Democratic Presidential Hopeful John Delaney on His Market-Based Approaches to Universal Health Care and Addressing Climate Change

This week, hosts Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter welcome another 2020 Presidential candidate to Conversations on Health Care, former Maryland Congressman and entrepreneur John Delaney. They discuss his record as a centrist Democrat who favors more market-based approaches to universal health care, which gives all Americans access to coverage, but keeps private payers in the mix, providing more consumer choice than Medicare for All. He favors a carbon tax approach to addressing climate change to foster US innovation to reduce reliance on fossil fuels.

Congressman John Delaney

Female: Welcome to Conversations on H ealth C are with Mark Masselli and
Margaret Flinter, a show where we speak to the top thought leaders
in health innovation, health policy, care delivery and the great minds
who are shaping the healthcare of the future.

This week Mark and Margaret speak with former Maryland
Congressman , John Delaney , the First Democrat to announce his run
for the Presidency in 2020. Congressman Delaney talks about his
unique approach to expanding healthcare, which maintains a role for
the insurance industry , so that consumers have choices. The centrist
democrat and entrepreneur also talks about the need to take a
market approach to addressing pressing issues like climate change .

Lori Robertson also checks in, the Managing Editor of F a ct ch eck. org ,
looks at mis statements spoken about health policy i n the public
domain, separating the fake from the facts . We end with a bright idea
that’s improving health and well - being in everyday lives.

If you have comments, please email us at chcradio@chc1 . com or find
us o n Facebook, Twitter or wherever you listen to podcast . You can
also hear us by asking Alexa to play the program Conversations on
Health Care . Now, stay tuned for our interview with Dem ocratic
presidential candidate John Delaney on Conversa tions on Health Care.

Mark Masselli : We 're speaking today with former Congressman , J ohn Delaney ,
candidate for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination.
Congressman Delaney represent ed Maryland's sixth congressional
district in the US House of Represent atives from 2013 to 2019.
Previously, as an entrepreneur, he started t w o businesses : H ealth C are
Financial Partners , which provided loans to small healthcare practices ;
and Capital S ource , which invested in small businesses in
economically distressed areas.

He won the Ernst & Young Entrepreneur of the Year Award in 2004.
He earned his BA at Columbia and his law degree from G eorgetown.
Congressman Delaney , welcome to Conversations on Health Care .

John Delaney : Great to be with you .

Mark Masselli: You have th e distinction of being the First Democrat to thr o w y our hat
in the ring for the 2020 presidential nomination and you're
considered as more of a centrist democrat in this very crowded field. I
had the opportunity to be in Iowa, at the Wing Ding and heard yo u
and I thought you gave great presentation talking about the strong
business sense that you bring to the campaign through your
candidacy.

I wonder if you could talk about the motivating factor that led you to
enter the presidential race and how you would define what makes
your candidacy unique?

Congressman John Delaney

John Delaney : Well, I think what motivated me most is the sense that our
government -- our federal government, is just broken. It's broken for
lots of reasons. The biggest reason it's broken is the complete inabili ty
of the political parties to actually find commo n ground and get
anything done a nd that has really hurt the American peop le , b ecause
the world has changed very rapidly and driven by things like
technological innovation and globalization.

These forces ha ve been really disruptive to lots of people and lots of
communities. There are things that our governme nt should have done
a long time ago to address them. We didn't do them , b ecause we're
too busy fighting a nd we're too busy engaged in partisan warfare. I t's
really hurting our country, y ou know, and I think the future is coming
at us very rapidly.

These changes we've seen over the last several decades are
accelerating. I just think we need a President who actually cares abo ut
trying to bring the country t ogether to get things done. That's really at
the end of the day, why I decided to run for President , because I think
I'm uniquely positioned to do that. I had a very strong bipartisa n track
record in the Congress a nd as someone who spent most of my career
in the private sector, building things and getting things done, I think
that's th e kind of background we neede d o ur next President , we need
a unifi er not a divider. We need a doe r not a talker.

Margaret Flinter: Well, Congressman, as you know, you were suc cessful entrepreneur
building a business in the healthcare sector that provided loans to
practices and healthcare entities looking to build their organizations.
Certainly , healthcare is front and center. In the debates, we're hearing
a lot of talk from the democratic candidates about the American
health care system. Some folks are very focused on a need to shift to
a Medicare for All system.

