Dr. Jeffery Brenner, Executive Director of the Camden Coalition of Healthcare Providers
This week, Mark and Margaret speak with Dr. Jeffery Brenner
, Founder and Executive Director of the Camden Coalition of Healthcare Providers. Dr. Brenner speaks about the data-driven, “hotspotter” approach he developed to reduce health care costs by indentifying high-use patients and more effectively and efficiently addressing their multiple needs.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: Well Margaret, it’s certainly been a week of upheaval around
the globe with unrest springing up throughout the Middle East.
Margaret Flinter: Well, our hearts go out to the victims of the tragic events in
Libya and the protests in other countries, which all show us and remind us just
how precarious this situation is in our boost Arab spring world.
Mark Masselli: International politics have briefly redirected the focus on the
presidential campaign but healthcare continues to be a primary topic in the
ongoing analysis of the two candidates.
Margaret Flinter: And I thought it was interesting to note, Mark, that there was no
discernible bump in ratings reportedly for Nick Romney after the GOP
Convention. A week after the democratic convention, President Obama has
made some gains and, I think, particularly as it pertained to healthcare.
Mark Maselli: Well, your right. Several recent polls show the President with a
sizable lead over his challenger. When it comes to healthcare a recent CNN poll
showing Mr. Obama with a nine point lead.
Margaret Flinter: And a Ritter’s poll that actually gave the President a 14% lead
when voters were asked who they felt was the best candidate for their
healthcare. Though I also note, that Nick Romney there are some aspects that
he might keep.
Mark Maselli: That was before he said he wouldn’t keep them. No, can’t say
that. Mr. Obama has also pulled out a lead in swing states like Florida,
Wisconsin, Ohio on the question of healthcare.
Margaret Flinter: And the analysis are saying, Mark, that people are maybe are
starting to appreciate some of the benefits of the Affordable Care Act, appreciate
them directly. So the message from the Romney and Ryan camp about rekindling
the act maybe doesn’t sound so appealing anymore.
Mark Maselli: I think your right and our guest today can shed some light on
some of the key difference on each candidate’s platform as it pertains to
healthcare, as well as how the healthcare wall will proceed beyond the election.
Margaret Flinter: Sarah Kliff is Senior Health Correspondent for the Washington
Post and for Want Plug Name [01:48]. She’s been closely covering the
intersection of politics and healthcare for a number of years.
Mark Maselli: And speaking of intersections, we’ll get another update from
FactCheck.org’s Lorie Robertson.
Margaret Flinter: And just a reminder, you can hear all of our shows by Googling
CHC Radio.
Mark Maselli: And it’s always if you have comments, e-mail at us
CHCradio.com or find us on Facebook or Twitter. We’d love to hear from you.
Margaret Flinter: And we’ll get to our interview with Washington Post Sara Cliff in
just a moment.
Mark Maselli: But first, here’s our producer, Marianne O’Hare, with this weeks
Headline News.
[Music]
Marianne O’Hare: I’m Marianne O’Hare with this Headline News. The
polls continue to assess the aftermath of the two recent political conventions and
it appears as though healthcare, though a decisive issue, seems to be having a
positive effect on the Obama campaign. Several polls showing President Obama
with at least a ten point lead when voters are asked which President will be better
when it comes to their healthcare. Another rather conflicting poll shows, though,
that there is still some confusion over the health reform law itself. Kiser
Foundation poll showed that while 36% of those polled were in favor of the
Affordable Care Act, 43% said they were against it, even though a majority holds
several measures of the law in a favorable light. Recent census information that
came up had some good news. Fewer Americans are without health insurance in
2010, however the change was only slight. The biggest increase in those insured
were young adults being allowed to stay on their parent’s plan until age 26 under
the Affordable Care Act. But what about the undocumented young adults living in
the US. White House released a statement this week that those illegal aliens who
were brought here and raised as children can file for citizenship but their not
entitled to healthcare provisions under the Affordable Care Act until they’re
actually naturalized. And childhood obesity isn’t natural but it’s growing at an
alarming rate in this country. A study just out in the Journal of American Medicine
shows a link between high levels of BPA, that’s Bisphenol A used in many
packaging products and higher rates of obesity. Numerous studies have shown
BPA disrupts multiple metabolic processes. The FDA recently banned the use of
BPA’s in baby bottles and sippy cups but not in things used by older children like
food packing and aluminum cans. I’m Marianne O’Hare with this Headline News.
