Conversations on Health Care Special Radio Interview on the Supreme Court and the Affordable Care Act

This week, CHC’s Conversation on Health Care has a special broadcast about the Supreme Court and the Affordable Care Act.  Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Professor Timothy Jost, Law Professor and Legal Scholar on Public Health Policy and the Affordable Care Act. Professor Jost, a frequent legal contributor to Health Affairs and NPR, discusses the Supreme Court Hearing on the Affordable Care Act; the constitutional implications and the potential outcomes of the Court’s decision on the legality of the individual mandate.

Listen Now!

Conversations on Health Care broadcasts every Sunday afternoon at 4 PM on WNPR, at 4:30 Wednesday on WESU and is available on other stations around the country and as a Podcast on the Conversations on Health Care website.

Given the great importance of the hearings starting today at the Supreme Court, we are making a special version of the podcast available.  Please visit Conversations on Health Care for many other important broadcasts, and if you are not already receiving emails about Conversations on Health Care and would like to, please join our mailing list and make sure the CHC Radio box in the Interests section is checked.

(Music)

Mark Masselli: Welcome to Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.

Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.

Mark Masselli: Well Margaret, it's the end of March and we are having our own
version of March Madness in Washington at the Supreme Court.

Margaret Flinter: That’s right. I think we can officially call this being down to the
final four, four issues heard this week by the Supreme Court regarding the
Affordable Care Act.

Mark Masselli: That’s right, Margaret. The Supreme Court hearings concluded
today on the legality of certain provisions in the Affordable Care Act. Monday’s
arguments looked at whether the fine levied on those who don’t buy insurance by
2014 is actually a fine and not a tax.

Margaret Flinter: And the arguments about the Anti-Injunction Act also seemed
to be bogged down in legalise but the bottom-line appears to be that the court
does want to make a decision on the broader issues related to the Affordable
Care Act and they are going to do it in this session.

Mark Masselli: One of the biggest issues, the Individual Mandate, the part of the
act that requires all Americans to purchase health insurance, dominated
yesterday’s proceedings.

Margaret Flinter: And it did seem that arguments became more heated as time
went on with the lines on the High Court becoming more visible on who is for and
who is against the Individual Mandate. And it seemed pretty clear that Justices
Scalia and Alito are against it.

Mark Masselli: And I will add that it also seems that fellow Conservative, Justice
Thomas, is in step with those two, and we will watch for his final ruling in his
written comments.

Margaret Flinter: The Democratic-appointed justices seemed to be leaning in
favor of the government’s case, not a surprise. But as for Chief Justice Roberts
and Justice Kennedy, well pardon the pun but the jury seems to still be out;
although, we did notice they drilled the government’s legal team pretty hard on
the lack of precedence for using that commerce clause to justify the Individual
Mandate.

Mark Masselli: A little levity is certainly welcome, Margaret. Considering the
contentious nature of this issue, largely due to political ideologies, the High Court
is expected to rule before adjourning in June.

Margaret Flinter: Our guest today, on this show, is an expert and a legal scholar
on the topic of health care legislation and specifically the Affordable Care Act.

Mark Masselli: Timothy Jost is a Professor of Law at Washington and Lee
University, is a regular contributor to the Health Affairs and NPR. Professor Jost
has written extensively about the Affordable Care Act and brings tremendous
insight into the importance of the proceedings this week.

Margaret Flinter: And one aspect of the Affordable Care Act that Professor Jost
is particularly well-versed in is this whole Medicaid expansion provision, which 26
states are arguing against. So we will get to the professor in just a moment. But
no matter what the story, you can find all of our shows and hear more about us
by Googling CHC Radio.

Mark Masselli: And as always, if you have feedback, email us at
www.chcradio.com , we love to hear from you. Before we hear from Professor
Jost, let’s check-in with our producer, Marianne O'Hare, with this week’s Headline
News.

(Music)

Marianne O'Hare: I am Marianne O'Hare with this Headline News. Three
riveting days of testimony in the Supreme Court on the Affordable Care Act have
come to a close. Six hours of testimony covered four main topics, whether the
fine to be levied on those who don’t buy insurance is in fact a tax, whether the
Individual Mandate to order all Americans to buy health insurance is in fact legal,
and whether states should be forced to expand Medicaid to include more low
income residents into their health coverage pool. The High Court will sort
through the myriad arguments for and against and issue a decision on the matter
sometime before adjourning for this summer in June.

