David Wessel, economics editor of the Wall Street Journal

Last Sunday, WNPR in Connecticut joined the family of stations carrying Conversations on Health Care.  The show continues to air on numerous other stations and be available on the CHCRadio website and iTunes.  I will continue to post new shows here for people wishing to use other podcasting clients.  The URL for the Podcast feed is http://community.chc1.com/category/chcradio/feed/

This week, Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with David Wessel, economics editor of the Wall Street Journal. He’ll give us his perspective on the economy and the forces that are shaping health care and living standards around the world.

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.

Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.

Mark Masselli: Well, Margaret, summer is officially here. School year is ending.
People are planning their vacation. Perhaps again, this year, they would call
staycationsm, and there is lots to do around every state and always work to do
around the house.

Margaret Flinter: Well, we wish a wonderful summer to everybody. The solstice
was last night, the longest day of the year, which is my personal favorite, and
hopefully it will be healthy and safe summer for everybody.

Mark Masselli: Well, I hope the weather is better than it's been this spring.
There are lots of natural disasters happening all over the country. A bad weather
is not partitioned. And interestingly, wherever it happens, state governors are out
there asking the Federal Government to help them out with the disaster. And yet,
at the same time, our country faces a large budget deficit, and there is still the
standoff going on about the debt limits. We will see how that plays out.

Margaret Flinter: You could say sometimes there is a love/hate relationship
between the states and the government, but we are glad for all those
communities in need that there is help, God knows, they needed.

Mark Masselli: Absolutely.

Margaret Flinter: And there is plenty of pasturing around the need increasing the
government’s borrowing limit, and negotiations are continuing overspending
reductions that are tied to raising the borrowing limit. Lawmakers from both sides
are trying to come to some agreement on how to save $4 trillion over the next
decade, and it's the big ticket items to continue to divide Republicans and
Democrats and certainly those in food whether to increase tax revenues and
making substantive changes to entitlement programs like Medicare and
Medicaid.

Mark Masselli: Well, those changes in Medicaid and Medicare are likely to be on
the table during discussions this week and probably for the next month into early
August. Reports are that both parties have made some concessions last week,
and House Budget Chairman Paul Ryan said he is open to keeping the traditional
Medicare as an option alongside private plans to his overhaul proposal. And
House Democrats have offered their solutions to preserving Medicare insolvency.

Margaret Flinter: Well, I continue to think that heat is going to be on the issue of
entitlements, and it was interesting to note that a Democratic support and survey
found that support for the Affordable Care Act, for the Health Reform Bill itself

has actually increased as a result of Ryan’s Medicare proposal, showing people
really do see how the two things affect each other.

Mark Masselli: Speaking of heat, the American Medical Association has been
tied up in debate, and they came out two-thirds of the membership voted in
support of the Affordable Care Act and in particular, the individual mandate. So
there is still strong support at one of the old established medical institutions.

Margaret Flinter: And we had their president many months ago, and I thought he
laid out some very reasons for why there is support for the Affordable Care Act.
And let’s see how far all of these ideas go and hear about some others from our
guest today, David Wessel. David Wessel is the Economics Editor for the Wall
Street Journal. He also writes the Capital column, a weekly look at the economy
and forces shaping living standards around the world. And we are delighted
David can join us today.

Mark Masselli: And we are also pleased to announce the Conversations on
Health Care is also airing on Connecticut Public Radio WNPR 90.5 on Sundays
at 4 p.m. Listeners in Connecticut, New York and Long Island, we look forward to
learning more about you when you call us up and ask us questions about
Conversations, and we are excited to be with them.

Margaret Flinter: And for our new listeners as well as our established listeners,
as always, you can hear all of our shows on our website Chcradio.com .
Subscribe to iTunes to get the show downloaded. Or if you want to hang onto
our every word and read the transcript, come visit us at Chcradio.com . And don’t
forget, you can become a fan of Conservations on Health Care on Facebook and
follow us on Twitter.