[Music]
Mark Maselli: We’re speaking today with Sarah Kliff, veteran health blogger
and health policy report for the Washington Post. She’s the Health Editor for
Post’s daily blog Wonk Blog. Ms. Kliff has covered the healthcare industry
extensively and she was co-author of the Political PULTS, Politico’s Daily Health
Policy Briefing. She covered the 2008 presidential campaign for News Week.
She’s been awarded several reporting fellowships from the Kiser Family
Foundation and the USC Annenberg School of Journalism. Her work has
appeared in National Geographic and BBC, as well as numerous other
publications and broadcast outlet. Ms. Kliff, welcome to Conversations on
Healthcare.
Sarah Kliff: Great, thank you for having me.
Mark Maselli: Sarah, the presidential election season is in full swing now and
healthcare and Medicare, two issues that keep on giving in this politically
charged environment. And while the Affordable Care Act is now the law of the
land, republicans said they will immediately repeal the law if elected to the White
House. What’s most likely to happen as a result of different election scenarios?
Sarah Kliff: Right, you know I think it matters a lot kind of who’s in each
branch of the government. If, you know President Obama wins the election, you
know it’s the easiest to game out. If you have a President Romney and a
democratic Senate it, you know, once again, becomes pretty difficult to change
anything. You know you would need to get, you know the majority of senators on
board to, you know pull off and repeal. It is one situation where, you know Nick
Romney could get some legs with repeal would be is if the republicans won the
Senate. So you have republican control of the Presidency, the Senate, and the
House, which was the situation when democrats passed their health reform law.
You know in that situation, you know there are parts of the law they can repeal
but actually getting rid of the entire thing is still really hard. So even if you got
control of every branch of government, there’s still some hurdles. So, you know
we’ve heard Governor Romney talk a little bit about repealing the healthcare law
on day one. Most folks here in Washington will tell you just because of the
logistics of this city, that’s impossible. But they definitely if, you know republicans
control the congress and the Presidency, they could dismantle some big chunks
of the law.
Margaret Flinter: So Sarah, we’re looking at the Affordable Care Act and
thinking, huh, 2014 fully up and running but really multiple pieces of it already
implemented or well on their way. Maybe looking a little more broadly than that,
what do you think the lay of the land in the United States would have to be
politically for repeal of the Affordable Care Act?
Sarah Kliff: Yeah, you know that’s a good question. The doable number of
states that, you know really like the Affordable Care Act and, you know the ones
that come to mind for me are California and Maryland. They’ve been really
aggressive in putting a lot of Federal money and some of their own money
towards, you know implementing the law. Setting up these new healthcare
market places called Exchanges and, you know you could see some of them,
even if Congress starts going back to the law on a Federal level, saying, you
know maybe we’ll go the way of Massachusetts. Maybe we’ll, you know just do
this on our own. The financing becomes a little difficult. They’re initially relying on
the Federal Government for all the money to pay for the insurance expansions.
So they would have to do that on their own. So, you know even repeal here in
Washington, you know might not mean repeal everywhere across the country just
because, you know, as you mentioned, there’s always been so much work done
towards the Affordable Care Act. So you could see, you know each state
becoming it’s own little healthcare laboratory and kind of trying out some new
approaches.
Mark Maselli: Walk us through the, you know there are a lot of charges going
back and forth and Medicare is clearly a front and center in the debate. And the
republican camp continues to accuse the President of cutting $700 billion from
Medicare and, yet if you were to read the Ryan budget plan it wouldn’t be that
dissimilar, at least in the dollar amounts, to the President’s but can you sort of
shed light on – maybe do a little fact check for us on this.