One disease expected to exact a huge toll on health care cost is diabetes. 25
million Americans have it and 75 million are expected to have the disease within
a few decades. A new study out shows bariatric surgery, which surgically shrinks
the stomach and reroutes the intestines, is more effective than drug, exercise
and diet therapy alone in overweight or obese adults with out-of-control sugars.
The study found many patients who had surgery, not only lost weight, they saw
their Type 2 Diabetes go away completely and their cholesterol and blood
pressure greatly improved as well. This is the first study comparing different
Type 2 Diabetes protocols.

Former Vice President, Dick Cheney, is recovering from a heart transplant this
week. The 71-year-old has been battling heart disease for decades. Meanwhile,
a recent study out showed kidneys from older donors worked just as well as
those from younger people. The study looked at kidneys donated from folks in
their 60s and the data showed there were no discernable differences in
outcomes. And want to stay on the slim side, you might want to start with that
chocolate under your pillow. Recent study of so-called Chocoholics, people who
crave and regularly eat chocolate, showed many within that group actually have
a lower BMI and average weight than the non-chocolate eaters. Now, that’s
sweet news, indeed. I am Marianne O'Hare with this Headline News.

(Music)

Mark Masselli: Today, we are speaking with Timothy Jost, Law Professor at
Washington and Lee University in Virginia. Professor Jost is an expert in the
Affordable Care Act and Public Health and is a regular contributor to Health
Affairs and NPR. Welcome to Conversations on Health Care.

Timothy Jost: Thank you.

Mark Masselli: Professor, you have been writing extensively about the impact of
the Affordable Care Act, it’s precedent and numerous legal challenges since it's
th
been passed two years ago. And beginning on March 26 , the Supreme Court is
having three days of all arguments about the constitutionality of the Affordable
Care Act. Now much attention has focused in on the Individual Mandate
requiring all Americans to obtain health insurance but the court is hearing
arguments on a number of important issues raised by the act. Off the numerous
legal challenges to the ACA, which ones are being considered this month by the
High Court and can you set the stage for us?

Timothy Jost: Yeah. There have been, as you said, a number of, I think there
were over two dozen cases filed across the country against the Affordable Care
Act. Although the plaintiffs in a number of cases have requested Supreme Court
review, the court’s only hearing one of those cases at this time, and that is the
case brought by the 26 states. That case raises four issues. One of those is the
constitutionality of the minimum coverage requirement, which is usually called
the Individual Mandate. But there are several other questions as well. One of
them is whether a statute called the Tax Anti-Injunction Act, which prohibits the
federal courts from hearing challenges to tax assessments, would bar the court
from even hearing the challenge to the minimum coverage requirement.

Another question is if the minimum coverage requirement is held
unconstitutional, how much of the rest of the statute falls within the severability
question? Perhaps, the most important question for your listeners however, and
perhaps even more important than the minimum coverage requirement question
is the challenge to the Medicaid expansion. The states are arguing that

Congress cannot constitutionally require them to expand their Medicaid programs
to cover all adults who have incomes below 133% of the poverty level which is
what the Affordable Care Act does. And if the court should uphold that challenge,
it would put many federal programs at risk including frankly the rest of the
Medicaid program. So I think that’s perhaps the most serious question being
considered by the court because it really goes to the heart of our federalism and
calls into question pretty much the way the Federal Government has operated
since the new deal, and in particular, health care programs.

Margaret Flinter: Professor Jost, obviously these are complex and historical
legal precedents for the arguments on both sides of the issues. And certainly
Federal District Court Judge Robert Vinson, who decided in favor of the 26 dates,
opposing the legality of the Affordable Care Act said, essentially, the Congress
can't make you eat broccoli. Maybe you can give us a sense of what are the key
arguments for why it is or isn’t constitutional and how do you expect they will
frame it?