We're really inter ested in hearing your thoughts, y ou support
universal access to healthcare, but you said we should be wary of
such a radical shift as Medicare for All in the healthcare infrastruct ure.
W e would really welcome you sharing with our audience, some of the
aspects of your better care healthcare proposal and maybe helping
our listeners understand what might set this apart from other
positions on healthcare ?

John Delaney : [inaudible 00:04:45] the question up well , because I do favor a
universal health care system. What I mean by that is I favor a system
where every American has healthcare as a basic hum an righ t and a
right to a healthcare plan as a right of citizenship . My Better Care plan
does that , but what makes my Better Care plan different than
Medicare for All , is that it's not a sin gle payer healthcare sy stem. A
single payer healthcare system means th at government is responsible
for all the bills. Very few countries actually have a single payer system.

Congressman John Delaney

Most countries have a form of universal health care , but it's not single
payer. My Better Care program is modeled in many ways after what
Germany has --

Margaret Flinter: Yeah.

John Delaney: -- which is effectively a system where everyone gets a basic
government healthcare plan a s a right. But then they have options.
The first option they have is they could opt out of the government
plan, get a tax credit and use that tax credit to buy their own private
insurance.

The other option they have is they can take their government plan
and improve it with a supplemental health plan, which is also private
insurance, which is what Medicare beneficiaries many of the m do
right now.

Margaret Flinter: Yeah.

John Delaney: Then the third option is they could get their employer healthcare and
then they could take their tax credits again because they're not u sing
the government plan and they could turn that credit into thei r
employer or their union a s a way of offsetting the costs . Everyone has
basic government healthcare as a right , b ut then there's kind of a
private market that floats on top of it, where people have lots of
options. I think tha t's a better healthcare syste m, I think that leads to
a healthier and stronger healthcare marketplace . It also gives the
Amer ican people the cho ices that they're interested in.

Mark Masselli: I was just thinking about what Americans are probab ly animated
about in healthcare and I was reading the headlines that noted that
the cost of employee provided health c overage past $20,000 per
family . In addition, individuals, families were paying about $6,000 a
year up and healthcare costs represents about 20% of our GDP. We're
on the way to $3. 5 trillion a year in expenditures. What would Better
Care plan look like in terms of trying to address the i ssues around
cost? How do you think you can tackle that outside of a larger
theoretical framework?

John Delaney : In many ways, we have a universal h ealth care sy stem right now a nd
it's called t he emergency room. Any American or any person in our
country for that matter , who shows up at an emergency room, they're
required by law to receive care. The p roblem is that care is often 10 to
20 times m ore exp ensive than if you would have went to a doctor. By
creating an org anized form of universal health care , you create the
opportunity to get people in a lower cost setting for their care.

The second thing it does is it allows you to drive preventative
medici ne better , because if people aren't in a health insurance plan or
covered by some form of government healthcare and they're just out

Congressman John Delaney

there uninsured, they never do preventative care, which we all know
can save a lot of money.

The only way ultimately to lo wer healthcare costs is to make the
system more efficient. That means ensuring the care is delivered at
the lowest possible p oint of cost , creating incentives in the healthcare
system for providers, l ike the Affor dable Care Act, for example, that’s
a reall y good incentives in it . Th ings like penalizing hospitals , who
have had lots of readmissions , to encourage them to actually g ive the
care they need the first time and do things to make sure the patient
isn't readmitted. You can't really begin to drive effi ciencies in the
healthcare system unless everyone is in a form of organized
healthcare .

Margaret Flinter: Congressman, we've been t alking about the cost of healthcare being
in the headlines, b ut another set of headlines on the front page and
then again on the obituary pages of our local newspapers, relates to
the opioid crisis, which has just --

John Delaney: Right.

Margaret Flinter: -- caused such devastation i n all of our communities across this
country and there has been progress made towards stabilizing it,
certainly, in just the recent year or two and some funding and some
programs , but 70,000 deaths last year , beyond shocking.

Y ou've outlined a plan to confront the crisis with a multi - pronged
approach and w e'd like you to comment on what your plan is for
addressing the opioid crisis and perhaps as well as appropriately
holding responsible individuals that may have contributed to setting it
in mot ion.

John Delaney : Yeah, I definitely think it needs the accountability. I think many
pharmaceutical compani es knew exactly what was going on a nd they
actually encourage more aggressive sales practices.

I think not only the company should be held financially liable, but I
think executives to the extent they have this knowledge , should be
held personally liable , in a criminal context, because we lose 70,000
A mericans to addiction every year. That's a Vietnam a year. That scale
of this tragedy is overwhelming. We have to address it.

