Carl Schmid, Deputy Executive Director of the AIDS Institute
This week, Mark and Margaret speak Carl Schmid, Deputy Executive Director of the AIDS Institute, and an AIDS policy analyst and activist. Mr. Schmid speaks with us from the recent AIDS 2012 Convention and talks about strides being made in containing the spread of HIV/AIDS as well as the hope for further progress towards ending the epidemic and improving the lives of those living with HIV in the U.S. and around the world
(Music)
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: Well Margaret, what a summer it's turning out to be, certainly one
of great achievement from the best and the brightest of our country.
Margaret Flinter: It has been Mark. And so many exciting contests at the
Olympics, shattering old records whether it’s Michael Phelps in the pool, or
Gabby Douglas in gymnastics, or maybe most of all, both of them working with
their teams certainly showed what talent and perseverance we possess as a
nation when we work hard and we work together, and just so exciting to see all
those young people succeeding.
Mark Masselli: And in the midst of all of that Margaret, we scored another
successful landing, the rover Curiosity landed safely on Mars last week.
Margaret Flinter: I heard about that. And although this is the seventh craft they
have landed on Mars, our closest neighboring planet, still gives us a bit of a thrill
Mark, just great to see advances in science and advances in being able to carry
out some new dreams and visions.
Mark Masselli: It's another great moment for science and exploration, and yet, it
reminds us of how many frontiers we have yet to explore and how much
teamwork is required to achieve all of these milestones.
Margaret Flinter: Well Mark, one challenging frontier here at home that’s been
out in front of us for decades is finding a cure for AIDS and ending AIDS for the
next generation. And our guest today spoke with us recently from the floor of the
AIDS 2012 Conference in Washington DC, where tens of thousands of AIDS
experts and activists came together to note the progress being made in the fight
against the AIDS epidemic, which to date has impacted over 60 million people
around the world.
Mark Masselli: Carl Schmid is the Director of the AIDS Institute and is a leading
AIDS policy analyst and advisor in this country and around the globe. He will be
talking about the real hope for a cure for AIDS in our lifetime, new treatments for
living with HIV and how the health reform law is going to help that population live
better and healthier lives.
Margaret Flinter: FactCheck.org’s Lori Robertson will look at some claims from
the campaign trail pertaining to the Affordable Care Act and see how they stack
up against reality.
Mark Masselli: But no matter what the topic, you can hear all of our shows by
Googling CHC Radio.
Margaret Flinter: And as always, if you have comments, email us at
www.chcradio.com or find us on Facebook on the Conversations on Health Care
Radio Show homepage. We love to hear from you.
Mark Masselli: We will get to our guest Carl Schmid in just a moment but first,
here is our producer Marianne O'Hare, with this week’s Headline News.
(Music)
Marianne O'Hare: I am Marianne O'Hare with this Headline News. The ticket is
named “And Up and Running”. Presumptive GOP Presidential Candidate Mitt
Romney has chosen his running mate. The choice of Congressman Paul Ryan,
Head of the Congressional Budget Committee is being hailed by Conservatives
who support his controversial budget proposals, which slashes trillions of dollars
in entitlement programs, and for suggesting that Medicare and Medicaid should
be phased out to a system of vouchers.
Democrats on the other hand are seeing this election as a rallying cry for those
who support the Health Care Law under the Obama Administration. Medicare as
well as the Affordable Care Act are sure to be central themes in this year’s
election. One measure of the health care law seeks to reduce the number of
costly hospital readmissions, one of the biggest drivers of health care costs with
over one in five Medicare beneficiaries being readmitted to hospital within 30
days of discharge. Over 2000 hospitals across the country are being penalized
by Medicare for not doing enough follow-up care with patients resulting in those
readmissions. The hospitals are balking at the penalties saying they could do
more harm to hospitals who likely could use resources to improve their follow-up
care protocols.
