Rosemary Gibson, author of The Treatment Trap: How the Overuse of Medical Care is Wrecking Your Health and What You Can Do to Prevent It.

Conversations on Health Care® focuses this week on patient safety. Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Rosemary Gibson, nationally known for her work in patient safety, communications and healthcare quality. Her latest book, The Treatment Trap, focuses on the overuse of medical care and what can be done to reduce it.

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare. I am Mark Masselli.

Margaret Flinter: I am Margaret Flinter.

Mark Masselli: Margaret, I am out in Colorado with some friends one who is
going to be a United States Senator and another who is going to be the Governor
of Colorado and there was a lot of build up of money spent and I think there has
been shift in the House of Representatives. I am not sure there was the sea
change that people predicted.

Margaret Flinter: Well congratulations to those fine folks from Colorado and of
course we are very proud to say that they both have strong connections to
Connecticut and to Healthcare to Wesleyan University and to Middletown so
congratulations to Governor Hickenlooper and Senator Bennett.

Mark Masselli: Yeah it's very-very good news and it was late night across
country I know we are still counting ballots in Connecticut and they are still
counting ballots in Washington State so first of all it was little closer than people
thought in some areas and blowups in others so clearly there will be a change in
the House of Representatives and there is concern on terms of Healthcare
Reform. Not that there will be huge changes in the legislation but there might be
an effort to limit funding.

Margaret Flinter: Well, you know I agree with you, a huge change but I think I
would stop sure to saying a seismic change maybe the fact that the democrats
retain control of the senate certainly boards well for things moving forward. And
you know Mark, there is so much that’s already been put into motion as I look
around what’s been accomplished already most of the states working and setting
up their Health Insurance Exchanges, the prevention bill already funding, new
directions in preparing health professionals for the future, the HIT, the preexisting
conditions, so a lot going forward much of which we have covered over the past
year and much of which we have interviewed people who we are hearing about
on the National News last night, we have interviewed on the show over the past
year.

Mark Masselli: That is true we are going to keep an eye on all of the changes
that will start happening in January when the new Congress has sworn in but we
will also be keeping our eyes on the State Houses as they start to implement this.
And I think as the temperature cools down a little bit people understand at the
end of the day we still have a problem that we need to collect in healthcare and I
think the Reform Bill does a good job at it and yet they always use the community
(inaudible 2.29) to make it even better.

Margaret Flinter: Well, by the time we get back to Connecticut we may know who
is the next Governor of Connecticut. We don’t know that as of this moment as

the show is getting ready to go on AIR but hopefully we will find that out soon.
We know the states will be continued to be laboratories for innovation and that
will be over the coming months again focusing both on reform and innovation on
Conversations on Healthcare.

Mark Masselli: Margaret, let’s turn now to today’s guest Rosemary Gibson, who
was a National Leader in Patient Safety and Quality Healthcare. She has also
written books her most recent is called The Treatment Trap: How the Overuse of
Medical Care is Wrecking Your Health and What You can do to Prevent it. You
may also recall her first book Wall of Silence: The Untold Story of the Medical
Mistakes that Kill and Injure Millions of Americans. We are happy she can join us
today.

Margaret Flinter: And no matter what the story, you can hear all of our shows on
our website www.chcradio.com . Subscribe to iTunes and get our show regularly
downloaded or if you would like to hang on to our every word and read a
transcript of one of our shows, come visit us at www.chcradio.com and you can
become a fan of Conversations on Healthcare on Facebook and even follow us
on Twitter.

Mark Masselli: And as always, if you have feedback, email us at
www.chcradio.com we would love to hear from you. Now before we speak with
Rosemary Gibson, let's check in with our producer Loren Bonner with 4Headline
News.