I think what it takes to a ddress it is we need more resources, we've
underfunded prevention , we've underfunded mental health. I mean, if
you think about the amount of fundin g we provided against Zika and
E bola, which are two very serious things and deserve the funding, by
the way ; but we provided billions of dollars in funding to those two
situations and I think three Americans died.

Mark Masselli: Right. Right.

Congressman John Delaney

John Delaney: I'm not diminishing it. I think the funding was appropriated and
prevented it being a much larger scale situation. But for years, people
advocated for hundreds of millions of dollars in funding for the opioid
crisis and they came up empty handed.

Margaret Flinter: Yeah.

John Delaney: Yet , we use 70,000 a year.

Margaret Flinter: Yeah.

John Delaney: I think it ’ s funding to prevention . I t hink it ’ s funding treatment . I think
it's backing local interventions that work. I think it's really creat ing
parody in our mental healthcare system ; but we can also ignore the
economic opportunity piece of this , because clearly, if you have
ec onomically distressed communities, you're more likely to have th e
environment that can lead to addiction.

Mark Masselli: We 're speakin g today with former Congressman , J ohn Delaney
candidate for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomi nation. He
represented Maryland’s six congressional district in the US House of
Representatives from 2013 through 2019.

You don't want to pull the thread on your tenure in Congress, you are
a pro - business moderate democrat and it seemed that that
orientation informs your approach to many things, includin g climate
change . You recently announced a multi - trillion dollar climate plan
that you say will achieve far mor e than the so - called Green Deal , by
promoting the private sector.

I wonder if you could talk a little bit about that plan, but also about
the climate itself and the challenges we face globally on this. Also why
isn't it animating? I was reading, I think Nate Silver's FiveThirtyEight
comment that Inslee, his candidacy , probably speaks to that climate
may not be the thing that's animating the electorate this round. A
couple of questions in there ; but first, certainly your sense of the
challe nges of the climate that we face?

John Delaney : Sure. Well, I don't think , it's the -- climate is incredibly important for
democratic primary voters as it should be. I think it's very hard to run
for President a s a one issue candidate, because the problems the
American face [inaudible 00:11:59] face are much greater than one
issue. We want our President to speak broadly to a range of issues. I
think tha t's one reason why the govern or's campaign, which we
basically framed all around climate change didn't work.

I also think every one of the democratic candidates are very good on
this issue. It becomes -- it's not like he was the only one who cares
abou t climate change, right? W e all have very aggressive plan s. My
take on it is very different , b ecause I'm much more clear - eyed about

Congressman John Delaney

things tha n I think a lot of people and w hat I mean by that is 80% of
the energy that this country consumes and about 85% of the energy
tha t the world consu mes comes from fossil fuels.

When you think about getting us off fossil fuels , you have to think
about how do we replace that energy, because fundamentally, the
political system will not deny its citizens ’ energy, nor will it just deliver
them energy that is incredibly expens ive to deal with climate change ,
becau se the political system doesn't have that kind of long - term
orientation, it has a short - term orientation.

You have to say to yourself, okay, I want to deal with climate change,
but I can't do it o n the backs of hard working citizens. That's where
I'm thinking , I'm different. I mean, a lot of these people are proposing
things that will increase energy costs on the American people
dramatically. When you have a situation where half of our country
can' t afford their basic necessities, just not going to ever get things
done that solve climate change on the backs of hardworking
American s.

You have to be clear - eyed about the challenge an d not engage in this
kind of fairy tale solution. The first thing I p ropose , which is to put a
price on carbon, which is sometimes known as a carbon tax .

The reason that works and the reason that's the best way forward,
initially, is what it does is it mak es fossil fu els more expen sive and
discourages their use and so it e ffectively makes all the energy that
any of us consume from fossil fuels a lot more expensive and it makes
us not use it. But what it does , that ’s unique in my proposal, it takes
all the money that's raised in the carbon fee, because effectively what
the g overnment i s doing is putting a fee or a tax on carbon.

O ver 1 0 years, it raise d $3 trillion a nd then it takes all that money and
it gives it right back to the American people in a dividend and every
American gets the same dividend. If you're a hardworkin g American,
working - class, middle - class American, your dividend will be bigger
than the amount that your energy costs go up.