And where are kids getting fatter? Follow the snack policy it would seem. A
recent study out in the Journal of Pediatric shows a clear link between states with
and without policies governing snacks in schools, so-called competitive foods
that are not part of the school lunch program. Kids in states with strict school
snack policies for low fat, low sugar options and wending machines are leaner on
average than kids in states without those policies. Experts say this should be a
wakeup call to officials making policy with childhood obesity rates rising steadily
th
since 1980 in this country. 1/5 of child population in America is obese. I am
Marianne O'Hare with this Headline News.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: We are speaking today with Carl Schmid, Deputy Executive
Director of the AIDS Institute, a national non-profit organization that promotes
action for social change in HIV AIDS through public policy, research, advocacy
and education. Mr. Schmid was a member of the Presidential Advisory Council
on HIV/AIDS from 2007 to 2009, advising both the Bush and Obama
Administrations on policy initiatives to combat AIDS, was recently named by
several publications as one of the most effective AIDS policy activists in America.
Mr. Schmid, welcome to Conversations on Health Care.
Carl Schmid: It's great to be here and to be talking from the International AIDS
Conference.
Mark Masselli: You played a prominent role in the conference bringing together
25,000 top scientists, activists, policy leaders, Secretary Clinton is there, Bill
Gates, many more, really focusing on addressing the global epidemic of HIV and
AIDS. The theme of this year’s conference was Turning the Tide Together and
there was much talk about the end game of HIV/AIDS being within sight. We are
hearing through the news media that there are numerous breakthroughs in
drugs, in protocol, disease management and policy initiatives. Help us
understand the magnitude of the current state of the epidemic and where are the
key fronts in the battle against HIV/AIDS now in 2012.
Carl Schmid: Yeah. HIV has taken a huge toll on this world. 30 million people
have already died, there are several million new infections every year, and over
30 million people living with AIDS in world right now are mostly in Sub-Saharan
Africa. But here, in United States, there is an AIDS crisis as well. Over 1.2
million people living with HIV, that’s a record. More people are living with HIV
than ever before. And unfortunately, it's not on people’s minds anymore I guess
because people are living longer, people are no longer contracting the disease
and then being very ill and dying quickly within months. People are living with
HIV. When someone’s diagnosed with HIV today, they could live another 60, 70,
80 years almost normal lives. But they have to take medications everyday and
that’s one of the keys, making sure that we get those medications to people
because not everyone has that.
We also have 50,000 new infections every year in the United States, that’s
50,000 too many. I mean (06:52 inaudible) HIV, you can use condoms. That
may not work well with everyone so there are new prevention methods as well,
there are new scientific breakthroughs. But HIV predominantly in United States
affects the poor. Over 60%-70% of the cases are gay men and more and more
of them are Black gay men, are Latino gay men. And 39% of all the new
infections today are in people aged 29 and below. So it shows that we are not
getting the messages across particularly to our youth. And the other segment
that is most heavily impacted are African-Americans, around half of all infections,
even though 14% of the population is amongst the Black community. So that’s
what HIV looks like today 1.2 million people living with HIV but 50,000 new
infections every year and that’s been relatively constant.
Margaret Flinter: So Mr. Schmid, then I understand there are still thousands that
stay on wait list for drug assistance to be able to afford the drugs that they need
to control the disease and to help us with preventing further transmission. Tell us
about the role of health disparities and how they continue to pose a challenge to
those who are fighting HIV/AIDS and what's being done to address those
disparities.
Carl Schmid: HIV predominantly affects minority communities, gay men of all
races and ethnicities, the poor, the homeless. People don’t want to talk about
those issues. HIV is predominantly spread by sex and people don’t want to talk
about sex, particularly in more conservative parts of our country. So there are
wide disparities. I have been to a lot of sessions the last couple of days and
white, black gay men have the highest rates of infection in our country and a lot
of it has to do with education and poverty, huge disparities in HIV in our country.
Mark Masselli: Mr. Schmid, your organization’s been advocating for policy
changes in America and tell us about the national HIV/AIDS strategy you are
advocating for in Washington and could it lead to an end of the AIDS epidemic
here in America?