Loren Bonner: I am Loren Bonner with this week’s Headline News. Republicans
gain control of the house after Tuesday’s midterm elections but democrats
remain in control of the senate. It was a big loss for democrats and their
signature legislative accomplishment health reform. Some of the laws biggest
supporters lost while the House Democrats who had opposed the law one seats.
Arizona and Oklahoma passed ballot initiatives pushing back against the
individual mandate but a similar Colorado measure failed. Exit polls from
Tuesday night showed Health Reform as the second most important issue for
voters after the economy. Federal Officials from the Department of Health have
announced a new grant program intended to help states make implementing
health reform a little easier. HHSS early innovates contest will reward states that
lead the way developing the Information Technology infrastructure needed to
operate the Health Insurance Exchanges that will be available in 2014. The IT
Systems in the exchange will be handling a variety of complex transactions like
helping consumers find the right health plan determining eligibility enrolling
people and plans and administering subsidy payments. The grant contest comes
in response to state’s concerns over the enormous task of developing the IT
systems in just three years and mid-tight state budgets. HHS said it will award
grants to five entities. This could be individual states or coalition of states. The
winning systems will be used as models for other states to follow. The two year
grants will be awarded in mid February 2011. A panel convened by the Institute

of Medicine will be meeting this month to begin considering what kind of
preventative care for women should be covered at no cost under the new
healthcare law. The big question is whether birth control should be considered
preventative care. Dr. Jeffrey Peipert from Washington University’s Department
of Obstetrics and Gynecology says he is glad to hear the Healthcare Reform Bill
as is written includes free contraceptives for women.

Dr. Jeffrey Peipert: It's hard for me to believe that many insurance companies
will cover Viagra but they won't cover something like contraception. I think family
planning and conception are essential components of any healthcare reform.

Loren Bonner: For many medico and public health experts, there is no debate.
But the US Catholic Bishops have weighed in and they strongly oppose any
requirement to cover contraceptives or sterilization as preventative care arguing
that pregnancy is a healthy condition not an illness. One option on the table is
allowing insurance plans why discretion on meeting the coverage requirement
but how the Obama Administration will apply the law remains to be seen. The
Department of Health will make a final decision in August 2011.

This week on Conversations on Healthcare, we were discussing the overuse of
medical treatment. A recent study conducted by the Institute for Social Research
at the University of Michigan found that patients hear far more from doctors about
the pros then the cons of medications, tests and surgeries. In addition
physicians tend to offer opinions not options and rarely do they mention to
patients that they can decide not to do anything. The studied surveyed more
than 3000 patients age 40 and older and asked the subjects about decisions they
made with healthcare providers within the past two years regarding common
medical issues like screening test for breast cancer, taking prescription drugs for
high cholesterol or having surgery for knee or hip replacement. The study found
that doctors, nurses and others were much more likely to talk of the advantages
of a treatment or test while skipping the negatives. For instance only 20% of the
patient who discuss breast cancer screening so they heard anything about
possible downsides such as false positive results, while 50% say they heard a lot
about the pros of screening. Health policy experts consider it vital that patients
fully understand both the benefits and the risks of medicine and that they have
the right to say no to suggested treatment. Let’s turn now to our interview with
Rosemary Gibson who can tell us more about the overuse of medical treatment
in our healthcare system and what can be done about it.

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare. Today we are speaking
with Rosemary Gibson a National Leader in Patient Safety and Healthcare
Quality and author of the book The Treatment Trap. How the overuse of medical
care is wrecking your health and what you can do to prevent it. Welcome
Rosemary. The Institute of Medicine has acknowledged this uniquely American
phenomenon in healthcare over years. I think the IOM defines the overuse as
situations in which the potential for harm of healthcare services exceeds the

possible benefit and while the overuse of drugs is often what comes to mind first
you point to a number of common medical procedures that are overused, and
may lead to more harm than good. Can you start by telling us what lead you to
this subject and are there particular areas in healthcare where you have found
the problem of overuse particularly striking?

