Donna Shalala, former U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services, current president of the University of Miami and chair of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Initiative on the Future of Nursing at the Institute of Medicine.

Conversations on Health Care® focuses this week on the future of nursing in advancing health. Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with former Health and Human Services Secretary Donna Shalala about the Institute of Medicine’s report in light of national health reform.

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare. I am Mark Masselli.

Margaret Flinter: I am Margaret Flinter.

Mark Masselli: Margaret, we finally got to hear from Don Berwick, the newly
appointed Director for Medicare and Medicaid. Although it was in the context of a
grueling senate finance committee session, it was compelling to hear defend
criticism about the new health law and denounce efforts to repeal it.

Margaret Flinter: Well Mark, Dr. Berwick is certainly no stranger to grueling
conversations. He headed up our HR 00.28 _______ and tried to change the
course of the entire healthcare system to make it more safe and of higher quality.
And only an hour and half was allowed for the session by Max Baucus the
Democrat from Montana, some republicans and democrats like, would have liked
more time and there is still lingering resentment that the appointment of Dr.
Berwick and his confirmation as Head of CMS was done in a recess appointment
by President Obama which of course bypassed the Congress.

Mark Masselli: Oh that bypassing of the confirmation process never makes it
easier. But Dr. Berwick is hard at work and he has already begun to apply some
of his innovative ideas for making medical care more efficient and less
expensive. CMS finally launched the innovation center. We have been hearing
so much about before initial demonstration projects that focus on coordinating
medical care beneficiary’s care.

Margaret Flinter: And did you notice that that office now has a new Head, Dr.
Richard Gilfillan, and I was not surprised at all that he comes out of the Geisinger
System, served as its past president, he is a family physician by a profession.
We have heard so much about the route to success in Health Reform being
about integrating healthcare services and coordinating care for individual
patients. No surprise he came out of the system that’s really been a leader in
that and I am looking forward to hearing more from him.

Mark Masselli: You are a fond of knowledge out there at Geisinger. Well now,
let’s turn to today’s guest, Donna Shalala who is currently President of the
University of Miami, but she also served in the Clinton Administration as their
Secretary of Health and Human Services. President Shalala is no stranger to
seeking out ways to improve America’s healthcare system. She is also a Chair of
the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation initiative on the future of nursing at the
Institute of Medicine and we are happy she can join us today.

Margaret Flinter: And no matter what the story you can hear all of our shows on
our website www.chcradio.com . Subscribe to iTunes and get our show regularly
downloaded or if you would like to hang on to our every word and read a
transcript of one of our shows, come visit us at www.chcradio.com . And you

could become a fan of Conversations on Healthcare on Facebook and follow us
on Twitter.

Mark Masselli: And as always if you have feedback email us at
www.chcradio.com , we would love to hear from you. Before we speak with
President Shalala, let's check in with our producer Loren Bonner with Headline
News.

Loren Bonner: I am Loren Bonner with this week’s Headline News. The
Department of Health and Human Services issued the long awaited regulations
that spell out how much of the premium dollar insurers must spend on patient’s
healthcare also known as the Medical Loss Ratio. Starting in January 2011, the
federal regulation will require health insurers to spend at least 80% of premiums
on healthcare for individuals and those enrolled in small group plans and 85% for
those enrolled in large group coverage. The new rules which followed the
National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ recommendations will prevent
insurers wasting valuable premiums on overhead, marketing and executive
bonuses. Nancy Ann-DeParle, Director of the White House Office of Health
Reform says there is even more good news here for consumers.

Nancy Ann-DeParle: This will be transparent. You will know it will be public. You
will know how much of your premium dollars your insurance company is
spending towards your healthcare.

Loren Bonner: Insurance companies that do not meet the Medical Loss Ratio
standard will be required to provide rebates to their consumers starting in 2012.
The Department of Health also announced that it's putting 290 more dollars into
the National Health Service Corps, the program that helps primary care clinicians
pay off student loans in exchange for two years of service in underserved areas.
The expansion is projected to allow 11,000 and more primary care providers to
participate. Right before the Thanksgiving Holiday Recess senators agreed on
extending the current medicare physician payment rates in an effort overt at 23%
st
cut in Medicare provider reimbursement scheduled for December 1 . The
measure represents a unanimous agreement negotiated by Democrat Max
Baucus and Republican Charles Grassley. Senator Baucus and Senator
Grassley said the one month extension would provide time for Congress to work
at a deal on a longer extension in December. They said they are working to
secure “a mutually agreeable way to pay for the year long cost of the physician
formula as well as other extenders.” The measure now goes to the house which
is scheduled to take it up after the Thanksgiving Recess.

