominent mandate. So we need to tailor our
efforts along the way and there is a long way of saying that yes the healthy
people process has been helpful both for 1990, for 2000, 2010, 2020 will be but it
needs to improve every single year.
Mark Masselli: Dr. McGinnis speaking of prevention, you led the creation of the
US preventive task force in 1984 to assess clinical preventive services, now the
backbone of much of the screening, immunization and testing and clinical
practices in primary care. How has the taskforce recommendations faired under
the federal health reform bill? Do you think we will see widespread adoption of
the guidelines under any new health plan developed for the health insurance
exchanges for instances and do you think there is the public welfare mandates in
the area of prevention?
Dr. Michael McGinnis: I think the direct answer to your question will the public
support the focus on prevention I think that there is a much greater appreciation
and the importance of prevention and hence the public will support it, is
supporting it and is in fact likely to demand it. And the law, the Affordable Care
Act passed earlier this year actually enhanced it substantially the prospects for
the recommendations of the US preventive services taskforce to be implemented
by virtue of formally establishing that body in statute as the official body that
determines what will we provided in the way preventive services under Medicare
and Medicaid. We have come a long way in that respect. The reason that I
formed the taskforce in the first place back in the 80s was despite the fact that
there was a substantial body of evidence developing at that, even at that time on
the effectiveness of preventive services, immunization, screening, counseling so
forth. There was relatively little reimbursement for those services in private plans
or by the government, in fact Medicare was prohibited from providing preventive
services except by individual in effect the active congress. And so when we
would ask why preventive services couldn’t be reimbursed under any of these
various insurance plans we get back to the question or the answer where is the
proof? And of course there was lots of proof, the preventive services taskforce
used this rigorous standards of evidence to deliver that proof. I think it’s been
effective in growing the acceptance and delivery of preventive services but it’s far
from as effective as it should have been because we have a big gap between
what needs to be provided in the way of proven preventive services and what
actually is provided. I think that the Heath Reform Act will be very helpful in that
respect.
Margaret Flinter: Well I can tell you that in our organization we rely on the
preventive service taskforce recommendations as a fundamental element of our
model of care so we thank you very much for your work in that area Dr McGinnis.
And you also in addition to the taskforce and the screening initiatives you initiated
at the National Coordinating Committee on Worksite Health Promotion from 1979
to 1987 and also the National Coordinating Committee on School Health
emphasizing throughout that it’s not just about what goes on in the clinical exam
rooms but it’s also about workers on in our schools and in our workplace. Would
you like to point to any significant progress that you have seen in innovations in
either school place or workplace health that contributes to healthier communities
and individuals?
Michael McGinnis: In both cases there have been substantial gains, the credit to
what we see in the way of developments in school health for example, the
emphasis finally on better childhood nutrition in school food services. And finally
on the kinds of foods that are included in vending machines is a tribute
unfortunately to the recognition that childhood obesity is threatening a generation
in fact perhaps multiple generations. And the issue of health promotion and
preventive services that are emphasized through the workplace and through
employer polices, we do see a substantial focus on that now recognition of the
possibility of really changing workforce health profiles but that’s driven
substantially by the exploding healthcare costs and the drain on our national
competitiveness regardless of what the reason is. I think there is attention and
again back to the Affordable Care Act, there are now incentives that are possible
if appropriately implemented to help shift the focus more toward health outcomes
as opposed to individual services and that should provide another boost to the,
strengthening the length between payment for services in medical care and what
goes on in the community.
Mark Masselli: Today we are speaking with Dr Michael McGinnis Health Policy
Leader and Senior Scholar at the Institute of Medicine. Dr McGinnis back in
2008 you have worked with Kaiser Permanente to develop an action plan to
guide the use of evidence in decision making about obesity prevention policies
and programs, tell us about that evidence, and I remember that it’s not too long
ago since counseling for obesity wasn’t even a covered service under most
Medicaid or private health plans. How has the evidence been incorporated in the
Kaiser plan and beyond that do we have good comparative effectiveness
research in the area of childhood obesity?
