Lynn Quincy, Senior Health Policy Analyst for Consumers Union
This week, Mark and Margaret speak with Lynn Quincy, Senior Health Policy Analyst for Consumers Union, the policy branch of Consumer’s Report. Ms. Quincy discusses her report on recommendations for design architecture of the on-line health insurance exchanges being created in states around the country, so that they are easy to navigate and consumer-friendly.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations On Health Care. I’m Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I’m Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: Well Margaret the GOP Convention is behind us. Now we turn
our attention to Charlotte, where the democratic national convention is on their
way.
Margaret Flinter: Well it has been a fascinating week and it’s interesting to know
Mark that the GOP didn’t really get much of a convention bumped in terms of
polling numbers.
Mark Masselli: They didn’t and yet they’re still polling and we’ll watch that Gallup
poll closely and we’ll see what happens to President Obama’s ranking after this
week at the moment the presidential candidates are neck in neck. But the
election is still two months off and so we’ve seen in politics before, Margaret,
anything is possible.
Margaret Flinter: It is and I think you could categorized the prevailing theme this
week are we better off now than we were four years ago.
Mark Masselli: And if we’re talking about health care the answer would have to
be a resounding yes, for the millions of young Americans who are able to insured
on the parent’s plans.
Margaret Flinter: And for the tens of millions of American women who have now
have no co-paid for preventive cancer screenings and also all those Americans
who won’t be denied coverage due to preexisting conditions I would put those all
in the category of yes better off today than four years ago.
Mark Masselli: Absolutely. In the past which is the Affordable Care Act is
certainly a singular achievement in the whole marked of the Obama Presidency
whereof I know he is now starting to refer to his Obamacare, because he does
care.
Margaret Flinter: Okay. And our guest toady is somebody who has examined
how the Affordable Care Act and specifically technology advances in health care
are improving the landscape across the country.
Mark Masselli: Darrell West is the Director of the Center for Technology
Innovation at the Brookings Institution, he has done extensive research on the
ways mobile technology is improving health care deliver in these country.
Mark Masselli: And factcheck.org Lori Robertson takes a look at claims that were
made at the GOP Convention.
Mark Masselli: And as always you can hear all of our shows by Goggling CHC
Radio.
Margaret Flinter: And if you have comments remember email us at chcradio.com
or reach out to us on Facebook or Twitter because we love to hear from you.
Mark Masselli: We would and we’ll get to our interview with Darrell West in just a
moment but first here is our producer Marianne O'Hare with this weeks headline
news.
(Music)
Marianne O'Hare : I’m Marian O’Hare, with this Headline News. Tens of
thousands have descended on Charlotte, North Carolina for their Democratic
National Convention a week after the GOP held their nominating event in Tampa.
And health care was the dominate topic at the start of the event, with the
prevailing theme from last weeks event focusing on President Obama’s Medicare
Funding Plan. Republicans claim it’s taking 7 out of $16 billion from Medicare, a
politically charge statement based on only marginal fact, the president’s plan
would cap growth in Medicare expenses over the next 10 years. Harvard
economist Dr. John McDonagh’s saying that candidate Romney’s Plan who quote
restore those Medicare cuts would actually hasten the insolvency of Medicare
and that the move would actually require seniors to pay an average of $350 more
per person out of pocket under the Romney Plan.
Meanwhile some of the informal administrators on President Obama’s Health
Care Law are making recommendations for health reform 2.0 proposing a
measures similar to one recently passed in Massachusetts, that seeks to contain
health care caused in the future on the team that includes former CMS acting
Administrator Don Berwick, they are calling for things like an overhaul of
spending systems for Medicare Medicaid putting limits on medical liabilities for
doctors who follow best practices paying fix rates for treating certain conditions
rather than the current unchecked fee for service system and biding from
Medicaid expenditures.