Timothy Jost: In our federal system, Congress has limited powers. And the
justice department is defending the Individual Mandate, the minimum coverage
requirement, claiming that it was properly adopted under the power of Congress
to regulating our state commerce and also Congress’ power to tax and spend
supplemented by the necessary and proper cause. Since the new deal, the
Supreme Court has interpreted these powers very broadly, and what the Federal
Government is arguing is that Congress really needed to adopt the minimum
coverage requirement first to make the rest of insurance reforms work. You can't
require insurers to insure everybody if only sick people show up to buy
insurance. They also are arguing that it's necessary to make our health care
system work because right now we have millions of people who are uninsured.
When they get sick, they can go to emergency rooms, they can get care and that
care is sometimes paid for them but often not and the rest of us end up paying
for it. The states argue and the NFIB argues that Congress has never before
required Americans to purchase products in a private market and that it doesn’t
have the authority to do so. And therefore this is not within the Commerce
Clause power of Congress. And also that it isn’t a tax. It's enforced through a
penalty not a tax and therefore it's not authorized under Congress’ power to tax
and spend.

Mark Masselli: Professor Jost, in the major case being argued before the court,
the Eleventh Circuit stated that the individual mandate was unconstitutional but it
could be severed from the rest of the law, which was constitutional. Explain to
our listeners what would happen next if parts of the Affordable Care Act are
overturned while other parts are left in place.

Timothy Jost: I think that if the court finds any part, either the individual mandate
or the Medicaid expansions to be unconstitutional, it's extremely unlikely to strike
down the entire statute. It will probably leave the rest of the statute in place. If

the court finds the minimum coverage requirement to be unconstitutional, the
Federal Government at least has argued that the Guaranteed Issue and
Community Rating Requirements would fall with it. If that happens of course we
will be left with a situation pretty much like we have now except that more people
will have premium tax credits to pay for their insurance. If they strike down only
the Individual Mandate, the effect of that would probably be that fewer people
would be insured but that sicker people would be insured and therefore health
insurance would cost more for everybody.

Margaret Flinter: Professor, I understand there are also numerous amicus briefs
amicus briefs that have been filed either for or against the Affordable Care Act.
How significant will these amicus briefs be do you think in terms of the Supreme
Court’s final decision, and from your perspective, which ones present the most
interesting and compelling arguments?

Timothy Jost: Frankly, I think the two that are most interesting and compelling
are the two that I worked on. One of them was a brief that was filed on behalf of
several dozen historians of health care policy and that brief was focused on a
claim of the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals that health care regulation and
health insurance regulation was traditionally the role of the states and the
Federal Government had not been previously much involved in it. Of course
anybody in health care knows that that’s nonsense; the Federal Government has
been heavily involved in regulating health care and health insurance for decades
now. So we took issue with that. On the Medicaid expansion argument, I helped
to write a brief on behalf of over 60 religious organizations including some major
American denominations, Jewish groups, Catholic groups, even Muslim and
Buddhist groups, coming out in support of the expansions of Medicaid, saying
that this is really something that’s morally important for us as a society to
undertake, to provide health care for our poor citizens. And it's interesting to me
that all of the coverage that has been given to the religious questions raised by
the contraception mandate, this brief has received virtually no attention. But
there are many briefs, some of them filed by academics, some by politicians, and
I frankly think they probably are not going to have a major impact. There are so
many of them, I would expect that some of them won't even be read.

Mark Masselli: Professor Jost, let’s talk about the makeup of the High Court.
Certainly the Roberts Court is commonly viewed as having a conservative
leaning. Based on previous opinions, how do you anticipate the members of the
court will come down on issues such as Congressional powers, executive branch
powers, federalist point of view involved in these cases and who are the critical
or possible swing justices we should be keeping an eye on?

Timothy Jost: Well I think it's pretty clear how a few of the justices are going to
vote. I think everybody would be amazed if Justice Thomas ruled for the
government, at least on every issue. On the other hand, the four democratic
appointees I think are quite likely to support the administration. With respect to

the others however, I think that all of them are in play and I think it could be a 5:4
decision but I think it could very well be an 8:1 or 7:2 or 6:3 decision.

Margaret Flinter: We are speaking today with Washington and Lee University
Law Professor Timothy Jost, an expert on health law and the Affordable Care Act.
Professor Jost, obviously, it doesn’t need to be said that this is one of the most
politically charged issues that the Supreme Court has faced in recent history. So,
how do you see this current political climate around health care reform impacting
how the High Court is going to approach this issue?

