Dr. Lucian Leape, a leading figure in the modern patient safety movement.
The latest episode of Conversations on Health Care is now up on the CHCRadio website and on iTunes. You can listen this afternoon on WESU in Middletown, CT and on other radio stations over the coming week.
I am also posting the information here for people who want to subscribe to an RSS feed of the show or listen to it with other podcast clients.
Conversations on Health Care focuses this week on patient safety – how far we’ve come and what still needs to be covered. Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Dr. Lucian Leape, one of the country’s leading figures in patient safety whose body of work includes the landmark Institute of Medicine report “To Err is Human.” Dr. Leape currently chairs the Lucian Leape Institute at the National Patient Safety Foundation and teaches at the Harvard School of Public Health.
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: Margaret, it's April and Congress still hasn’t resolved last year’s
budget and another deadline looms large and the political process in Washington
has swung at a high gear over which program should be cut and to what extent,
and there is uncertainty at this point is to whether democrats and republicans can
come to an agreement on funding the government. President Obama has called
the housing senate leaders into the White House trying to avert a government
shutdown. And then again, we are looking forward to the 2012 budget battle and
it's kicked off this week, the GOP Budget Committee Chair, Paul Ryan has
proposed a rather ambitious plan, which he claims to save 2.2 trillion from health
care over the next decade.
Margaret Flinter: Well Mark, that certainly was a headline grabbing figure, 2.2
trillion from health care over the next decade is certainly very substantial. And of
course, it was inevitable that some of those savings would come from repealing
the Affordable Care Act. The Congressman Ryan and his committee estimate
that that would save $1.5 trillion and certainly be consistent with what the
majority party hits said they wanted to do.
Mark Masselli: Well, these are numbing figures, and there is going to be a lot of
reconciliation of these numbers, and burning of the midnight oil is going to be a
happening at the Congressional budget office, because you remember Margaret,
under the Affordable Care Act, they actually said that we would save $210 billion
over the next 10 years.
Margaret Flinter: That’s right. And the plan has been put forth as we understand
that also cost for Medical Malpractice Reforms with the projection that that would
save $43 billion, and you remember that a lot of people didn’t feel the Affordable
Care Act went far enough to introduce Medical Malpractice Reforms to the
system. But the real surprise to me anyway called for major changes to
Medicare which I thought was the third rail and nobody would touch it.
Mark Masselli: Well, there have been a lot of private groups who have been
saying that the Congress needed to stand up and address these issues.
Certainly, representative Ryan has in his proposal whether or not it is against
traction or one of the items is that he wants to increase Medicare eligibility and
raise the age level to 67 years of age.
Margaret Flinter: That’s right, which tells us that we should enjoy what we are
doing because we are going to do it for a long time, and he has put forth the plan
to privatize Medicare for those 55 and younger starting in 2021, so really this
affects the next generation of seniors more than today’s. It would call for
premium support in which the government would pay only 8% of the Children
Insurance Premium for seniors with more help for low income and sicker people.
And just like private insurance works today, if you want better coverage or more
comprehensive coverage, you could kick in some more money.
Mark Masselli: Here at Conversations on Health, we will be keeping an eye on
representative Ryan’s proposal and the entire 2012 budget process as it impacts
health reform. Clearly, one of the issues in terms of saving money will be the
conversations that are going around the country about improving patient safety
and effectiveness.
Margaret Flinter: That’s right. Patient Safety saves lives and saves money, and
today’s guest is a national expert in that field. Dr. Lucian Leape is internationally
recognizes for his efforts in advance in patient safety. He is known as the Father
of the modern Patient Safety Movement and his body of work includes the
landmark 1999 Institute of Medicine Study, To Err Is Human, which prompted the
medical community and legislators to find ways to improve patient safety. We are
so happy Dr. Leape can join us today.