And it’s back to school time, a tough time for a lot of kids but especially tough on
kids who are on the Autism Spectrum. A recent report out shows 50% of kids
with either Autism or Asperger’s are bullied in school that compares to about 11%
of kids being bullied in the general student population. A UC Berkeley study
published in the archives of pediatrics and adolescent medicine showed those
kids on the spectrum who are in general public school populations were most
likely to be bullied in that environment.
I’m Marian O’Hare with this Headline News.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: We’re speaking today with Darrell West, Vice President and
Director of Governance Studies and founding director of the Center for
Technology Innovation at Brookings Institute, one of the top public policy think
tanks in the nation. Mr. West spent 26 years on the faculty of Brown University
teaching political science before joining Brookings in 2008. He is the author, co-
author of numerous articles in 18 books including digital medicine health care in
the internet era. Mr. West welcome to Conversations on Health Care.
Darrell West: Thank you, pleasure to be with you.
Mark Masselli: You know you’ve spent a considerable amount of time throughout
your carrier analyzing the impact technologies having on our economy, politics,
education and in health care. And in Brookings, you’re currently conducting the
three year mobile economy project that is studying the various ways mobile
technology is changing the landscape and politics health care and in business.
Let’s take a look at the bigger picture for a moment, how are all these areas
conversing and what can we learn from your past studies in digital governance
that will help us navigate this these new emerging world in digital health?
Darrell West: A few months ago I was in Barcelona for the World Mobile
Congress and there I found out the research is indicating that 80% of the
broadband access within four years is going to be through mobile devices. So
that’s one of the reasons we’re doing this mobile economy project just to figure
out how the use of smartphones, tablets and cell phones is going to alter every
area including health care. Certainly there have been a number of very important
in health applications, we’re starting to see remote monitoring and devices and
which people can record their own blood pressures and other types of vital signs
machines will electronically submit to your physicians office and so it can save
time and money because a physicians can get basic health information without
you personally having to go to that person’s office.
Margaret Flinter: Well I know you have been paying a lot of attentions, we have
to the fact that the Supreme Court upheld the Affordable Care Act and Health IT
as a big component of those changes that we see coming, you’ve noted I think in
a recent Brookings report, there’s been a lot of progress in establishing the
organizational framework for health information exchanges and, I think you called
that part of a mega change underway in health care. But still there is just so
much work left to be done across the country. What are the key components yet
to be completed and the most challenging obstacles to the adoption of these
health information exchanges in the various states?
Darrell West: When technology is enabling new approaches to health care which
offer the potential to really bring various networks together bring them the
hospitals, the physicians and other health care providers into one type of
network. And then, you know once you created those networks you can then
share data and then start to analyze those data for purposes of compared of
effectiveness. And the thing that continues to amaze me about American Health
Care is how so much of it still is done on a trial in our basis. You know you go to
the doctor with your particular symptom -- try one drug if that’s work fine and if it
doesn’t then you’ll try something else. We don’t really have very detailed
information on what works and what doesn’t works. So I think the different data
sharing networks sort of being created now really have great potential to get a
handle on caused which is so important right now without necessarily sacrificing
the quality of the cure that people valued so much.
Mark Masselli: It also seems to be very fragment at the health care system in
terms of its adoption of technology. It seems to be very focused it on billing and
accounting. Give us the bigger picture if you will of how this personal health
records, electronic health records, health exchanges are going to fit together in
the emerging realm of mobile health and also in the back drop of very slow
adoption by the health care industry relative to other industries?
Darrell West: I mean I think you’re exactly right that the big challenge that we
face in United States is just the very fragmented nature of our health care
system. Here our system is broken down to individual physicians, individual
hospitals and until recently those different types of providers would not very well
integrated. So what technology is trying to do is to bring the health care at the
same sense of efficiency that we have found in other areas you know there have
been many sectors that have created data showing networks and then that
allows those providers to become more efficient and more productive. So what
we’re trying to do in the health care area is to use electronics health records so
that all of someone’s personal records are located in one place. So we’re trying
to figure out ways to integrate the electronic part of health care so that we can
improve our record keeping then we can get rid of duplicative test, that’s one
thing that really drives up the caused as oppose to having one set of test that go
into your electronic record and then all the relevant providers have access to
that. You know in our current system we just keep running a test after test,
physicians in hospitals make a lot of money off of that but obviously creates very
bad incentives and helps to drive the cost up, you know a high cost system
without necessarily producing the quality of cure that we all desire.