Timothy Jost: Well I think that the political climate is really important. The nation
is very deeply divided over the Affordable Care Act. When you ask Americans
about particular provisions of the Affordable Care Act, they are very supportive of,
for example, getting rid of preexisting condition clauses or insuring adult children
up to the age of 26. But polling shows that Americans really oppose the
minimum coverage requirement. And the court is not immune from political
considerations. They read the newspapers just like the rest of us do. But I think
the court’s legitimacy is also under challenge. I think it suffered a lot from the
decision in Bush v . Gore and frankly, the decision in Citizens United I think has
done a lot of damage to our political system and I think the legitimacy of the court
as a completely fair and impartial decision making is really in question. So I think
that a 5:4 decision right now either for or against the statute would be not a good
thing for the court. And I expect that Chief Justice Roberts will do what he can to
avoid that kind of result, which I think makes it more likely the statute will be
uphill than be struck down.

Mark Masselli: Professor Jost, I want to pull the thread on that a little because it
was this issue right now before an election, could they have deferred on this for a
while or was there importance to get this resolved this year?

Timothy Jost: Everyone is saying that they are going to wait till June to decide
and they usually do decide major cases in the last week of the term, which this
year would be the very end of June. On the other hand, because of the
considerations that you point out, I would not be at all surprised if they decide this
case in April or May. So I think that given the fact that we are in an election year,
given the fact that everything is hanging in terms of state implementation of this
statute until this case gets decided, I would not be surprised if we get actually a
quite early decision from the court.

Margaret Flinter: Professor, you are based in the State of Virginia, which just
th
became the 8 state in the nation to require ultrasounds before a woman can
obtain an abortion and certainly we are seeing the battle over access to
contraception grow more and more heated over these last couple of months as it
relates to directives from the Affordable Care Act. So it appears as if women’s
health is one of the emerging or has emerged as a battleground in the health

care debate. What do you see as the coming conflicts as we move past the
Supreme Court decision?

Timothy Jost: I think the biggest decision facing us and really I think much more
important than the Supreme Court decision is the election. If the Republicans
sweep the House Senate and the Presidency, that’s probably the end of the
Affordable Care Act in a much more decisive way than if the Supreme Court
decides that one or two provisions of the statute are unconstitutional. On the
other hand, if President Obama is reelected, and the Supreme Court doesn’t do
any major damage to the statute, I think we will probably see it implemented. So
I think that at this point after the Supreme Court decision, everything moves to
the political arena and everything is going to hang on what happens next
November.

Margaret Flinter: Once again, the most important election of our lifetimes as we
seem to say every four years.

Timothy Jost: Yeah.

Mark Masselli: Professor, the Obama Administration has just released a much
anticipated final rule for operating state-run health insurance exchanges as part
of the Affordable Care Act. And states are being given specific guidelines on
forming these insurance markets for the uninsured. Can you inform our viewers
about why the final rule came out and then your observations about the final
rule?

Timothy Jost: Well the final rule is 650 pages long including the preamble and
the regulation itself. And I frankly spent all night reading it and writing a blog post
that just went up on Health Affairs. So if somebody wants to know what I think of
it, they can go to www.healthaffairs.org . I think it's a pretty good rule. I think that
470 pages of the preamble are responses to the 24,000 comments that they
received on the proposed rule and I think they considered them very carefully
and came up with a rule that on the whole, I have quibbles with it, but on the
whole that’s pretty good job of setting out what the states need to do. The
problem is that the states don’t seem to be eager to do it and I frankly think that
st
on January 1 , 2014, most states in this country are going to have a federal
exchange, which is ironic because that’s what the House bill provided to begin
with but the Senate bill provided the state-run exchanges and it looks like the
states aren't right now eager to take on that responsibility.

Mark Masselli: And it breaks down by red state/blue state in some ways.

Timothy Jost: Well it does but even some of the blue states don’t seem to be
moving very quickly. And a few of the red states are moving ahead but you are
right, it does mainly break down that way. I think that after 2014 that many of the

states will transition to a state exchange but I don’t think many states are going to
st
be ready to go on January 1 .

Margaret Flinter: Professor, we like to ask all of our guests this final question.
When you look around the country and world, what do you see in terms of health
care policy innovation and who should our listeners at Conversations be keeping
an eye on?