Sarah Kliff: Yes, for sure. You know I think the place to start is with what
the healthcare law actually did. And, you know Paul Ryan and Nick Romney are
right. The healthcare law did reduce Medicare spending by $716 billion and that’s
a number I’m sure we’re going to keep hearing. How it did this is is it basically
reduced how much hospitals and private plans, these plans called Medicare
Advantage, that paid. So it gave essentially a pay cut to the hospitals and gave a
pay cut to these Medicare Advantage providers. And, you know the hospitals, you
know they obviously don’t like taking a pay cut but, you know they’ve decided it
would be okay. And the reason they did that is because of the health law’s
insurance expansion. They’re [ inaudible 08:25] of 32 million new customers with
health insurance. So on the balance, you know while they’re getting paid a little
less per customer, there’s going to be huge influx of customers. So that’s why
hospitals decided, you know what this is an okay deal. We’re going to sign up for
this and support the healthcare law. On the Medicare Advantage side, those
private plans that take care of about one-quarter of the Medicare patients right
now, those, you know as you point out, Representative Ryan and his position as
the Chairman of the Budget Committee did include those cuts in his 2013 budget.
There, you know he doesn’t dispute that. However, you know the Romney, Ryan
campaign now says, you know if they were to come into office, they would repeal
those cuts. They’re saying they’re not going to do what the Ryan budget says
here.
Margaret Flinter: Let’s, maybe then, look over to the other side of the entitlement
world and look at Medicaid for a minute, which, of course, is scheduled to be
expanded to include coverage for more Americans of low income or of those
living near the poverty line under the Affordable Care Act. And if there’s one thing
this whole debate over the last year has done, I think more Americans know the
difference between Medicaid and Medicare than ever before. But that’s one
where it seems to be there are really clear differences between what the Obama
plan is for Medicaid and what the Romney plan, or from the Ryan budget plan
would introduce. Maybe you could sort of clarify those differences between the
two parties for Medicaid and also maybe talk about CHIP, which is really quite
popular in the states insurance coverage for America’s children.
Sarah Kliff: Yeah, you know one interesting thing that I think gets a little bit
lost in this debate is that Obama and Representative Ryan’s budget, they’ve
actually proposed spending the exact same amount on Medicare. They both
want to see it grow at the exact same rate, they just have different ways of
cutting it to get there. Right now each state gets a set amount of money for each
Medicaid enrollee. What the Ryan budget proposes and, you know it’s a lot of
republicans here in Washington support, it giving states a lump sum. And what
they like about that approach is it makes Medicaid spending much more
predictable. We know how much we’re going to spend. We’re able to control it
better. And it gives states and incentive to really think up better ways to deliver
care. All of a sudden, you know there’s an incentive for them to save money that
there really wasn’t before. The concern from Medicaid advocates is that, you
know states will save money by scimping on benefits. So that’s, you know that’s
a very stark difference between what the Obama administration would do and
what a Romney administration would do on Medicaid. The Obama administration,
you know has caught against block granting. It’s specifically opposed it. It, you
know sees Medicaid continuing in its form right now and, as you mentioned,
actually expanding, becoming a lot bigger in 2014 instead of kind of a
hodgepodge that we have right now.
Mark Maselli: We’re speaking today with Sarah Kliff, Health Policy Report for
the Washington Post, health analyst for the Post Wonk Blog. She’s the former
author of Political PULTS, Politico’s Daily Health Policy Report and also coverage
of Biden for News Week in the 2008 election. Ms. Kliff is keeping a close eye on
the current presidential election. Analyzing how the outcomes could impact
health reform in this country. Sarah, I’m a little confused about the GOP heath
platform because on one hand it’s Romney who’s running for President and it
seems like he conveniently grabs the Ryan plan when he wants to. So what are
you doing as a reporter in trying to tease this out because it – it’s – it can’t be that
convenient for – he hasn’t clearly articulated that it is completely one that he
would put forward.