Margaret Flinter: You know Mr. West I think that most consumers if we said to
them that the area of personalize medicine is one of the positive changes that lie
ahead that would probably sound pretty good to people. You’ve talked about this
as something that really is based on three revolutions that are going on in which
technology and personalize medicine will play a bigger and bigger part in health
care, the first in medical delivery revolution, the second the digital revolution, and
the third revolution in Genomics. So let’s take those three separately and first
let’s look at the medical delivery revolution. Tell us your observation in this new
reality of personalize medicine and cure delivery.
Darrell West: Well the good news is the people are getting more involved in their
own health care. They’re doing these in terms of preventive medicine and you
know paying more attention to diet and exercise which produces tremendous
savings and quality health down the road. But they’re also getting more engaged
with their primary care providers.
Mark Masselli: We’re speaking to -- with Darrell West, Vice President and
Director of Governance Studies and founding director of the Center for
Technology Innovation in Brookings Institute. Mr. West is conducting a three
year study on the impact technologies having it on Health Care delivery. Let’s
look at that second revolution you see coming in health care, the digital
revolution. And patients are now accessing a merit of health information from
sources like WebMD or mayoclinic.com. What sorts of impact will this better
informed and digitally engaged patients have on the transformation of health
care?
Darrell West: I think it’s having a very positive impact on health care just
because people are more involved, they know more and so they can be smarter
consumers about their own health care. And I think this is particularly relevant in
the case of weird diseases, those are often the most challenging for our health
care system. So there are social media websites probably the one is called
patientslikeme.com. That basically deals with people who are suffering from a
weird diseases and they’re able to share knowledge, they actually put detailed
information online about what their symptoms are, what their treatment is, and
then what the resultants of that treatment and so as oppose to relying on one
doctor in your home town who may not know a lot about that particular illness,
you’re suddenly kind of plugged into these broader network of people who are
going through these problem and sharing information and thereby learning from
one another and so I think that’s a great example of how the Digital Revolution is
improving access to information and improving the quality of the cure to gets
delivered as well.
Margaret Flinter: Mr. West, if we can just look at third area you agree I think the
integrating genomic information is poise to have a really significant impact on
health care moving forward but maybe you could help us understand the
potential impact of genomics on medicine and health care and also your thoughts
on any necessary policy development that’s going to be needed to govern its
use?
Darrell West: I mean I think this is how we can really personalize medicine
because what we’re finding in research is that someone’s genetic makeup
actually has a huge consequence both in terms of their susceptibility to particular
diseases, but also the advocacy of particular treatments so for example there are
many common drugs where we already know that the drugs are only effective in
a third of the patients or half of the patients or may be 60% of the patients based
on particular genes that a person has and so when you think about the cost
implications of that you know now we’re basically trying out different drugs not
knowing what someone’s genetic structure is and if the drug is only successful
half of the time, we’re wasting half of the money right there. So if we can start to
developed a better understanding of someone’s genetic structure and then learn
what are the genes that associated with particular diseases as well as with
particular treatment, we can then personalize that health care to that individual
and the cost of the gene testing kits are really starting to come down. But in the
next few years we’re anticipating those costs are going to drop dramatically and
it's really going to open up a consumer market for gene testing.
Mark Masselli: That’s very exciting and certainly at the intersection of all of those
revolutions in health technology is the corner stone and its -- we’re looking at
thousands of apps and devices floating in the market place, all with varying
degrees of efficiency and now the FDA I think these last summer has gotten into
approving mobile health devices. Tell us about your concerns about the FDAs
involvement what kinds of policies are needed to facilitates the FDAs role in
digital health?