Margaret Flinter: But no matter what the story, you can hear all of our shows on
our website Chcradio.com . You can subscribe to iTunes to get our show
regularly downloaded or if you would like to hang onto our every word and read a
transcript of one of our shows, come visit us at Chcradio.com . If you are social
media aficionado, you can become a fan of Conservations on Health Care on
Facebook, and follow us on Twitter.
Mark Masselli: And don’t forget, if you have feedback, email us at Chcradio.com .
We would love to hear from you. Now, before we speak with Dr. Leape, let's
check in with our producer Loren Bonner for the Headline News.
Loren Bonner: I am Loren Bonner with this week’s Headline News. House
Budget Committee Chair Paul Ryan’s 10 year budget blueprint has been officially
released. The proposal is designed to Reign in Medicare and Medicaid
Spending while squeezing trillions of dollars from the nation’s deficit. The plan
makes fundamental changes to Medicare by converting the entitlement program
for the elderly into a premium support program where the government would
spend a specific amount for beneficiary’s care. Congressman Tom Price from
Georgia spoke at the unveiling and said “In addition to changing Medicare, the
proposal would also repeal President Obama’s healthcare overhaul.”
Tom Price: This budget repeals and refunds the government takeover of
healthcare so that we can advance patient-centered health reforms, and this
budget reflects an honest assessment about the current unsustainable trajectory
of Medicare and save the program for future generation.
Loren Bonner: The republicans’ 2012 budget proposal stands little chance of
becoming law since it would have to be approved by the democratic control
senate and signed by President Obama. The senate has voted to repeal the
unpopular tax-reporting requirement in the Health Care Law widely referred to as
the 1099 Provision. The measure had few backers from either party, yet a
month’s long battle ensued over how the repeal would be paid for. The measure
now goes to the president who is expected to sign it. The much anticipated
Accountable Care Organization or ACO rules for Medicare have been released
by CMS. The Medicare shared savings program as it’s officially known would
allow providers to band together as ACO starting in January of 2012. The ACOs
create an incentive for healthcare providers to band together and form a network
to coordinate Medicare patients’ care with the end result being improved quality
of care and cost savings. The 429 page proposed rule is just a draft that now
enters a 60-day comment period for the public and interested parties to way in.
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. Today, we are speaking
with Dr. Lucian Leape, one of the nations leading figures in patient safety, widely
known as the father of modern patient safety movement in this country. Dr.
Leape is currently Adjunct Professor of Health Policy in Harvard School of Public
Health and Chair of the Lucian Leape Institute at The National Patient Safety
Foundation. Welcome Dr. Leape, begin your career in pediatric surgery and
came to health policy later in life. You credit Dr. Howard Hiatt, pioneer in patient
safety must widely known for his work on the Harvard Medical Practice Study
with guiding you in this direction. What were your early years like when you
began in this field and what else has influenced your work?
Dr. Lucian Leape: I spent 25 years as an academic pediatric surgeon and
decided going to health policy work and Dr. Hiatt invited me to join the just
beginning medical practice study, so this is a very different experience for me.
This was a big population based record review study, we looked at 30,000 patient
records in hospitals in New York state and what really struck me after we had
done all the work and got the data and analyzed it, were two things, one is the
extent of the injury of patient harm from treatment was much greater than I had
ever realized as a practitioner. You know you don’t see these things very often in
your everyday practice, but when we you know looked at overall a large sample
patients it turned out at one in 25 or 4% had an injury, but what really struck me
was that two thirds of those seem to be due to errors which we could tell just
looking at the records, so I was certainly impressed with the fact this was a much
bigger problem I had ever realized before.
Margaret Flinter: Dr. Leape in reading some of your work, I can see your real
interest in passion for changing the culture for one of the shame and blame as it
sometimes called to looking at the breaks and complex systems that really lead
almost inevitably to the error happening. Could you tell us a little more about
how systems theory works in healthcare when you apply it to this issue of patient
safety?