Carl Schmid: Well certainly, first of all the entry (09:09 inaudible). We had some
really arcane emotional response to HIV and AIDS. And one of those laws that
was put in effect was barring anyone who is HIV positive from coming to United
States. President Bush started the process and under his leadership, he got
Congress to go along, and he signed a law that lifted it but then there was still
administrative process, and that happened under President Obama
Administration. And we are able to have the conference here for the first time
bringing 30,000 people to United States to this conference from over 200
countries. You look back at AIDS over the last decade and President Bush really
showed great leadership with the creation of PEPFAR, the President’s
Emergency AIDS Relief Program, and changed the face of Africa and the
epidemic there.
But as I said, there is a great epidemic here in United States and President
Obama has really put the spotlight back on the domestic HIV crisis. Two years
ago actually, he released the National HIV/AIDS Strategy that has three main
goals. One is to reduce the number of infections, increase the number of people
who are getting treatment and three, reduce health disparities, as well as a
fourth, that seeks to bring better coordination between all the federal agencies
both at the federal level and at the state government to work better. Everyone’s
been siloed in the approach and he’s trying to get everyone to work together. So
in reducing new infections, the goal there is to help some of the communities that
are most impacted and making sure that there are prevention messages for
those communities and also making sure the money is spent in those areas, for
care and treatment and also I should say the President has shown great
leadership in his annual budget putting forth increases for HIV preventions.
Margaret Flinter: Mr. Schmid, as you talk about those policies of this
administration, your organization has also lauded the Affordable Care Act, which
you say is poised to make it possible for far more people who are HIV+ and
maybe don’t know it to get tested and to get into treatment. And of course there
is many provisions in the Affordable Care Act that will improve conditions for
those in the AIDS community as it will for anybody living with health problems
and chronic health conditions. But you have also expressed a worry about
existing programs like the Ryan White Program that most people are familiar with
and that could be jeopardized. Tell us how you see the Affordable Care Act both
improving outcomes and access for the HIV/AIDS population but also what are
the threats to dismantling some of the infrastructure that’s been successful in
helping us to deal with the epidemic?
Carl Schmid: The Affordable Care Act is really (11:55 inaudible) for HIV/AIDS
care in the country. So many people that don’t have health insurance today,
many of them are poor and also people with HIV have been discriminated
against because they have a preexisting condition. Now with the Affordable Care
Act, there is an end to a ban on people with preexisting conditions; that is no
longer a barrier. So people through the Medicaid expansion and through getting
health insurance, they can access health care for the first time. Right now, only
around 30% to 40% of people with HIV in United States are getting access to
care and treatment and only around 28% actually have a suppressed viral load,
that’s what the treatment (12:40 inaudible). So we have a long ways to go and
the Affordable Care Act is going to open up opportunities to provide drivers in
health care to many, many people with HIV.
Mark Masselli: We are speaking today with Carl Schmid, Deputy Executive
Director of the AIDS Institute. Mr. Schmid had a prominent role at the AIDS 2012
Summit. He has taken a few moments out from the conference to talk to us. Mr.
Schmid, it's irony that the conference was held in the nation’s capital, which
happens to be one of the highest HIV infection rates in the nation. You have
received accolades for your work in attempting to impact the population there.
Tell us about how you are taking ideas shared from the conference and applying
them to impact in local communities like the District of Columbia.
Carl Schmid: There is some reason why the conference came to Washington
DC. Not only is the US government the largest provider of AIDS relief abroad but
it's our nation’s capital and we do have a serious AIDS epidemics here. This
conference was in the works in last couple of years. They put pressure on the
US government but also the district government to get its act together. And I
think I really have to praise the local government here in addressing the AIDS
epidemic. There are leaders like Connecticut in providing (14:02 inaudible)
people with access to health care. They really are providing increased testing,
they even do testing in the Motor Vehicle Department here. But also there is
treatment immediately for people who test positive. So it helps the AIDS crisis
here and also just having the conference here and putting AIDS back on the front
page that helps raise people’s consciousness.