This week on Conversations, we are looking to the role nurses play in the future
of healthcare. At three million strong, the nursing workforce has the potential to
significantly improve the quality of healthcare and Americans access to it. The
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Institute of Medicine published a new
report on this very subject. One aspect of the report focuses on the role nurses

play in primary care managing chronic disease particularly in high risk
underserved populations. One challenge for healthcare today is to adequately
care for an aging population with chronic disease. This challenge comes beside
a primary care workforce shortage and the high cost of chronic disease which
accounts for more than 75% of annual healthcare costs nationally. Five nurse-
led innovations aimed at better managing chronic care are highlighted in a
section called Transformation Models of Nursing Across Different Care Settings.
One of the demonstration projects mentioned for example, involves advanced
practice nurses at a nurse-managed Primary Care Healthcare in Texas. They
oversee community health workers who provide intensive care coordination
involving home visits and telephone calls to patients enrolled in a Chronic
Disease Management program. The interdisciplinary team takes into account
social determinants of health and care delivery and involves engaging a
Community Advisory Board in implementing a program. There are already early
indications that it's having a positive impact on health. Let’s turn now to our
interview with Danna Shalala who led the initiative on the future of nursing at the
Institute of Medicine.

(Music)

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare. Today, we are speaking
with Donna Shalala of US Secretary of Health and Human Services during the
Clinton Administration and currently President of the University of Miami.
President Shalala is also Chair of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation initiative
on the future of nursing in America at the Institute of Medicine. Welcome
President Shalala. As a Secretary of Health and Human Services, the longest
serving HHS Secretary in US history I might add they were many
accomplishments raising childhood immunization rates to the highest level in
history making health insurance available to millions of children through the
SCHIP program and improvements to Medicare to name a few but National
Health Reform eluded the Clinton Administration in which you served. As you
look back, how was the environment different in the Obama Administration from
the Clinton Administration that made it possible for Health Reform Legislation to
pass?

Donna Shalala: Well, first of all, he had the votes. He had both senate and the
house. By the end of our first two years, we had lost both the senate and the
house but initially coming into the administration we simply didn’t get it done as
quickly as the Obama Administration, didn’t reach consensus. They essentially
used existing platforms as existing program and handed over a lot of the
coverage to the private sector to do with the states. So Obama’s proposal was
state based, not the federal takeover everybody has been talking about though
there clearly are federal guidelines but the states will organize the markets, the
states will hand out the subsidies to people who can't afford to pay. Most of
whom are working and the states will expand their existing programs, the
Medicaid program in particular that cover low income workers.

Margaret Flinter: President Shalala, Dr. Harvey V. Fineberg the President of The
Institute of Medicine has said that the possibility of strengthening the largest
single component of the healthcare workforce nurses to become partners and
leaders in improving the delivery of care in the healthcare system as a whole is
what inspired the IOM to partner with the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and
creating the initiative on a future of nursing which you of course have led and
chaired. That committee was formed in 2008 just before the health reform efforts
got on to way so your work really played out against this backdrop of a huge
national debate on healthcare. How did your understanding of the fundamental
issues in healthcare generally and in nursing specifically change over these two
years?

Donna Shalala: Well there is no question that if you want to cover a larger
number of people you are going to have to use every part of the healthcare
workforce to their training and nurses are fully able to absorb a very large
number of people that will be coming into primary care. Working as partners with
physicians we simply don’t have the physician workforce for primary care to be
able to absorb the very large number of people whether it's primary care chronic
care management, palliative end of life care, nurses are trained to do these jobs
but they are restrained by rules in their state. If we can use nurses as part of this
expansion will have quality healthcare that will be able to deliver fairly quickly.

Mark Flinter: Because initially while your committee is true together national
leaders from healthcare, government, education technology in nursing but in
addition to exhaustive research it took the committee on the road for a series of
forms in LA and Houston and Philadelphia. The form seemed to be designed to
inform the committee about critical and varied roles and nurses play across
settings and you focused in on acute care education and community health.
That’s what was the consistent message you heard in those forms.

Donna Shalala: That nurses can do more that they have the education they
need more education as we go forward but they certainly have the education and
the ability to take on larger roles in healthcare. That’s what we heard consistently
from one end of the country to the other. Not simply from nurses but from
educators from doctors from other parts, other leaders in healthcare.