Rosemary Gibson: I got into this work after reading a report from the
Commonwealth Fund. It surveyed Americans and 32% of people said they have
had medical care they thought was unnecessary. I thought that was a very
interesting statistics. So, I started asking people to questions have you ever had
medical care you thought was unnecessary? Have you ever declined the
treatment options that you thought were bit over the top and did you find it
medically appropriate alternative? The response to these questions has been
extraordinary. It turns out that there is a very large segment population. They
are typically, they have good insurance, they are fairly well educated, they do
their homework, they are finding that they are receiving medical care that really
they think is not good for them and that could cause more harm than good. And
these are people who are giving great thought, they are not doing this cavalierly.
They are getting second opinions, third opinions really doing their homework. So
that’s how I got into this. The areas where there was significant overuse ranges
certainly from medication overuses off the charts. The overuse of surgery is
especially pronounced, consumer reports that back surgery was the most
overused surgery in the country and it's continuing to increase.

Margaret Flinter: Rosemary you are an early pioneer and advocate in patient’s
safety and quality of care and certainly the issue of overuse is completely
intertwined with patient’s safety because virtually every treatment or procedure
carries risk to the patients or the potential at least for an error or bad reaction.
We have talked on other shows with guests about share decision making,
making sure the patient and the family is involved in making decisions and
choices about treatments and procedures. Is this a useful strategy do you think
in approaching this problem of overuse?

Rosemary Gibson: I think shared decision making is a wonderful approach that
should take place in every conversation about every decision. The question is
how do we get from where we are now to where we need to be, and there is long
road to go there. There are some wonderful tools out there for decision aids but
they are not directly accessible to the public. We have got to find a way to make
these tools to enable this conversation, you know their videos of you know real
life patients who have made decisions, who talk about the treatment options, the
risks, benefits so it’s a wonderful thing is we have got to find a way to get them to
people when they need them, when they have to make a major medical decision.

Mark Masselli: Rosemary in addition to the book being a guide you give 20
smart steps for consumers. You can also share a very compelling story of an
individual on elderly gentleman doctor I think Mr. Good who is admitted for knee

surgery that perhaps wasn’t really necessary and unfortunately died from
complications and it seems to me that a major problem there was coordination
amongst specialist and perhaps the lack of involvement of a primary care
provider who really knew the patient and we have been talking a lot about patient
centered medical homes. Do you think this model has a role to play in reducing
overuse?

Rosemary Gibson: If there is a well functioning medical home with primary care
providers that this gentleman who we call Mr. Good in the treatment trap went to
instead of going directly to a surgeon, an orthopedic surgeon there is no
questions that that surgery would never have taken place because it was entirely
inappropriate given his medical condition. So the medical home concept if
played out as envisioned is an absolutely critical step forward. If we look at all
that major countries in the world they have found that the basis for their
healthcare system is primary care and 70% to 80% of physicians are primary
care doctors. In this country is the opposite, most are specialists. The good
news is with healthcare reform is that the nurse practitioners are going to be
playing even greater role in nurse managed care to provide primary care for
patient. It’s exactly the direction where we need to be going, primary care is an
antidote to all of this overuse that’s causing more harm than good.

Margaret Flinter: Rosemary in the Treatment Trap and as you just suggested
certain treatments or procedures are particularly overused and can do harm back
surgeries is one, coronary, bypass surgery and other and of course in the past
year we have been treated to wildly different recommendations on the value as
well as the frequency for mammogram screening. So if the public understands
anything it's probably that there are very few absolutes in healthcare and what
we know today may be contradicted by new research or new science tomorrow.
Given that it's no surprise that patients want to rely on their doctors and
healthcare providers for expert recommendations but who do their healthcare
providers rely on and what’s the role of comparative effectiveness research in all
of this for healthcare professionals.