Michael McGinnis: Actually we have relatively little evidence in a range of
pediatric interventions. There is now a rather substantial boost and interest in
that arena. It’s very complicated because much of the childhood obesity
epidemic can only be addressed by factors outside the clinical arena. Progress
is dominantly going to come from what happens outside those clinic doors.
Margaret Flinter: Dr McGinnis I would like to talk about one other area of health
and healthcare that often doesn’t get as much attention as it should, and really
didn’t get as much attention in the federal health reform process as I hoped it
would and that’s the state of rural healthcare and rural health services in
America. We know that adequate dental care doesn’t reach enough people
particularly low income and people living in rural areas. Can you tell us what the
Institute of Medicine is thinking about in this area and will we see some
recommendations coming forth from the institute in the future?
Michael McGinnis: If you look across the boards in terms of national health
status and step back a little bit and say what single issue is the most prominent
challenge for the nation in the health arena, it would have to be the disparities in
health status and health challenges. And the issue of rural health is what might
be viewed as a central indicator in that respect. Because it is far more
prominently a problem and a serious problem in lower income populations and
isn’t given the recognition that is needed.
Mark Masselli: Dr. McGinnis when you look around the country and the world
what do you see in terms of innovation and who should our listeners at
Conversations be keeping an eye on?
Michael McGinnis: Actually I think that the listeners should be keeping an eye on
themselves because assuming ownership of their health status and healthcare is
probably the innovation that is most actively in progress. The major and driving
dynamic here is just what's going on in the scientific arena. When we look at the
tremendous pace of growth of information and insight about the generic variation,
individual variation, the patient and clinician as a shared set of partners in
understanding, bringing all of the evidence to the fore and in working together to
make the decisions is just going to be absolutely inevitable and necessary. So
that’s why I say as you look at scientific progress most of that progress I think is
ultimately going to drive the patient who have to take more control over their own
health prospects and decisions about their healthcare.
Margaret Flinter: Well that’s a tremendous message to our listeners and to the
country. Today, we have been speaking with Dr. Michael McGinnis, Health Policy
Leader and Senior Scholar at the Institute of Medicine. Dr. McGinnis thank you
so much for being with us today.
Michael McGinnis: Well thank you Margaret and Mark.
Mark Masselli: Each week Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives.
Margaret Flinter: This week’s bright idea comes to us from Africa where following
the summer’s World Cup tournament in South Africa soccer fans are still as
active as ever but on a somewhat different project, The Football For Hope
Community Centers. In 2007, FIFA the International Soccer Association teamed
up with the Street Football World Network with the goal of using soccer to
promote social development, peace, and social change. The founders of the
Football for Hope Movement hoped to use what they see as the universal appeal
of soccer to bridge cultural gaps and bring people together to solve critical
issues. This year FIFA and Street Football World launched a new 20 centers in
2010 campaign with the aim of raising $10 millions to fund 20 Football for Hope
Centers across the continent. Six centers are already nearing completion in
South Africa which will serve as models for the remaining 14 in the years to
come. Although all the centers share Football for Hope’s broad mission of
positive social change with a particular focus on health and education. Their
individual programs will be tailored to specific local needs identified with and by
local partner organizations. All of the centers will also contain renewable energy
systems such as wind and solar and will be built from a cycle bulk of materials.
The basic design of each center, a mid-sized Astroturf soccer field, classrooms,
and healthcare clinics so to conserve as an open and gathering space for local
youth as well as a school and health clinic for the whole community. The first
Football for Hope Center opened its doors late in 2009 in South Africa with the
mission of using the power of soccer to fight AIDS and provide youth with the
skills and support to live HIV free. The center’s local partner, Grassroots Soccer
runs classes for 12 to 18 year olds in which they are trained as peer educators.
These young people are becoming health ambassadors in their community
sharing what they have learnt in creative ways with their families and friends. By
using the unifying power of soccer to create vibrant health and education centers
the Football for Hope Movement is helping provide people with the resources and
the knowledge they need to promote wellness in their own communities. Now
that’s a bright idea.
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Healthcare; I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan
University at WESU, streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.