Margaret Flinter: President Shalala the committee recently released its report
called the future of nursing leading change advancing health. It issued 8
recommendations for action consistent with Dr. Fineberg’s call for the initiatives
conclusions to be a blueprint for action. We would like to explore a few of these
recommendations in more depth starting with recommendation number one,
Remove scope of practice barriers and you gave very specific directions to
congress, to the state legislatures, CMS even the Federal Trade Commission on
how to do this. But I think outside of the nursing profession the issue probably

just isn’t part of public consciousness. Can you share with our listeners why the
issue of barriers, the scope of practice such an important one in healthcare?

Donna Shalala: I think the American people will be surprised to learn that they
have invested in nurse’s education in their states. And yet there were states
restrains on how much nurses are allowed to do. In some states like New
Hampshire for example, nurses are allowed to do everything the primary care
doctors or at least 70% of what primary care doctors are allowed to do. They can
write prescriptions, they can do diagnosis, they are obviously not specialists but
they can do referrals, where in another state Kansas for example, or Ohio, or
Florida they are restrained from doing many of those things. Nurses can be in
places like Kansas City, Missouri, Kansas City, Kansas and on side they can do
more than they can do on the other side of the bordered line so. This is unfair
constraints given the fact that the public the tax payers have invested in their
training, have approved that training, have tested that training but have unfair
constraints on their ability to use that training. It's also a very expensive way to
do healthcare, invest in training you ought to be able to use your education and
training. You can go to some states and use it and other states there are
restraints put on you.

Mark Flinter: President Shalala, the report makes strong recommendations for
education, life-long learning and to prepare enabled nurses to lead change. You
call for increasing the percentage of nurses with the Bachelor’s degree and
doubling the number of nurses with the doctorate. But you also speak to the
need for leadership training and business practice skills for nurses as essential to
leading change. What did you hear from nurses in the healthcare community as
a whole during your work that led you to focus on the ability to lead change as a
vital importance skill for nurses.

Donna Shalala: Well I think it's very important that nurses see themselves as
partners, that that they see themselves as leaders and their education and
training has to include that as part of the curriculum. There is no question that
they can step forward that they are on the line that they see patient care from a
different perspective that most patients first contact and last contact is really with
the nurse. We also call for 80% of the nurses to have Bachelor’s degrees. That
doesn’t mean that we think those programs should be expanded just in current
four year colleges. We believe in community colleges across the country that
they ought to be able to expand to four-year programs in nursing. That has
already happened to the couple of places in Florida. We believe it will be very
successful universities like mine are training the faculty for those places. The
only way you are going to get to 80% is to have lots of parts of the health system
participating.

Margaret Flinter: President Shalala I actually had the pleasure of attending the
Philadelphia Form and the Future of Nursing and was your Guest Blogger for the
event. Governor Rendell spoke very powerfully at that forum about his view the

advanced practice nurses and particularly nurse practitioners and midwives were
critical to his state’s goals of improving access and also transforming care and of
course Pennsylvania has been a leader in providing support to practices in health
centers to transform care particularly around chronic disease management. So
this kind of executive leadership at the state level is obviously very helpful to
carrying out your recommendations. Have you in the committee been involved in
working with governors across the country in this effort and is there plan to help
bring the many new governors and new members of congress up to speed on
these issues in this post election period.

Donna Shalala: Yes in fact Robert Wood Johnson program is going to underwrite
the efforts to implement the report and that means working with governors and
state legislatures I am going to be talking to some state legislative leaders myself
a little later this month and make the point that they really have to step up if they
want to improve the quality, the breadth, the coverage of healthcare in their
states.

Mark Flinter: This is Conversations on Healthcare, today we are speaking with
Donna Shalala former Secretary of Health and Human Services and currently
chair of the committee on the future of nursing at the Institute of Medicine.
President Shalala you started your career as a Political Science Professor. We
heard that every spring semester there in Miami you teach a course covering the
United States Healthcare System trying on your expertise as serving as secretary
of health and human services. With the changes in health reform how is your
lesson plan going to change?

Donna Shalala: Well we are going to talk about the politics of implementation
and the politics of change. What happens when you get a new congress they
take a look at the legislation and say may be we want some changes here. It's
hard to do changes before you started the implementation process so my
students will be following both the politics and the economics of healthcare to see
whether the new congress and basically the voters have set a message for some
changes. I doubt there are going to be many changes but I do think
implementation is where the action is going to be.