Sarah Kliff: You know it’s a little bit difficult as a reporter, you know with the
Affordable Care Act we have a 2000 page law to look at. So we know very, very
specifically what President Obama, you know wanted to do for our healthcare,
what someone is doing with our healthcare system. We know exactly, you know
how he would change Medicare because he did it and we have it in writing and
that’s what we’re doing right now. And that’s kind of how we understand, you
know what exactly is happening. On – the problem inside is a little more difficult
because, you know Romney and the republican party and their platform has
embraced a structure like the Ryan budget. But there’s a lot of really important
specifics that, you know we don’t know and I don’t know that we’ll find out by the
end of this campaign. So, you know, I think on my part, we just keep asking as
many questions as we can, trying to find out as much as we can but I think it’s
kind of an inherent in the fact we have a President who passed the law and the
Governor with a proposal that, you know they’re not exactly on equal playing
fields in terms of the details we’re getting.
Margaret Flinter: Sarah, no matter who wins in November, one of the prizes that
they’re going to find, if you will, it’s a problem that goes to whoever wins and
that’s dealing with this Medicare reimbursement formula that Congress set over a
decade ago. We’ve talked about it a few times on the show. It’s a formula that
reimburses the providers who treat Medicare patients for the care they give. And
we’ve gotten used to kind of lurching from crisis to crisis for emergency votes.
Nobody has really stepped forward with, I don’t know if this is the political
courage or the knowledge of the solution to over hall the system. So, from your
perspective, where do we stand with that Medicare reimbursement formula that I
am reminded that ten thousand baby boomers per day are aging into that
Medicare system. So kind of urgent that this gets fixed.
Sarah Kliff: Yeah. Yeah, you know it’s a big problem and, you know it
happens every year and it’s a problem that Washington created and now can’t
seem to fix. Back in the 1990’s we set a specific formula to pay for Medicare.
Unfortunately, that formula has worked out to less money than what it would cost
to cover all our seniors since about 2001 or so. And, you know it comes down to
the wire there somewhere, it just creates a lot of uncertainty. We’re at the point
now if Congress doesn’t pass a doc fix that doctors across the country would see
their reimbursement rates fall by about 27%. So we’re talking about, you know a
lot of money. And, you know I think it’s actually the money that’s the big obstacle
fixing anything here in Washington. Right now if we wanted to, you know fix the
doc fix, say, you know this isn’t going to be another problem for the decade. It
would cost $245 billion. Finding the money in Washington is not very easy right
now. And that’s why you see, you know year after year, sometimes even at a
month or two of length, that we passed maybe a $10 billion fix or a $20 billion fix.
It is easier to get through then, you know something that costs in the hundreds of
billions of dollars range.
Mark Maselli: You know Sarah’s speaking about doc fix, you’ve written about
another type of doc fix that’s needed and that’s the projected shortfall of primary
care physicians in the country, especially after 2014 when tens of millions of
Americans will be added into the primary care poll. But I think people who follow
the healthcare new will be a little confused with the fact that also more medical
schools are opening now than at anytime in the last hundred years. So how do
we get into this pickle and what are the solutions to the shortage of primary care
physicians?
Sarah Kliff: Right. So I guess some people won’t be surprised to hear this
is another problem that Congress does play a hand in. Back in 1997 they passed
a law that limited the number of residencies that Medicare would fund. Medicare
has traditionally funded most of our graduate medical education. And, you know
with some sense these are the doctors who are going to be seeing our seniors
and it’s really expensive to train doctors. It costs about $145,000 to just – for the
residency. Anyway, back in 1997 we passed a law that said Medicare would only
fund a set amount of residencies and we have not increased that cap since. Our
population is getting older, ten thousand people hitch on to Medicare each day.