Rosemary Gibson: Two things, first of all one way that I started communicating
to the public on this which we talk about in the treatment trap is using a traffic
light as an example the types of decisions we have to make. Green Light Care is
care you always want to get. Yellow Light Care is like the mammogram issue for
women in their 40s, should I or shouldn’t I, there is some uncertainty. Women
have different tolerance just for risk, different histories in their family. So all of
those things need to be taken into account and then finally there is Red Light
care and that’s the care you should never get. Healthcare professionals can and
primary care providers in particular can go a very long way to guiding people to
where they should go to get the care that’s appropriate for them. Comparative
effectiveness research can provide extraordinary information on what works and
what doesn’t in contrary to what’s been written out there that the public is
concerned about evidence based medicine. I will bet that there is not a single

patient when they are relying on agreeing before they are going into an operating
room who doesn’t want their physician or surgeon whomever their team to they
want them only to do those things for which there is evidence. But I think
comparative effectiveness research will only go so far where I believe we need to
go is registry. And what that is if you are having back surgery your physician
along with other physicians will track the outcomes over a period of time of that
surgery for you and hundreds and hundreds of other patients. So we find out
what works. This is an approach that was used to treat and learn what does
work for childhood cancer and account for the fact that we have made so much
progress in a relatively short period of time for children. That approach that has
worked with them and it's worked for cystic fibrosis and we should apply that in
addition to comparative effectiveness research to healthcare today.

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare. Today we are speaking
with Rosemary Gibson author of The Treatment Trap, How The Overuse Of
Medical Care Is Wrecking Your Health and What You Can Do to Prevent It.
Rosemary the subject of overuse raises a number of issues that were considered
during the crafting of the patient protection in Affordable Care Act and are still
being debated now that legislation is passed. The legislation addresses patient’s
safety, quality and effectiveness of care. In the public’s mind though there seems
to be a persistent worry that the government or perhaps government insurance is
will established the rules for what a patient can and can't have done under
insurance versus it being the prerogative of their doctor. You followed the
healthcare debates closely was the subject of overuse specifically considered in
the development of this legislation.

Rosemary Gibson: That’s a very interesting question. Early on in the dialogue
President Obama used the term overuse, Peter Orszag – the Head of the Office
of Management and Budget used the term but after a while you didn’t hear it
anymore and I think that’s important because it's not politically correct among the
established interest in the medical industrial complex. It shows a flaw in it and
also while there have been some wonderful patient safety components of the
health reform legislation they are still small steps, and we are just beginning to
put our toe in the water. We have got to move a lot faster if you want to provide
high quality care to people in a way that’s affordable. So got to start it but we still
have a long way to go.

Margaret Flinter: Rosemary in your career you have no stranger to challenging
issues in healthcare. You have been a leader in advancing the concepts and the
use of palliative care and as program officer at the Robert Wood Johnson
Foundation one of the leaders of their strategy to bring palliative care into the
main stream and certainly that has required an enormous investment in
education and training not just at the research and academic health center level
but really at the level of community hospitals and individual healthcare providers
and practices. There are some similarities here with the issue of overuse but we
need a similar strategy around training and education at the front line level and

where do you see this and how do you see this being incorporated into training in
practice of the next generation as well as the current one.

Rosemary Gibson: Oh it's a great question. Well first of all I think we need some
good research and let me tell you the listeners about this extraordinary story that
came out in New England Journal of Medicine it was done very recently at the
Massachusetts General Hospital. These were patients with metastatic lung
cancer. And there were two groups of people those who had regular oncology
care and those who had regular oncology care but also early palliative care, early
attention to their symptoms, expression of their wishes for care and also they had
less aggressive treatment. It turns out that the people who have less aggressive
care and early palliative care these are people with metastatic lung cancer. They
lived nearly three months longer than those people who have standard oncology
care. In other words on the flip side of it as those of it on standard oncology care
they died sooner. What we need is more research that points out the harm from
overuse. Not just in this arena but in other aspects whether it's back surgery and
there have been some studies coming out on that but how to change culture. I
think we are going to need to have some and Medicare started to this with some
performance measures for overusing diagnostic imaging like CT scans and we
saw that new NCI study came out showing that that’s causing 29,000 excess
cancers a year just from the overuse of CT scans and the estimate 15000
deaths. So I think we need a combination of strategies of education and training
it's informing the public through getting these stories out in the media through the
Associated Press picked up by newspapers around the country and also we
need to share decision making. All of these components are needed to begin to
change the system. That’s all we did with patient safety in Wall of Silence that I
did on putting a human face on adverse events we began to make progress on
patient safety through all of those means educating the public, engaging the
media and educating and training physicians and nurses and other healthcare
professionals and patient safety.