Mark Masselli: If you have feedback, email us at Chcradio.com , we would love to
hear from you. And before we speak with David Wessel, let’s check in with our
producer Loren Bonner with Headline News.

Loren Bonner: I am Loren Bonner with this week’s Headline News. The
Department of Health has unveiled its new warning labels for cigarette packs. As
part of Tobacco Control Act, these new labels are meant to be more graphic and
more prominent. The department chose nine color images among those
proposed, some more graphic than others. For example, one label will depict the
man exhaling smoke through a tracheotomy opening in his neck. The new labels
will also occupy 50% of cigarette packs. Dr. Margaret Hamburg, Commissioner
of the Food and Drug Administration says, “The labels are just the first step and
an expanded effort to further decrease U.S. smoking rates.”

Dr. Margaret Hamburg: We also are involved in helping to support new products
in innovation in terms of pharmaceutical interventions to help people to stop
smoking.

Loren Bonner: All cigarette packs will also contain a toll free telephone number
for quit smoking services. This is the first major change to cigarette warning
labels on packaging in more than a quarter of a century.

In the separate announcement, Department of Health Officials unveiled the
National Prevention Strategy, a plan to get all government departments and
sectors of society on board to help Americans lead healthier lives. U.S. Surgeon
General Dr. Regina Benjamin outlined the strategic directions for the plan. They
include healthy and safe community environments, clinical and community
preventive services, empowering people and eliminating health disparities. And
like the Healthy People program which comes out every 10 years, the National
Prevention Council will issue yearly reports to the President and Congress.

States are coming to terms with the fact that crucial federal funds for Medicaid
will run out this month. The Obama Administration injected more than $90 billion
into state Medicaid programs during the height of the recession. But two years
later, the number of beneficiaries is higher now than when Congress approved
the aid as part of an economic recovery package. As a result, many states are
cutting Medicaid payments to doctors and hospitals, limiting benefits for Medicaid
recipients and increasing their co-pays, as well as reducing the scope of
coverage services.

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. Today, we are speaking
with David Wessel, Economics Editor of the Wall Street Journal. Welcome,
David.

David Wessel: Thank you.

Mark Masselli: David, reducing the federal debt has become a dominant theme
in the political discourse. And at the same time, as state governments are
struggling to balance their budgets, there are other deficits like the trade deficits
that are some are concerned with. Health care spending though is the significant
part of the economy. Can you lay out for us the relationship between health care
spending and the larger economic picture?

David Wessel: Well, we are spending an ever greater percentage of our income,
whether as a country or as companies or as individuals on health care. And on
one hand, you can look at that as a good thing that because we have become
richer over the decades, we don’t have to spend all of our money on food and
shelter and clothing. We have money left over for other things. And in America,
we seem to have a taste for buying more health care.

So it's also true that we are able to do things that we never did before, save lives
whether it's preemies who are born and weigh three pounds or less or helping
older people live a higher quality life in the last decade of life so we could do hip

replacements or bypass surgery and stuff like that. So I think it's important to
remember that it's not all bad. But the problem is we all seem to get our moneys
worth, and it's eating a lot of our resources and making it impossible for the
governments in particular, both state and federal governments, to spend money
on other things that might be more productive in the long run.

Margaret Flinter: David, it's easy to get caught up in the U.S. health care issues
for sure, but we would like to take a look at the larger world frame. We often hear
two different things. One, in the U.S., we pay more for less in terms of access
and health outcomes but, two, the U.S. health care is the best in the world, bar
none. And sometimes they translate that to “it's great for individuals, not so great
for the total population.” But how is U.S. health care spending and the return on
that investment compared with other industrialized nations? Are they seeing the
same issue of rising costs and what are they doing about it?

David Wessel: I think the answer to that is yes and no. On one hand, we do
seem to spend a lot of money. And when you look at the overall measures of
health, whether it’s infant mortality or lifespan, we don’t seem to look better than
other countries who spend a lot less. On the other hand, I think we know that if
you have some advanced and bizarre illness, the chances of getting really state-
of-the-art care in the United States, particularly if you have insurance, are better
than anywhere else, whether it’s heart-lung transplant or the latest cancer
treatment. I mean I don’t think those are mutually inconclusive. I think that at the
frontiers of medicine, we have the best medicine in the world. But as a society,
we haven't found a way to care for everybody in the society despite the efforts of
people like Community Health Center in Middletown.