We created an incentive for people to change where they get their
energy from both businesses and individuals , but we do it in a w ay
where the costs of tha t transition are not borne by working
Americans. Tha t's one of the cornerstones of my plan. It's called a
carbon fee or d ividend. I introduced this idea in the Congress and I
introduced it on a bipartisan basis , so this can happen.

Then the rest of my plan is really at the end of t he day a mass ive bet
on American innovation , because fundamentally, we're not going to
be able to solve this problem globally, u nless the United States of
America , which is the best innovation economy in the world,

Congressman John Delaney

effectively innovate s new battery storage, transmission and direct
your capture technologies to deliver around the world , b ecause we
cannot expect the developing world where billions of people in the
next several decades will go from poverty to the middle - class. We
can't expect these countries to deny them energy.

The energy they'r e going to give them right no w is fossil fuels ,
b ecause it's abundant and it's cheap. We have to basically come up
with new energy solutions. By the way , it's a huge e conomic
opportunity if we do that, to solve this problem globally. I've called for
kind of Paris 2.0 to be a global consortium of all the developed
nations around the world , who contribute money and intellectual
capital , coming up with the innovation that can effectively get the
world off fossils.

Margaret Flinter: Well, Congressman, I think you're making a great point that we can't
afford to have any single issue , because we have so many issues that
we need to deal with --

John Delaney: We do.

Margaret Fli nter: -- as a country and if you would allow me, I want to just go back a
moment to when we were t alking about the opioid crisis a nd you
made a comment that we really need mental health parity in this
country a nd you've really taken a strong approach on th is around the
need for behavioral and mental health s ervices, i t's such a great need.
Neither adults nor children, or anybody else really across the country
equitably have access to what we would consider high performance
behavioral health services.

Certa inly in our organization, we've taken an approach to fully
integrating behavioral health into primary care and are studying and
researching the outcome and the effectiveness of that, but it's just
not the case that it's readily available for most Americans . I know
you've been working on some proposals to address this a s w ell,
America's unmet behavioral healthcare needs . Tell us what you're
proposing ?

John Delaney : Well, I think, as part of having universal health care system, you have
to have a minimum set of mental health benefits that address the
need. You also have to increase reimbursement. Until we have
universal health care , the most important thing for us to do is increase
reimbursement within Medicaid , b ecause while many Medicaid
programs offer menta l health, the reimbursement rates are so low,
that providers don't take it.

Like in New Hampshire, for example, I think they pay about 18 bucks
for mental health through the Medicaid program. If you are a mental
health provider in the state of New Hampshi re and you could take

Congressman John Delaney

private pay or commercial insurance or Medicare, why would you
take Medicaid [crosstalk].

Margaret Flinter: Or no -- you take no insurance at all , a s we're hearing [crosstalk] .

John Delaney : No insurance at all.

Margaret Flinter: Yeah .

Mark Masselli: Yeah.

John Delaney: Right. You have to increase -- you have to have a -- t hat's why it's
important to initially fix Medicaid , but also basically have a form of
universal health care and make sure that there's good mental health
benefit in it and that the reimbursement rates are sufficient.

Mark Masselli: Earlier you were talk ing about energy and innovation, I was thinking
about those two words, in the context of what you're doing. It must
require an enormous amount of energy to be out on th e campaign
trail, as much as you have been.

Innovation , I'm wondering, you've had this rare opportunity to talk to
Americans, what have you learned from them in terms of the
innovations that they're thinking? I'm sure many of those
conversations animate y ou in terms of your candidacy and the like,
but tell us a little bit about what it's like to be out on the road and
what sustains you?

John Delaney : Well, I mean, I just find these issues are important and I'm about to
launch a tour whe re we focus on entre preneurship and innovation in
the rural econ omy, something that I think is very important. Really
talking about the issues that mat ter is, what sustains me .

Margaret Flinter: We've been speak ing today with former Maryland Congressman , J ohn
Delaney , a candi date for the 2020 Democratic presidential
nomination. You can learn more about his campaign platform and his
vision for the future by going to johndelaney .co m , or follow him on
twitter @ J ohn Delaney . Congressman, thank you so much for your
commitment to imp roving the public go od and for joining us today on
Conversations on Health Care .

John Delaney : Great . Thank y ou very much.

Mark Masselli: Conversations on Health Care , we want our audience to be truly and
to know when it comes to the facts about healthcare reform and
policy. Lori Robertson is an award winning journalist and Managing
Editor of FactCheck.org, a non - partisan, non - profit consumer
advocate for voters that aim to reduce the level of deception in U.S.
politics. Lori, what have you got for us this week ?