You know at the same time you do see a growing interest among students in
going into medicine. More medical schools are opening up, as you mentioned but
we’re running into a bottle neck with our residency program where medical
school’s actually wanting to expand even more but not doing it because, you
know they didn’t want their doctors to be out of work when they graduated
because there weren’t enough residencies. And, you know there’s a lot of
different ideas about how to fix this. One, you know that is the most simplistic, but
is also the least realistic, is getting Congress to increase the residency cap. And
there is legislation to do that. There’s some other thinking about, you know
integrating nurse-practitioner and the physician assistants and other folks in the
medical space better into the system, have them provide a lot of our primary care
to kind of lesson the burden on doctors a little bit.
Margaret Flinter: Sarah, in all of our conversations so far we’ve come back to
money and cost containment, a different way of looking at money is obviously,
but what are your thoughts on the cost containment measures in President
Obama’s healthcare law? Certainly one of the things that the architects of the bill
laid out was accountable care organizations, which seem to be growing, not just
for Medicare, but for other populations as well. What about that as a cross
containment measure versus any cost containment measures in the Ryan budget
other than, you know eligibility for the programs and how much we pay people?
Sarah Kliff: Yes, the cost containment looks really different in both, in
Obama in the healthcare law and the Ryan budget. The Ryan budget, you know
would ultimately end up using, you know premium support to kind of bring down
the cost of Medicare. In the Affordable Care Act, you know as you mentioned,
you do see accountable care organizations, which are meant to kind of change
the incentives in healthcare and give doctors an incentive to, you know provide
the best quality care rather than the highest quantity of care. Yeah, I think right
now the verdict is still out. You know the accountable care organizations are
really new. They might be like about a year or so in right now and it’s going to be
a little while until we understand, you know if these are really producing results
that are, you know shifting costs down and if that’s a permanent change. You
know I think a lot of people think back to the 1990’s and the rise of the HMO’s
and the three or four years we saw there of kind of lower cost growth. I think it’s
still going to be a few years though before we know if, you know all those
anecdotes really mean something is changing in how we deliver healthcare.
Mark Maselli: Sarah, it seems like candidates in the GOP side in this election
are capitalizing on the sense of uncertainty about how the Affordable Care Act is
going to impact the business community and you’ve recently wrote an article
about a survey of over 500 companies and what their plans were once the
healthcare law is fully in place. And a lot of conservative pendants are predicting
companies are going to dump their employees. I should note that last week we
had Howard Dean on the show and actually Howard Dean said the same thing.
He says it does not endear me to be in administration.
Sarah Kliff: No.
Mark Maselli: Is this prediction born at the survey you looked at?
Sarah Kliff: You know and I think, you know what was unique about this
survey was just very large businesses. We’re talking about anyone with over
1000 employees. And those are the ones you’d expect to continue offering
insurance, I think, because, you know they’ve been doing it for a decades, you
know.
Mark Maselli: He was clearly talking about the smaller ones.
Sarah Kliff: Right. So I think the ones that are more at the center of the
debate are these ones, let’s say with under like 50 employees. They’re not
subject to the employer mandate. They’re too big to get any tax credits from the
healthcare law.
Margaret Flinter: Sarah, we’d like to ask all of our guests just this one final
question. When you look around the country, what do you see in terms of
innovation that our listeners at conversations should be keeping an eye on?
Sarah Kliff: I think it goes back to a lot of the cost control work that’s
happening. You know I’ve spent a lot of time talking to some really interesting
hospitals and, you know electronic medical record companies and providers that
are really doing different things that didn’t happen before and that are kind of
enable by some recent changes in our healthcare systems. The rise of
technology and, you know the greater use of electronic records kind of give
doctors resources they didn’t have when they were trying to do capitated and
cost containment care back in the 1990’s. So I think you see a new sweep of
healthcare tools of, you know the ability to monitor outcomes and monitor costs
and see what are the most cost effective treatments. You know really being
employed in a way it hasn’t before. And I think that will be really interesting to see
if that, you know does keep our healthcare costs down or, you know if we’re kind
of in for a 1990’s reflux and we’re going to be seeing, you know higher costs for
us in the future.