I think that the other question, though, is that there are things which are driving
up health care costs which we have in common with other countries. One is, as
older our population gets, the more old people, the more expensive health care is
because old people use more health care than young people, and that’s the fact,
and you are seeing that in Europe and Japan and Canada. And secondly, the
ability of technology to – the advances in technology make it possible for us to do
things that we never thought doing before, and they tend to be expensive. So
these twin drivers of aging societies and technology opening up new avenues for
health care are driving up costs in other countries as well.

Mark Masselli: David, let me bring it back to our shores that Republican Party
seems to be very committed to redefine the role the Federal Government plays in
health care. There is a lot of talk about privatizing Medicare, Block-Granting
Medicated States and repealing the Affordable Care Act. I think we have a good
handle on the business community, which is often perceived as aligned with the
Republican Party. Tell us about what the business community is thinking on
Healthcare Reform.

David Wessel: If you have teenagers and someone says to me, “Tell me exactly
how it is that your teenager is thinking about (inaudible 10:49), I kind of feel like
(inaudible).” I think that the business community is not of one mind. As you
probably know, I wrote a column pointing out that I think for big employers
repealing the Obama Healthcare Bill is idiocy, and I think a lot of them know it.
It’s not that they like every part of it but the alternative which is to go back to the
status quo without much hope of controlling cost or insuring the uninsured is
worse.

I think big companies are, in some cases, frustrated that even if you have 10,000
or 20,000 workers, you can't deal with the health care costs and quality problem
because you are not big enough. And so some of them think about some global
solution, meaning – not really global – but national solution which simplifies
things. But other businessmen are just kind of stubbornly think that if the
government would just get out of their hair, they could do a better job of doing it,
and some of them have experimented with interesting things.

I think that the difference between what you hear from the Republicans in
Washington and businessmen often boils down to who were we talking about
here. The Republicans in Washington are very interested in the Federal
Government spending less on health care and finding ways to do that, in many
cases by shifting the cost more to individuals on the theory if the individual is
spending their money, they will be wiser shoppers, and it will function like a
textbook market.

And I think a lot of businesspeople say, “Oh my God, we saw that before. The
government spends less, and it just gets passed onto the people who have
insurance. And we and our employees are going to pay more.” So I think they
are very suspicious quietly, privately about things that they think will end up
adding to their cost rather than reducing the national.

Margaret Flinter: David, subject that you have written about that we now hear so
much about is the role in the importance of clinical and basic science research
spending in health care, you have actually framed that up from both the
Republican and Democratic point of view, what are some of the implications of
this research for national economy, the health care system and really ultimately
for the nation’s health?

David Wessel: Well, I sometimes joke – and I do made a joke – as if we want to
slow health care cost growth, why don’t we spend so much money on the
National Institutes of Health inventing more ways to treat people and come up
with the cure. I mean there is a bit of contradiction there. I think that the debate
in Washington over government spending is sometimes mindless because it sort
of – one group of people says every dollar the government spends is a waste,
and other people say every dollar the government spends is making someone’s
life better, and we know that neither one of those is true.

I have been intrigued by some Republicans, including the infamous Newt
Gingrich, who have made the case that starving research and basic science is a
huge mistake, and we will pay a price in the future if we don’t continue to spend
it. That is that the basic research at any market economy is always going to have
to be funded by the government or subsidized by the government because no
company is going to do it because the chances of making a profit on it are so
slim. ______ 14:02 takes along and stuff. Or if you invent something, basically
everybody else will share the benefits, and you won't be able to ______.

So there is a very straightforward, basic, conservative economic case for
government spending on clinical research and development and science and
stuff like that. And I actually think that that’s having some impact on Washington.
Now, my guess is that when they get done with this budget-cutting exercise, that
they won't have starved basic science as much as it looks like from the initial
proposals, partly for that reason.