Dr. Lucian Leape: Sure, this is really the driving concept behind the patient
safety movement. I referred it was a transforming concept, the idea that people
make mistakes was not because they are bad people, it is because they are in a
bad system and this was brand new to us background of 15 years ago, because
we had all been trained in medical school and same for nurses in nursing school
that if you, you know learn your lessons, do your homework, and keep up and
are careful you would not mistakes. When it turns out, you have to do all that but
that doesn’t keep you from making mistakes, and so there was a whole and
immense body of knowledge regarding psychology, human factors engineering,
and that sort of thing about the fact that errors are induced. They are caused by
defects in the system and the corollary of that _____ 9:33 is the point is that you
can change the system, you can change the processes of work to make them
much less error prone to make is much less likely that you will make a mistake
and that’s the concept behind the systems change that is as Don Berwick like to
say every system is precisely designed to produce exactly the result it gets, so if
you don’t like the results in this case harm the patients then change the system.
I often think that’s true, I mean you know people say that that’s extreme and
always still human factor and there certainly is, and we do have problems with
people who have not kept up or have conferencing problems, but those are
systems problems too, what's the system you have or making sure that people
who are properly trained and are maintaining their skills and so forth so, this idea
that if you want to improve an outcome, look to the process is very fundamental
for safety and for all of quality improvement and has really proved to be very
useful, I mean it works, we do it and it makes a difference.
Mark Masselli: Speaking with Dr. Berwick, you are a member of the Institute of
Medicines Quality of Care in American Community, you helped write the famous,
To Err Is Human in 1999 which stated that medical errors kill up to 99,000
patients per year and that prompted the medical community and law makers to
find ways to improve patient care, and a few years later in 2001, the IOM
published crossing the quality chasm which offered a set of performance
expectations for the 21st century health care system, what some of the areas
you have seen progress in patient safety since the called action became more
widely adopted.
Dr. Lucian Leape: Well, in several areas that we have seen substantial strides,
the first thing that comes to mind is medication use. We prescribe three and a
half billion prescriptions a year in America and doctors make mistakes and
pharmacist make mistakes and nurses make mistakes, patients make mistakes
in using medicine and so there is tremendous amount of attention to go to some
of our first studies, the first study we did to try to see if this systems theory work
was on medication systems and so there has been a lot of work on improving
medication systems Simple thing we did which now must be almost ten years
ago was to remove hazard destructs from the unit as medicines that if you
accidentally gave him would be fatal, and you have them done in the pharmacy
where they can mix them and take care of them. So medication safety has been
one area, another has been we had in our interest but a lot of other people as
well in computerizing patient records and computerizing the order system so that
you order a medication on a computer instead of writing prescription by hand.
This has immense potential to improve safety and it's just taking forever to get it
implemented, I mean finally the Obama administration appropriated $30 billion to
move electronic medical records into doctor’s offices. I think the other areas
where we have become much better at, patient identification making sure we
have the right patient for the procedure, the medicine, or whatever. You went to
hospital now and it seems everybody is asking you your name and your birth
date, but that’s good, that’s a good thing and so it's a nuisance but it's a good
thing. And then it has been a lot of attention in the last few years on preventing
infections. Infections are one of the most common types of adverse events and
infections are one of the big ones, and we have had a lot of improvement in that
area as bloodstream infections, pneumonia, surgical infections, etc. So, I think
it's been a lot of good work and a lot of improvement, not nearly enough though, I
mean we still have a long way to go.
Margaret Flinter: Dr. Leape many institutions certainly like the Institute of
Medicine and your own Institute, The Lucian Leape Institute at the National
Patient Safety Foundation are hard at work on this issue of advancing patient
safety, and there are also the very well known to those best in healthcare
anyway, figures like Dr. Peter Pronovost, who has been a guest on our show,
who created a really a breakthrough but very simple intervention using the
checklist to reduce those central line catheters that you were speaking about a
moment ago and I remember when we spoke with Dr. Pronovost, the good news
was that hospitals that had rigorously adopted this had reduced their central line
infections down to near zero and the bad news was that not every hospital had
adopter, was seem to be so obviously, and effective interventions, so guess my
question is has patient safety, at the hospital level or large healthcare
organization level moved into the executive suite, the corporate suite, the board
suite or is it off still on a sideline in quality. Would a board of directors expect
your reports on errors in patient safety the same way they would on the financials
of the institution these days.