Darrell West: Well we need policies and regulatory procedures that are in
keeping with the different revolutions that we have been talking about because
what the FDA has done in the past is basically when a treatment is proposed, we
have this very expensive and very time consuming clinical trials and so the
problem is it’s often years after research suggest that a drug maybe effective with
particular diseases until we actually figure out what it’s possible impact is. And
so what we need to do is to really speed up that process obviously without
compromising patient’s safety but try and take advantage of these new data
sharing networks that we’re building so that we can basically use those networks
as an early warning system as opposed to waiting 3, 4 or 5 years to get that
feedback we can start to move almost towards a real time system where we can
try various treatments, see what the side effects are, see what’s working and do
that much more a rapid way. And so the FDA really needs to speed up the
process so that we can get information to consumers much more quickly than
what we see today.
Margaret Flinter: So, Mr. West, perhaps on the softer side of progress there’s
you know bit of a nagging concern about trust and people, still more persistent
lack of trust in technology and the protection of the privacy of their health
information. What’s your sense of how we’re going to galvanize trust in digital
health systems as we go forward to get maximum advantage from these?
Darrell West: Virtually, every public opinion survey in this area really identifies
privacy as the chief concern that people have about health information and
technology. So, what people obviously are concerned about is, you know, there
is very personal and very confidential information in people’s health record. They
are concerned about that information following into the wrong hands. We do
have to be very careful to maintain privacy, that’s certainly a very high priority for
consumers and the patients, but we also have to be careful not to be so privacy
oriented that we don’t get the innovation that we need from these data sharing
networks. One problem so far has been researchers often have not been able to
get access to the de-identified data, the health care records where someone’s
personal information, their name, their address, their phone number, their social
security number is taken out of the data sets and then researchers can kind of do
analysis of what works and what does not works. So, we need to kind of
understand its important on the one hand to protect privacy but we also need
innovation that will actually give the patients the advantages of these data
sharing network that are being created right now.
Mark Masselli: And Mr. West, we’re in the midst of the Presidential Race
Healthcare Reform and affordable care act are hot-button issues in the
campaigns. How do you see these diametrically opposed views on health care
playing out during the selection season?
Darrell West: Now we’re saying health care and then certainly the competing
plans between the two parties about the future of Medicare really attracting a lot
of attention and the selection of Congressmen ran as the running maid for Mitt
Romney certainly its going to focus a lot of attention on Medicare as well as the
affordable care act is because Republicans are opposed to Obama’s healthcare
legislation, they have already promised to repeal it. So, I think its really present a
very star choice for voters. What I always advice people if they are uncertain pay
attention to rebates. Its important election and certainly healthcare is going to be
essential in the outcome that we see there.
Margaret Flinter: Well it's always good to find an area of common ground in one
area if we can reduce cost and deliver better care that would be the holy grail of
the scenario. And you at your recent digital health gathering you were on a panel
that looked at this intersection between AM Finance and AM Health, as the real
breakthrough opportunity and containing mounting health care cost but how does
AM Finance and AM Health come together towards the holy grail of reduced cost
and better outcomes.
Darrell West: I mean right now we have tremendous inefficiency in our health
care system and that’s one of the reasons cost have sprawled out completely out
of control. So, the key thing that I focus on and I think how digital health really
helps is we need to get the incentives right in our current system. Right now the
big problem in terms of finance is there are just too many people who have the
wrong incentives like physicians and hospitals make more money by running
more tests. So, obviously they have incentives just to run a bunch of test. And
so we need to focus more on health outcomes as opposed to just paying a
provider support the number of tests that they run. You know, in other sectors of
the economy, we’ve seen technology enable tremendous cost savings without
compromising the quality of the service delivery. Health care is in the early
stages of that but I think technology really has to be part of that solution because
we need to figure out ways to use technology to reduce costs while still delivering
quality care to people.
Mark Masselli: Mr. West, we’d like to ask all of our guests this final question,
when you look around the country in the world what do you see in terms of
innovations that are listeners at Conversations should be keeping an eye on.