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. Today, we are speaking
with David Wessel, Economics Editor of the Wall Street Journal. David, I want to
pull the thread a little long on that last comment because you wrote an article
about enormous value of broadening access to quality health care, both the
individuals and the entire society. And the study you cited, which was very
fascinating compared to the educational test scores of black teenagers from the
south in the 1980s to improved health care that they had received these infants
after southern hospitals were integrated in the ‘60s. And so you have sort of
clear evidence-based research that shows that by these transformations that we
can save costs and good outcomes. So I am not sure why a conservative
wouldn’t buy that or it is just this natural reluctance to really give the Federal
Government any more rope because they feel other things will happen – other
bad consequences will happen.

David Wessel: Well, that’s a really good question. I think that if you look at the
study you cited about what happened to these scores, high school performance
of kids when the hospitals are reintegrated is consistent with a lot of studies.
There is a famous work that was done about when they wiped out hookworm in
the south, and it turned out with that hookworm was really – and they tracked the
wages of people in communities that had wiped it out, and you could see that
they did better in life years later.

I think that it gets lost in a kind of cynicism and skepticism about the value of
government. And I don’t really know how to explain it. As I am sure, you will be
sharp to learn in Washington, not all debates are decided on the evidence, and
this may be one of them. I think that there is, and I think it’s gotten worse since
the financial crisis, that kind of sense that when government touches something,
they just grew it up so we ought to get the government out of the way. And we
know that we had a health care system that, with so many people uninsured, was

both wasteful because we were caring for them in other ways or starving us of
their future productivity of these people, yet that hasn’t convinced very many
people or hasn’t convinced a lot of people.

Margaret Flinter: David, as you know, we have been in the business of
organizing and delivering care by running a Community Health Center for nearly
40 years. That’s a system to provide quality primary care to what we call special
populations, the underserved and uninsured and others. And across the country,
the program serves 20 million Americans, and it’s a really unique bipartisan
support kind of amazing in this day and age in part because there is data to
share its high-quality care and cost-effective care, and there is an economic
impact of these organizations in community. So obviously, any major change to
Medicaid or repeal of the Affordable Care Act or any of that has an impact, but
we would be curious, what do you see organizations like health centers or
national programs like health centers fitting into the economic landscape in terms
of health care cost container or the potential to do that?

David Wessel: Well, I think you probably know more about that than I do. I think
that we know that one of the flaws in our health care system is the way we
deliver care and the push towards having more integrated health care where you
don’t have 15 doctors. Each of them is ordering the same test. We know that
most experts think we have to find some way to solve their problem, and I think
Community Health Centers are one place for those populations where people
have a chance of getting not lost in the system.

But look, I think we also know that it's a mistake to argue that everything we do in
providing access to people, all the preventive care, it's all going to pay for itself. I
think some of it’s not going to pay for itself but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t do
it. And I think that, in my opinion, the people who are hard on money for
Community Health Centers, it's incumbent on them to say well, where would
these people get care if it weren't for Community Health Centers, and what
makes you think it would be cheaper for the system if they did that, whether it's
emergency rooms or whatever. But I think it gets lost in the much bigger shifting
on the tectonic plates.

Mark Masselli: David, let’s talk about the politics of resolving our national debt
ceiling this summer. I guess it will make great reading next summer but it's sort
of a nail-biter now. And it appears that some in the Republican Party are willing
to stretch this out as long as possible in hopes of bringing about dramatic change
and certainly in the front of health care in Medicare and Medicaid policy. How do
you see this playing out? And I know there is a lot of energy that’s being brought
by new members. Do you think sort of at the end of the day that sort of senior
leadership from both sides will say, “Look at it, we have let this ______ 19:31 too
long. Now, it's going to be too hot to handle at the moment, and let’s wrap this up
sooner than later.”