Dr. Lucian Leape: That’s a great question and I take it too hard because I
happen to sit on the board of directors of hospital and I am sort of the local
knowledge about this, but the short answer is not enough. And first problem is
get back and say I think Peter Pronovost work has been absolutely path
breaking. It was the first demonstration that you could completely eliminate a
certain type of adverse event, but _____15:29 people always said well you can
reduce them, and if you do a better job we will have few of them. And the whole
idea and safety of course is to have none. Peter’s work particularly in Michigan
where he had got them to implement the protocol for preventing central line
infections and also a protocol for preventing pneumonias and people who are on
ventilators, and he had 68 hospitals that went six months without a single
episode of central line infection and without a single episode of ventilator-
associated pneumonia, that alone with those hospitals saved over 1500 lives,
and so I am just, you know I cannot speak too hardly about Peter’s work. I am
glad you had him on your show because it really changed the conversation about
the improvement to eliminating adverse events. The problem is that most
hospitals still are on board, and if you look at the healthcare systems that have
really, really made great strides in safety, and I think of Virginia Mason Medical
Center in Seattle and Cincinnati Children’s, and I think Geisinger in Pennsylvania
and some other hospitals that have made a big difference, all those would have
the full support of the board as well as the leadership of the CEO, the question
for those ways of working is how would every hospital do that and we haven’t
figured that out yet.
Mark Masselli: This is conversations in Healthcare today we are speaking with
Dr. Lucian Leape one of the nations leading figures in patient safety. We will pull
the thread a little more on the mandatory reporting, which is mostly bit in the
purview of the state. Do you think there is a need for a federal system of
regulation, talk to us a little bit about the role Medicare might play or should it be
left up to the states and hospitals and along these same lines what can
regulators do to learn from various states and encourage safety and quality and
innovation.
Dr. Lucian Leape: Well I think that last question is the important one and that is
one why report and what does it have to do with safety, but lets start with the fact
and that is it’s only half of the states require reporting. So if you say you think
this is essential, it's quite evident that leaving it to the states doesn’t do the job,
and that’s an argument some people have used for a national system. But the
important questions what are we trying to accomplish when you look at the state
reporting systems and some of them are very impressive, I think Pennsylvania
has an outstanding system, for example. They get 10’s of 1000’s of report, and
so if we were to have a national reporting system we would get, you know, over a
million reports a year. And as soon as you say that you would then can
immediately understand that the obvious question which is, how do you process
that? The only reason to report is that you can learn from it and make changes
to prevent something from happening again and _____ 18: 32 to be of value they
have to do an investigation to try to understand what went wrong and try to figure
out what might be done about it. Without that kind of investigation which, a term
we use as root cause analysis really trying to understand where the system
broke down. Remember it's not bad people it's bad systems, okay what were the
bad systems? And so that takes time, money, expertise, etc. Without that, all
you are doing is getting account. You can say at the end of year well we had,
you know, 5,000 falls and well that’s nice to know but now what. So meaningful
reporting requires meaningful analysis that has to be done at the place where the
injury occurs, has to be done in a sophisticated way, and then information that
collected and put together. This is a huge job. What we really should do though
is have a better way of sharing those learning.
Margaret Flinter: And I couldn't agree with you more about the value of those
root cause analysis and primary care outside of the hospitals as well as in
hospitals. Now your institute has identified six areas of focus that require system
level attention if we are going to move this national patient safety agenda forward
and for our listeners, I want to go through them for a moment. They include
medical education reform and by that I assume to meet all health professionals
educational reform, engaging consumers transparency, integrating care, the
safety of the healthcare workforce itself and also the restoration of joy and
meaning in work. And that last one the restoration of joy and meaning and work
really stands out to us, it's so rarely discussed in healthcare. We certainly talk
about it in primary care as fundamental to maintaining that vitality and energy
and compassion over many, many years of caring for patients. But perhaps you
could elucidate the relationship as you see it between patient safety and
restoring joy and meaning in workforce.