Mark Maselli: We’ve been speaking today with Sarah Kliff, veteran Health
Blogger and Health Policy Reporter for the Washington Post. She is the Health
Editor for the Post Daily blog, Wonk Blog. Ms. Kliff is closely monitoring
healthcare issues in the selection. You can find her on Facebook, Twitter, and
Wonk Blog.com. Sarah, thank you so much for joining Conversations on
Healthcare.
[Music]
Mark Maselli: At Conversations on Healthcare, we want our audience to be
truly in the know when it comes to the facts about healthcare reform and policy.
Lori Robertson is an award winning journalist and Managing Editor of
FactCheck.org. a non-partison, non-profit consumer advocate for voters that aim
to reduce the level of deception in US politics. Lori, what have you got for us this
week.
Lori Robertson: Mark and Margaret, a recent add from Nick Romney claims that
the Federal healthcare law taxes wheelchairs but that’s not true. The claim
pertains to an excise tax on certain medical devices and that is part of the law.
The ad says that this 2.3% tax would apply to wheelchairs and pacemakers and
it shows a picture of a manual chair. But both, manual and motorized
wheelchairs, will be exempt from this tax according to treasury department
officials. There is a retail exemption for any device that’s generally purchased by
the public at retail and motorized wheelchairs would be exempt under a similar
provision for customized items. The IRS is now finalizing the proposed rules on
this. The ad is correct, however, in saying that pacemakers would be subject to
the tax. Other devices that would be taxed are cardiac defibrillators spent and
ultrasound equipment. And revenue from this tax is expected to be $20 billion
over ten years. And that’s my Fact Check for this week. I’m Lori Robertson,
Managing Editor of FactCheck.org.
Margaret Flinter: FactCheck.org is committed to factually accuracy from the
countries major political players and is a project of the Annenberg Public Policy
Center at the University of Pennsylvania. If you have a fact that you’d like
checked, e-mail us at CHC Radio.com. We’ll have FactCheck.org Lori Robertson
check it out for you here on Conversations of Healthcare.
[Music]
Margaret Flinter: Each week Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives. Around the world,
two million children die of pneumonia every year and most of these deaths are
preventable. The problem is that most of these children live in developing nations
where access to medical care is a real challenge. A team of students and
researchers at the University of Melbourne decided there had to be a simple
solution for early detection pneumonia that could be put right into the hands of
children’s parents or community health workers, not only in remote settings, but
ultimately anywhere in the world. Their solution, the Stetho Cloud, a peripheral
end app for Smart Phones that puts a stethoscope like diagnostic tool in the
hands of ordinary people. The student team was moved to develop the product
inspired by a professor who explained that most children who died o f pneumonia
could have been saved had there been a timely diagnosis when treatment could
be started.
Team Member: I think the key step is that people are not worried enough at the
start. So let’s say you’re in a developing country, you’re not worried enough, and
the clinic maybe be 30 kilometers away, a whole day’s trek or something. And
you usually don’t take the journey until your child’s very sick and by that stage it’s
almost too late.
Margaret Flinter: Dr. Andrew Lynn, he and his team of developers created this
diagnostic app to process information gathered from a stetho mic, a digital
stethoscope that plugs directly into an iPhone. The device is used to detect
breathing patterns just as a clinician with a stethoscope would do. The Stetho
Cloud app then runs lung capacity reading through a series of algryghms, sends
the information into the Cloud for analysis, and almost instantaneously a
diagnosis can be made. The students won the Australian’s final of Microsoft’s
Imagine Cup 2012. They’re testing and refining the device with the help of the
University Children’s Hospital and hope for a rollout of the product later this year.,
using ingenuity, technology, collective imagination to create the Stetho Cloud; a
simple device that has the potential to save millions of children’s lives. Now that’s
a bright idea.
[Music]
This is Conversations on Healthcare. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Mesalli: And I am Mark Mesalli, peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the Campus of WESU at
Wesleyan University, streaming live at www.wesufm.org , and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.