David Wessel: I don’t know about the sooner or later part, but I think that in the
end, they will raise the federal debt ceiling. After all, it's not like- the federal debt
is a consequence of spending in tax decisions that they made in the past. It’s
kind of ridiculous to think if you didn’t raise the debt ceiling, somehow something
would change. I think it's much more a question about how specific will the
conditions be that are attached to the debt ceiling, and that’s really hard to guess
at this point. There is clearly a game of check in between the Democrats and the
administration and the Republicans. And nobody – I think it may take some
scare in the markets and the span the stock market is going ______ 20:24 before
some of these guys realize that this is not just an idle threat that if you let people
think that a country that borrows as much as we do might not pay its bills that you
could really hurt things.

I don’t think they are going to reform Medicare and Medicaid in the next two
months when they raise the debt ceiling. I think the much more likely thing is that
they come up with some sort of targets for savings and tax increases or
something or debt reduction, that they all agree on now and that the fight over
how to reshape Medicare and Medicaid is deferred till after the presidential
election in 2012.

Margaret Flinter: David, we would like to ask all of our guests this final question.
When you look around the country and the world, what do you see in terms of
innovation and who should our listeners at Conversations be keeping an eye on?

David Wessel: Well, I think that the good thing about the United States is that we
still seem to be the center of a certain kind of innovation, and that’s really
encouraging. I mean the iPad and the Kindle may not be made in the United
States but the idea for them was born in the United States. And Amazon is now
selling more books on the Kindle than in print. And I saw a little video the other
day of some guys coming up with a software app that allows you to – and this is
really important to book authors – to autograph a Kindle copy of the book. What
could be better than that, right?

Margaret Flinter: Perfect.

David Wessel: On the other hand, I worry sometimes that we are complacent.
The Chinese and the Indians and Brazilians are coming on strong. They have a
lot of smart people. They are investing a lot in the future. They have fast
growing economies that are attracting investments from American multinationals.
And I think the competition in innovation is going to get stiffer rather than easier.
And we have to really stay on top of our game, and that means everything from
making sure that all our people are well cared for in health care so they can work
productively and contribute to society rather than become dependent on it.

It means fixing our K-12 school, and it means making sure that you don’t have to
be rich and son of a Harvard alum to go to Harvard because we need to make

sure that the best of our educational institutions are open to the broadest number
of people. It means keeping our doors open to ambitious immigrants and all that
stuff. And I think sometimes some Americans take for granted that we are going
to be the most innovative society just because we have been. And I think that’s a
kind of mistake that leads to a declining society.

Mark Masselli: Today we have been speaking with David Wessel, Economics
Editor of the Wall Street Journal. David, thanks so much for joining us today.

David Wessel: Okay, my pleasure.

Margaret Flinter: Thank you.

Mark Masselli: Each week, Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities into everyday lives.

This week’s bright idea focuses on a unique partnership between chefs and local
schools that aims to make a lasting impact on the way kids, parents, teachers
think about nutrition. The Chefs Move to Schools program was launched by First
Lady Michelle Obama, Let’s Move campaign and the U.S. Department of
Agriculture last June as a call to action for chefs across the nation to join in on
the fight against childhood obesity. Healthy school meals are crucial to a child’s
wellness since nearly 31 million students participate in the National School Lunch
Program, and more than 11 million participate in the School Breakfast Program.
The Chefs Move to Schools program encourages chefs to volunteer their food
expertise so that schools can do a better job preparing food that are tasty and
nutritious.

Well, at the same time, being mindful of the schools’ regulatory, dietary guidelines
and budgets in addition to chefs working with schools to whip up healthier meals,
these chefs who range from local restaurant owners to contestants on the hit
reality show Iron Chef also conduct cooking classes on the weekend and help
cultivate school gardens. So far, more than 1,700 schools have signed up to
connect with a chef through the program. And as word spreads, many more will
follow. Using their leadership and expertise to inspire children to eat healthy
foods, chefs are making a lasting impact on the health of the next generation.
Now, that’s a bright idea.

Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.

Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli. Peace and health.

Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan
University at WESU, streaming live at Wesufm.org and brought to you by the
Community Health Center.