Mark Masselli: Rosemary when you look around the country and the world what
you see in terms of innovation and who should our listeners at Conversations on
Healthcare be keeping an eye on?

Respondent: Well I am excited about the role of nurse practitioners going
forward. I think they have the power to transform healthcare and to bring sort of
the commonsense approach to it particularly in primary care. I think it is going to
be a wonderful thing. There are fewer and fewer physicians going into primary
care and that opens up the opportunity for nurse practitioners to come in and do
what they are trained well to do to provide high quality care to the people. What I
am intrigued by also is the role of thoughtful consumers who are beginning to
change things. I look at the StopHospitalInfections.org campaign led by
Consumers Union their Safe Patient Project. I believe that that campaign started
in 2004 has been the key factor that has put hospital infections out there as a
public issue, call for public reporting and accountability and led to Secretary

Sebelius saying we need about a 30% reduction by 2015 or so in hospital
acquired infections. That’s a great thing but that only happened because the
public organized a push forward. I don’t think the change can come from within
healthcare. It has to come externally, the pressure as Issac Newton said an
object at rest, remains at rest until an external force is applied that’s what
healthcare needs today. And that’s what we try to say in The Treatment Trap.

Margaret Flinter: Today we have been speaking with Rosemary Gibson, national
leader in patient safety and healthcare quality and author of the book The
Treatment Trap, How The Overuse Of Medical Care Is Reckoning Your Health
And What You Can Do To Prevent It. Rosemary, thank you so much for joining
us on Conversations today.

Rosemary Gibson: Oh thank you so much let me say Treatment Trap we donate
proceeds to patient groups because it’s the right thing to do and the book is
available on Amazon.

Mark Masselli: Each week Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities in everyday lives.

Margaret Flinter: This week’s bright idea focuses on a Sacramento, California
program. It’s bringing together doctors and high school students to learn about
Culturally Competent Healthcare. The cultural awareness in community health
education Outreach Project is a partnership between Kaiser Permanente and
students in Valley High Schools, Health TECH Academy. The goals are twofold
educating physicians about cultures impact on healthcare and healthcare
delivery, but also increasing the local community’s access to culturally specific
medical information. Kaiser Permanente physicians meet with Health TECH
Academy students every month providing support and information while the
students themselves develop community presentations on a whole variety of
culturally specific medical problems. This year students were divided into five
groups, Mong, African American, Filipino and Latino. One of their first tasks
involved a community survey. Based on their findings about their own
community’s common healthcare problems and prevailing attitudes towards
healthcare each group then chose a specific topic to research. For example one
of the Latino groups is studying diabetes, a disease that affected many of their
relatives. In addition to giving students first hand experience for searching
community health problems and recommending changes, the program also
provides local community members with healthcare information in a uniquely
accessible way. At the end of the school year students will deliver their
presentations in a variety of community settings including town hall meetings and
health fairs. Well equipped with a year’s worth of research they will also share
what they have learned in more informal setting like at the family dinner table or
in the car while driving with their parents. Community members will learn from
young people who they know and trust and who are often better than physicians
at presenting complex medical information and at the same time doctors will

learn from students about how to provide better and more culturally competent
healthcare. Now that’s a bright idea.
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Healthcare. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Messalli: I am Mark Messalli, peace and health.
Conversations on Healthcare, broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan University
at WESU, streaming live at Wesufm.org and brought to you by the Community
Health Center.