Margaret Flinter: Mr. Schmid, I would like to talk a little more about testing and
preventing transmission. You have praised the actions of Howard Koh at Health
and Human Services and when he called for HIV testing to be included in the 26
preventive screening tests required to achieve the goals set forth in the Healthy
People 2020 Initiative. And I think 200,000 Americans are reported to have HIV
infection and don’t know they have it so getting that testing is critical but lots of
barriers. You mentioned the Motor Vehicle Department has a place to do testing;
I know I am beginning to hear about over-the-counter testing incentives. Tell us
what's the strategy and what are the recommended key elements from your
organization’s point of view, what are you advocating.
Carl Schmid: The CTC came out with recommendation several years ago that
said that everyone between the ages of 16 and 64 should receive a HIV test
when they go to the doctor. You go to the doctor, you get your blood pressure,
you get your temperature taken and they check for your cholesterol. Well they
should be testing for HIV as well. There are certain populations that are rated at-
risk for HIV. But there are a lot of people that don’t know they are at risk for HIV,
particularly women and who is to know who is at risk and who is not. So it's
really important that everyone in their lifetime gets an HIV test. But certain
people should be getting that more often. But number one, we need to make
sure doctors offer the test and that’s not happening. So we need to increase
those efforts . So, anyone when they go into a doctor’s office, the doctor should
say they should get tested. The pregnant women, I think you see most of the
doctors offer the patients HIV test.
But the other issue is someone has to pay for those tests. And that’s another
beautiful thing about the health care reform that there is coverage of preventive
services, because we really want to keep people healthy. And so HIV testing and
other preventive services are covered for particularly those who are at-risk. And
st
starting August 1 , every private insurance plan has to cover an HIV test once a
year for sexually active women. That’s a real change. Now we have to expand
that for men as well. So I think as the Affordable Care Act is implemented, we
will see more coverage of HIV testing in the future.
Mark Masselli: Mr. Schmid, let’s talk about moving beyond simple testing to
prevention. Certainly the first step is universal testing so that everyone knows
their status and the next step is making treatment accessible to all who are HIV
positive. You have said that treatment is prevention because the new class of
drugs bring the viral loads down so low that an HIV positive person is 96% less
likely to transmit to partners. What other policy and tools for prevention are
needed to help eradicate AIDS?
Carl Schmid: I think the thing that’s really missing is sexual education. Since
HIV predominately affects gay men, those sex education programs have to
include all sexual orientations, and who is to know age 16, 17, 18, what one’s
sexual orientation is. But they have to be made aware because they are the
ones who are getting affected these days, the young, and they need education,
they cannot be left out. AIDS is still the crisis in our country but there are things
that you can do to prevent HIV.
Margaret Flinter: Mr. Schmid, I would like to ask you to maybe help our listeners
understand something. Now there is one more element that’s been introduced
that I am not sure people understand very much because we have seen
headlines about a drug to block HIV transmission and we are talking about the
recently approved Truvada. So while we don’t usually talk about specific
therapeutics on our show, we are just focused more on reform and innovation, I
would like to give you a chance to explain to our listeners what role is Truvada
going to play in this emerging hopefully end of the epidemic in our lifetime.
Carl Schmid: First of all, it's only going to be used and recommended for high
risk individuals. So perhaps someone who is HIV positive, their partner is HIV
negative, they would be able to take the drug. Now maybe some gay men with
multiple sex partners, they might also be a good candidate for this drug. It costs
money, a lot of money and people don’t have that luxury. We don’t have enough
money to treat all the people in United States who are HIV positive let alone
providing a drug which someone has to take every single day. So I don’t know its
use but it is another tool in our prevention toolkit.
Mark Masselli: Mr. Schmid, we like to ask all of our guests this final question.
When you look around the country, and the world, what do you see in health care
innovations that our listeners at Conversations should be keeping an eye on?
Carl Schmid: Health care reform, that’s the game changer for our country and for
HIV. People don’t have access today to health care and to the medications that
we know save people’s lives. And this will really be a game changer. Having
access to Medicaid, going to a doctor, getting the medications, that will change
HIV in the United States.
Margaret Flinter: We have been speaking with Carl Schmid, Executive Director
of the AIDS Institute speaking to us today from the AIDS Conference 2012 in
Washington DC. Mr. Schmid, thank you so much for joining us on Conversations
on Health Care.