Timothy Jost: Well I mean I have been keeping my eye focused very, very
narrowly on implementation of the Affordable Care Act for the last couple of years
and haven’t been looking too much more broadly as to what's happening around
the world. I mean I think the really big problem that we have to face, some extent
faced in the Affordable Care Act but we need to do more, is the cost of health
care. It's just rapidly becoming unaffordable to individuals, to employers, to the
government to everybody and that’s the big challenge. It's a challenge that other
countries have been much more successful than we have been in holding down
costs overall and I think we as a world need to figure out how we are going to
eventually bring those under control.

Mark Masselli: We have been speaking today with Professor Timothy Jost from
Washington and Lee College of Law, a regular contributor to Health Affairs and
expert in the Affordable Care Act. You can find links to his writings at our website
www.chcradio.com . Professor, thank you so much for joining us today.

Timothy Jost: Thank you for this opportunity.

(Music)

Mark Masselli: At Conversations on Health Care, we want our audience to be
truly in the know when it comes to the facts about health care reform and policy.
Lori Robertson is an award winning journalist and managing editor of
FactCheck.org, a nonpartisan, nonprofit consumer advocate for voters that aim to
reduce the level of deception in US politics. Lori, what have you got for us this
week?

Lori Robertson: Well Mark and Margaret, we have seen plenty of false and
misleading claims about the Massachusetts health care overhaul, especially
since former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney has been campaigning for
the Republican nomination. For instance, Romney has been saying that the
people who gained insurance since he signed the law have sought “private
insurance” not government insurance. But that’s not exactly true. Some people
have purchased private plans but the law that he signed also expanded
Medicaid. And on the other side of this, critics of the law such as Pennsylvania
Senator Rick Santorum have wrongly said that the plan was “a government-run
health care system”. And that claim or something very similar to it has been
made about the federal health care law as well and it's not true. Neither of these

laws, the state law or the federal law creates a government-run system in which
the government is the insurer or the provider of health care, something like you
would have in Britain or Canada. Instead, both these laws say people have to
have insurance and that greatly expands business for the private insurance
companies. The way the numbers break down in Massachusetts, more than
400,000 people have gained coverage since that law was passed in 2006; more
than half of them have private insurance, many of them with the help of subsidies
and the rest of them have joined the state’s Medicaid or Children’s Health
Insurance Programs. Now the 47% who have joined those two programs, that’s
not all due to the law, the struggling economy has played a big role in boosting
those numbers just as it has in all states. But still, this wasn’t a government
takeover, as Santorum says, and it also wasn’t a plan that relied only on private
insurance as Romney has claimed. So those are some of the big claims that we
are seeing on the Massachusetts plan.

Margaret Flinter: FactCheck.org is committed to factual accuracy from the
country’s major political players and is a project of the Annenberg Public Policy
Center at the University of Pennsylvania. If you have a fact that you would like
checked, email us www.chcradio.com , we will have FactCheck.org’s Lori
Robertson check it out for you here on Conversation on Health Care.

(Music)

Margaret Flinter: Each week Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives. The checklist has
become something of a buzzword in hospitals in recent years, the idea being that
running down a checklist of tasks, much as a pilot does preflight, can greatly
reduce medical errors. While hospitals and medical practices have been
adopting guidelines for these checklists for a while, there wasn’t a similar
protocol for patients until now. Elizabeth Bailey’s 81-year-old father had a series
of experiences that caused her to create The Patient’s Checklist. He was put on
strong steroid medication for presumed diagnosis, but when the diagnosis was
disproven, the meds weren’t discontinued. By the time he was readmitted to the
hospital with steroid-induced psychosis, he had a number of other complications
caused by the medication. And during a month long hospital odyssey that
ensued, frequently errors were made and ultimately he just walked out of the
hospital one day. But Bailey and her sisters didn’t censor the hospital or file a
lawsuit. Instead, they decided to do something proactive to help families and
patients be better masters of their own health care experience, and she
developed The Patient’s Checklist, a book of 10 checklists that addresses many
of the essentials for a safe hospital stay, how to manage your medications, how
to make your hospital stay safer and more comfortable and planning for your
discharge. Bailey sees the checklist not as an intrusion on the health care facility
but as a guideline for patients and families. She says The Patient’s Checklist
starts from the place of we all have the same goal, the best possible outcome for

this patient. A patient’s checklist to help patients and families achieve successful
outcomes in the hospital setting, now that’s a bright idea.
(Music)
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan
University at WESU, streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.