Margaret Flinter: Well that’s going to be a fascinating class. President Shalala
we were particularly pleased to see recommendation number three and the
report implementing nurse residency programs to support to transition to practice
for both new nurses and new advance practice nurses and parenthetically our
organization established America’s First News Practitioner Residency Program in
Primary Care in 2007. And in that recommendation you urged HRSA, CMS and
the foundations to the fund the development and implementation of residency
programs across all practice settings. Now over the years there have certainly
been many calls to revise the legislation that governs the Graduate Medical
Education Funding at the federal level or GME to allow these funds to be used
for nurse residency programs. We are curious whether the committee consider

that policy issue as a strategy to implement residency programs for nurses and
can you share some of the pros and cons if that was considered?

Donna Shalala: Well, you know, we certainly did consider it. We identified a
source of funding in HRSA that could pay for these programs but the truth is
many of these programs they will cost much money, particularly the hospital
based ones. Hospitals can implement Residency Programs, all the evidence
says that if you do that and pay close attention to the new group of nurses
coming in, you will reduce medical errors and you will increase retention and so
these programs will make a difference. It doesn’t mean that someone isn't
working, after all these nurses have their licenses. But it does mean that you pay
closer attention and put them through a Residency Program that will benefit your
bottom-line as well as the quality of healthcare you are able to provide.

Mark Masselli: President Shalala, you have a broad world view through your
entire career starting as one of the early Peace Corps volunteers when you were
assigned to Iran. We would like to ask all of our guests this question when you
look around the world, what do you see in terms of innovations and who should
our listeners at Conversations be keeping an eye on?

Dr. Donna Shalala: There is enormous amount of innovation going on around
the world. The use of nurse mid-wife in Peru for example, to reduce mother and
infant mortality is very impressive. Here is the nation that doesn’t have a lot of
resources but got their act together and got an integrated plan working with US
Aid and care to design a program that saves babies and their mothers by getting
people into institutional settings, clinics, and hospitals to have their babies. And
some of the poorest areas of Peru 70% of mothers are giving birth in the
institutions that have dramatically saved mothers’ lives as well as children’s lives.
So there are impressive programs all over the world not just in the industrialized
countries that are saving lives, that are improving and we have programs in the
United States that are innovative, using clinics combined with academic health
centers, using mid-wife centers for the delivery of babies. But all of these require
state law to be flexible so that we can improve the quality of care. We have
made dramatic improvements in reducing medical errors in hospitals. There
have been lots of quality initiatives. The fact that Don Berwick is now heading
CMS I think will make a big difference in leadership and in our understanding of
improving the quality of healthcare.

Margaret Flinter: Today we have been speaking with Dr. Donna Shalala who
served as US secretary of Health and Human Services from 1993 through 2001
under President Bill Clinton. She is currently President of University of Miami,
Florida and Chair of the Robert wood Johnson Foundation initiative on the Future
of Nursing in America at the Institute of Medicine. President Shalala, thank you
so much for joining us today.

Dr. Donna Shalala: You are welcome.

Mark Masselli: Each week Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities into everyday lives. This week’s bright
idea comes Peru where Solidarity Hospitals are making essential healthcare
services accessible and affordable for the country’s poorest residence. Peru’s
health system has undergone substantial reform in the last decade and the
government now guarantees access to healthcare for all citizens. However,
many Peruvians struggle to receive care because providers are scarce and often
lack resources. Recognizing this gap in services several Lima healthcare
providers and entrepreneurs organized the metropolitan system of Solidarity
Hospitals. They opened the first Solidarity Hospital in 2003 in a converted bus
and began providing basic health services to area residence. With the help of
the local government which encourages alternative healthcare providers 23
hospitals have been opened in and around Lima. Built out of recycle shipping
containers, the hospitals provide a wide variety of services from pre-natal care to
infectious disease treatment. They remain self-funded through a daily high
volume of patients whom they charge modest fees. They also keep overhead
expenses low. Peruvians are chronically underserved by state healthcare
programs. In 2000 the country had roughly 1 hospital bed per 1000 people and
32% of the population was suffering from a disease health condition or accident
or had no access to care. Because of these groups in government systems
many Peruvians see the Solidarity Hospital as their only option for affordable
reliable healthcare. In its 7 years of operation, the hospitals have served over
4.5 million people by facilitating the need left unmet by the state healthcare
programs, Solidarity Hospitals are democratizing access to affordable healthcare
for all Peruvians. Now that’s a bright idea.

Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Healthcare.

Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.

Margaret Flinter: Conversations on Healthcare broadcast from the campus of
Wesleyan University at WESU streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to
you by the Community Health Center.