Darrell West: The key innovation that I’m watching is called Big Data and data
analytics that basically, you know once we’ve created the data sharing networks
that we talked about here, we can start to use that information to analyze results
in real time and basically reduce the length of that feedback, so that we give
much more timely information about what works and what doesn’t work and at
what cost. Data analytics is a way to grow really use information in real time to
monitor what is going on, figuring out what works and then also figuring out what
is effective cost wise so that we can get the biggest bank for the buck. So I think
in the future that’s the innovation I think offers the greatest hope in terms of really
transforming our system while still preserving the high quality that everybody
wants.
Margaret Flinter: We’ve been speaking today with Darrell West, Vice President
of Governance Studies and Director of the Center for Technology Innovation at
the Brookings Institution. Mr. West, thank you so much for much joining us on
Conversations on Health Care today.
Darrell West: Thank you.
Mark Masselli: At Conversations on Health Care we want our audience to be
truly in the know when it comes to the facts about healthcare reform and policy,
Lori Robertson is an award-winning journalist and managing editor of
factcheck.org. non-partisan, non-profit consumer advocate for voters that aim to
reduce the level of deception in US politics. Lori, what have you got for us this
week?
Lori Robertson: Mark and Margaret at the Republican National Convention last
week a few speakers repeated an old false claim about the affordable care act
saying that it would interfere with the doctor-patient relationship. New Jersey
governor Chris Christie was one of them, he made the claim in his keynote
saying that the law bureaucrats between an American citizen and her doctor, and
the false claim was also made by John Archer, a congressional candidate from
Iowa who said that the government could come between patients and their
doctors. Mitt Romney has also made this claim but repeating it doesn’t make it
accurate. The healthcare law doesn’t regulate what doctors can and can’t do or
which doctors patients can see and the law doesn’t come anywhere close to
creating a government run system or the government is the insurer like that of
many other countries instead it builds on the current employer based insurance
system and while it expands Medicaid it also greatly expands business for private
insurance companies. Republicans often point to what's called the Independent
Payment Advisory Board as a source of rationing but that board which is created
by the law is passed with finding ways to slow the growth of Medicare spending.
And according to the law it can’t ration care. And that’s my FactCheck for this
week. I am Lori Robertson, managing editor of FactCheck.org.
Margaret Flinter: FactCheck.org is committed to factual accuracy from the
country’s major political players and is a project of the Annenberg Public Policy
Center at the University of Pennsylvania. If you have a fact, that you would like
checked, email us at chcradio.com. We will have FactCheck.org’s Lori
Robertson check it out for you here on Conversations on Health Care.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: Each week, Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives. For anyone who
spends time on social media you know that cute kitten pictures are all the rage.
Just looking at the images conserved to be coming on a stressful day, Seattle
Children’s Hospital artist-in-residence John Blalock met with 16-year-old Maga
Barzallo in isolation after a bone marrow transplant. He marveled at how she
didn’t complain about her plight at all. But one thing she wanted more than
anything was a visit from her beloved cat. Since an actual visit was out of the
question Blalock hatched a plan, the Cat Immersion Project. What if they
collected images of her cat and pictures of other cats belonging to the staff and
projected them on a screen for Maga. The plan quickly expanded to a call on
Facebook to have other people post images of their felines for the project.
Blalock interspersed pictures of the young patient’s cat with 1000s of other kitten
photos projecting them on a tent made of sterile bed sheets over her bed. He
also made a continuous loop soundtrack of real cat spurring. The affect on the
patient was mesmerizing. Lethargic and sick from treatment she literally came
alive under her tent of large projected image of kittens. As her mood improved
she became animated and engaged. And the sound of spurring kittens had a
calming affect as well. 16-year-old Maga said the photos made her feel like she
was part of the world again. She is beginning to write thank you notes to the
1000s of people who sent in cat images giving this young cancer fighter another
purpose during her time in isolation. A personalized art driven project using
simple technology and social media to erase isolation felt by a young patient
fighting a deadly disease. Now that’s a bright idea.
(Music)
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the Campus of WESU at
Wesleyan University, streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.