Lori Robertson: President Donald Trump has repeatedly criticized energy efficient

Congressman John Delaney

light bulbs, saying that people are being forced to use b ulbs that are
more expensive and contain hazardous gases and give off light that's
not as good as incandesce nce .

Experts, however, say that's an outdated and Inaccurate description
of the current technology. Trump spoke in early September about his
administration's decision to reverse a 2017 rule that would have
extended energy efficien cy standards to irregularly shaped b ulb and
prohibited the sale s of most traditional incandescent. He said that
people were being forced to buy b ulb that were, “ very dangerous
with all of the gases. ” He added, “ it's considered almost like a waste
site. ”

Trump's comments apply to som e degree to compact fluor escent or
CFL bulbs, which contain mercury ; but light - emitting diode or LED
bulbs are the dominant environmentally - friendly technology. They
have no such safety risks and in most cases, provide comparable or
even superior light at a cheaper lifetime costs than incandescence.

CFL s work by exciting mercury molecules to produce ultraviolet light ,
b ecause mercury is a neurotoxin, it does mean that if a bulb is broken,
special steps should be taken during cleanup.

The Environmental Pro tection Agency recommends airing out the
room for five to 10 minutes , before carefully collecting and placing
any glass fragments into a glass jar , until the b ulb can be taken to a
recycling center. The mercury issue is a legitimate drawback to CFL,
but no one is compelled to buy them over LED ’s , whic h do not contain
mercury or any other hazardous gases. That's my Fact Check for this
week. I'm Lori Robertson , M anag ing E ditor of Fact check.org .

Female : FactCheck.org is committed to factual accuracy from the c ountry ’ s
major political players and is a project of the Annenberg Public Policy
Center at the University of Pennsylvania. If you have a fact that you ’ d
like checked, e - mail us at chcradio.com we ’ ll have FactCheck.or g ’ s Lori
Robertson check it out for you , here on Conversations on Health Care .

[Music]

Mark Masselli : Each week Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to make
wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives. Currently,
some 30 million Ameri cans have Type 2 Diabetes and that number is
expected to climb substantially in the coming decades.

Amazon , the creator of the interactive voice technology known as
Alexa and pharmaceutical entity, Merck teamed up to launch a
competition for developers to create a tool using existing technology
that would help fol ks better manage their diabetes. T he winner,
Sugarp od .

Congressman John Delaney

Anne Weiler : T he challenge was how do you help someone newly diagnosed with
Type 2 Diabetes and we already had interactive care plans for peo ple
with Type 2 Diabetes , they we r e mobile and then we thought, w ell,
sure we can voice - enable those care plans. What we thought that was
the most interesting was the integrated care plan that included a
device , which is a voice powered scale a nd foot scan ner that looks for
diabetic foot ulcers and we thought that the scale was a nice way of
fitting into a routine that someone already had in their day

Mark Masselli : CEO , Anne Weiler says they were intrigued by the opportunity to
incorporate Alexa’s voice t echnology, along with some simple
technologies that exist , but had never been put together .

Anne Weiler: The three components are voice - enabled scale and foot scanner, a
mobile care plan , because voice isn't always the best interface and
then a voice inter action that could happen with any sort of Alexa
dev ice .

Mark Masselli : Chief Technology Officer , Mike Vance , Nolanb erg [PH] said creating a
user - friendly interface was important a nd they got great feedback
from consumers.

Mike: Yes , but anytime you want to do interventions on people that are
already kind of well, you need to have very low touch, lightweight
interactions, things that don't interfere with a person's life and can
kind of gently nudge the m in the right direction.

Mark Masselli : While weights ar e meas ured and feet photographed, Alexa offers
suggestions for weig ht management diet and exercise. Sugarpod is
simple constructed , Alexa enabled weight and foot ulcer scanner that
empowers newly diagnosed diabetes patients better manage their
disease, pro viding a flow of important clinical information, leading to
better diabetes management for patients and providers. Now that's a
bright idea. You've been listening to Conversations on Health Care ,
I'm Mark Masselli.

Margaret Flinter: I'm Margaret F l i nter .

M ark Masselli: Peace and health .

Female : Conversations on Health Care is recorded at WESU at Wesleyan
University, streaming live at chcradio.com , iTunes, or wherever you
listen to podcasts.

If you have comments, plea se e - mail us at [email protected], or
find us on Facebook or Twitter. We love hearing from you. This show
is brought to you by the Community Health Center.