Carl Schmid: It's been my pleasure. Thank you very much.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: At Conversations on Health Care, we want our audience to be
truly in the know when it comes to the facts about health care reform and policy.
Lori Robertson is an award-winning journalist and Managing Editor of
FactCheck.org, a nonpartisan, nonprofit consumer advocate for voters that aim to
reduce the level of deception in US politics. Lori, what have you got for us this
week?
Lori Robertson: Well, Mark and Margaret, I thought we would look at the topic of
the week and that’s the Medicare plan included in Representative Paul Ryan’s
budget proposal. Ryan’s plan is getting a lot more attention now that he is Mitt
Romney’s running mate. So what would this plan do? Well, for current seniors,
those who are on Medicare now, nothing would change, but starting a decade
from now in 2023, new Medicare beneficiaries would enter a new premium
support system where seniors would pick from a choice of private plans or
traditional Medicare that would still be a choice on a new Medicare exchange and
they would get government provided subsidies to help them purchase these
plans.
The plan also slowly increases the retirement age from 65 to 67 by 2034. These
premium support payments, they would be tied to the second cheapest plan
whether that’s the traditional Medicare or one of these private plans that are
offered. And Ryan’s plan says that that second cheapest policy can't grow more
than Gross Domestic Product plus 0.5% points, this is where it gets little
complicated, and if the cost does grow faster than that, then Congress is required
to step in and take some unspecified action.
Now one democratic claim that we have seen again and again is that seniors
would end up paying $6,000 more under Ryan’s plan than they would under
traditional Medicare. That claim actually pertains to Ryan’s old plan that he
released last year. This new plan is now a little more generous in terms of how
those subsidies or premium support payments increase overtime. But it still does
call for less government spending than the current Medicare system. And we
don’t have a good analysis from the Congressional Budget Office on what exactly
this latest plan would do to seniors’ costs. It would however be a major change
for Medicare. And that’s my fact check for this week. I am Lori Robertson,
Managing Editor of FactCheck.org.
Margaret Flinter: FactCheck.org is committed to factual accuracy from the
country’s major political players and is a project of the Annenberg Public Policy
Center at the University of Pennsylvania. If you have a fact, that you would like
checked, email us at www.chcradio.com . We will have FactCheck.org’s Lori
Robertson check it out for you here on Conversations on Health Care.
(Music)
Margaret Flinter: Each week, Conversations highlights a bright idea about how
to make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives. When it comes
to two wheeling it, Copenhagen leaves other modern cities in the dust. Over a
third of commuters, in the Danish capital, cycle to work in a city that puts plenty
of bike roads out there for the cycling populus, including a cycling superhighway
currently under construction that will link all of the city sections via a cycle-only
road system. And add to that, a bicycle library where you can check out all kinds
of innovative bikes for up to several days for free. That program makes
experimental bikes available for consumers to test drive, bikes that can haul a
small load, carry several people, even bikes with protection against bad weather.
The benefits of the hundreds of miles of cycling highways are many. Carbon and
diesel emissions are reduced in the city, making air quality much healthier than in
other modern metropolises; the daily exercise of cycling to and from work gives
an additional health benefit to the commuters; and there is cost, the practice
saves commuters money in gas cost and the city saves money in road
maintenance as well. And here is an additional social benefit. Cyclers have a
chance to meet other cyclers in the course of their commute. And other cities are
catching on. In advance of the Olympics, London installed an urban cycling
system and a bike sharing program and New York has added 300 miles of
cycling roadway across the five boroughs. But The Big Apple still has a long way
to go to catch up to Copenhagen. The manager of the Bicycle Innovation Lab in
Copenhagen who makes their experimental bikes available says it's about
exploring the possibilities of bicyclism which he says encompasses much more
than the cycling. It requires you to explore the infrastructure, the design, the
health benefits of creating a more livable city. A bicycle superhighway making
the roads accessible for healthy bike commuting and a free cycle library to
expand the transport possibilities for those riders, now that’s a bright idea.
(Music)
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the Campus of WESU at
Wesleyan University, streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.