Dr. Lucian Leape: We have been talking about burnout in nurses and doctors.
We have been talking about doctors retiring or only nurses quitting, and etc. And
in too many of our healthcare institutions we have a toxic environment and it's
just has grown that way. We sort of haven’t changed the way we practice in 50
years in the fundamental sense, but medicine has changed dramatically, and as
a result puts tremendous strain on people, and so our hierarchy to nature of
healthcare where, you know what the doctor says goes that doesn’t fit anymore.
The big lesson over the ast 10 years in patient safety is it's not enough to have
good safe practices, it's not enough to have checklist, it's not the checklist that
makes patient safe, it's the team work that it takes to put the checklist in place,
it's the team work it takes to implement the safe practices, and team work is
almost a foreign language in healthcare. We don’t run at medical school. It's fair
to say in many if not most hospitals we don’t have the kind of collegial team
collaborative working arrangement that’s essential. And as a result the
physicians and the nurses and everybody are under increasing strain and it has
literally suck the joy and meaning from their work. We think it's an absolutely
critical thing. We have already had one roundtable on this, we are going to have
another and we will be publishing a whitepaper with some very specific
recommendations, which I am hoping will address this.
Mark Masselli: Dr. Leape we would like all of our guests this question when you
look around the country and world what do you see in terms of innovation and
who should our listeners at conversations be keeping an eye on?
Dr. Lucian Leape: Well it's interesting because innovation is almost has to be the
daily work in quality improvement and safety, that is healthcare workers need to
address specific problems they surface in their work and then develop an
innovative solution for it. Massachusetts has a mandatory reporting system for
serious reportable events and they report the results once a year and you know
at the number one adverse events in hospitals by far falls people falling out. Well
we got to be able to prevent that and so there is a lot of work given to that and I
think there is some innovative thinking there. And of course when technology
marches ahead, you know, full steam, I mean you know I was a surgeon for 25
years, but I made incisions on people and sew them up. They don’t do that
anymore, they operate through these little tiny scopes and with robots and so
nobody can predict where that’s going to take us except it does post new
problems for safety that we have to address.
Margaret Flinter: Today we have been speaking with Dr. Dr. Lucian Leape one of
the nation’s leading figures in patient safety. Dr. Leape thank you so much for
joining us today on conversations.
Dr. Lucian Leape: My pleasure thank you for having me.
Mark Masselli: Each week, Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives.
Margaret Flinter: This week’s bright idea focuses on a program that improves the
way asthma is managed in children. The Cambridge Health Alliance and
Integrated Healthcare System in Massachusetts wanted to take a more proactive
approach to reducing the number of children who use the hospital emergency
department for asthma-related treatment as is the case around the country
asthma is one of the leading causes of ER visits for children, particularly low
income children, and one of the major reasons for miss days of school, and
certainly the data shows that with better management, these consequences can
be prevented. But at the most fundamental level, the Alliance’s Childhood
Asthma Program is a community based model of care, teams of community
health workers with registered nurses make home visits to help parents reduce or
eliminate some of the asthma triggers. They outline an individual asthma action
plan with regular steps to prevent or treat asthma attacks and another key
element is the patient registry so that the child’s asthma information is available
whenever he or she enters the healthcare system, be it the primacy care office,
the school health center or the emergency room. The asthma program has
dramatically reduced hospitalizations and ER visits for children in Cambridge,
annual asthma related emergency visits fell 50% from 2002 to 2009 for children
enrolled in the program. An approach to pediatric asthma management that’s
moving away from reactive treatment to aggressive daily management through
an integrated system of care that includes every place, the home, the office, the
school now that’s a bright idea. This is Conversations on Health Care, I am
Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan
University at WESU, streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.