Dr. John Wennberg, the Peggy Y. Thomson Professor for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences at Dartmouth College.
This week on Conversations on Health Care, Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Dr. John Wennberg whose research for the past 40 years has focused on variations in health care around the country and its implications on the individual, the community and the health care system as a whole. Dr. Wennberg is the Peggy Y. Thomson Professor for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences at Dartmouth and founder and director of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice, home to the Dartmouth Atlas Project.
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare. I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: Margaret, last week we talked about the Supreme Court not
listening an expedited hearing about the Affordable Care Act. This week they
came out and said they won't consider an earlier challenge to the law instead
opting to allow the case to proceed through the normal channels.
Margaret Flinter: And that doesn’t mean that they won't be hearing the case, it
just means they won't be hearing it soon. This has been quite a season for long
delays on almost everything that we expect to see coming out of Washington. So
we will have to watch closely as the case moves through the appellate courts.
Mark Masselli: Hurry, hurry wait, wait and we are often though you are with that
and meanwhile the Supreme Court is hearing another case. That could have an
interesting effect on healthcare and beyond. Vermont passed a law that would
prohibit pharmacies from selling information about which drug doctors prescribe
most to pharmaceutical companies, business implications beyond how
pharmaceutical companies market to doctors since any decision could impact
how other forms of data are gathered and sold.
Margaret Flinter: Well, the pharmaceutical company had its hits over the last
month or so with their progesterone drug to prevent Preterm Labor and now this.
Another topic we have been following closely this made some news reactions to
the proposed restructuring of Medicare in the republican budget proposal. We
were wondering when we would see that reaction.
Mark Masselli: That’s right Margaret, a few weeks ago we were wondering we
are all the town hall meetings with seniors telling their representatives to keep
their hands off of Medicare were and in light to the recent budget proposals put
forth by representative Paul Ryan, which includes privatizing Medicare, well over
the Easter recess. We started hearing the beginning to some rumbling
republican law markers have been back in their home districts and some of them
have really been feeling the heat from their constituents.
Margaret Flinter: And of course I don’t think anybody is surprised by that
certainly entitlement reform especially of Medicare has always been very
politically sensitive and a recent poll from the Washington Post-ABC news found
rd
that hasn’t changed much. The majority of Americans 2/3 still say they want
Medicare to stay the way it is. So convincing the public that the republican
proposal for referring Medicare is a good idea is going to be quite the uphill
battle.
Mark Masselli: And although the republican plan is supposed to privatize
Medicare for the next generation of seniors. It seems like many of the outspoken
seniors of these recent town hall events were skeptical of the republicans’
promise that they would remain protected. This is a big turnaround from the town
hall debates two years ago when President Obama’s healthcare plan was on the
table.
Margaret Flinter: And in these early months of the next presidential campaign – I
think we can now call this the early month of the next presidential campaign – the
president was on the road last week. He was criticizing the republican plan and
the democrats have launched immediate campaign accusing republican house
members of doing away with Medicare and putting retirees in danger.
Mark Masselli: Well healthcare will remain in the bull’s-eye for the campaign last
season and we will keep an eye on it here at Conversations on Healthcare.
Margaret Flinter: And anyway you can cut it what we do know is everybody all
politicians have to be figuring out the best way to reign in healthcare cause and
really that’s on the national agenda for all of us.
Mark Masselli: That leads us to today’s guest. We are happy that Dr. John
Wennberg is here to help us today. Dr. Wennberg is the Peggy Y. Thomson
Professor for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences at Dartmouth College and founder
of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice which houses
the well known Dartmouth Atlas Project. We look forward to speaking with Dr.
Wennberg about his research, which for the past 40 years is focused on
variations in healthcare around the country. And what we can learn from him
about making the healthcare delivery system more equitable and efficient.
Margaret Flinter: We are very glad to have Dr. Wennberg with us today and no
matter what the story you can hear all of our shows on our website chcradio.com .
Subscribe to iTunes and get the show downloaded or if you want to hang on to
our every word and read a transcript of our show, visit us at chcradio.com . And if
you are a social media aficionado, you can become a fan of Conservations on
Healthcare on Facebook, and don’t forget to follow us on Twitter.
Mark Masselli: And as always, if you have feedback, email us at chcradio.com
we would love to hear from you. Before we speak with Dr. Wennberg, let's check
in with our producer Loren Bonner with Headline News.
Loren Bonner: I am Loren Bonner with this week’s Headline News. The First
Family made sure that health and wellness was central in this year’s Annual
Easter Egg Roll.
In addition to listening to some great music and dancing a little bit you can roll
you eggs, you can do some yoga, you can play with some, do some obstacle
courses, play basketball and tennis.
Loren Bonner: Under the theme “Get Up and Go” the festivities on the South
Lawn we are part of First Lady Michele Obama's "Let's Move!” initiative to bring
awareness to health eating and activities for children. The Supreme Court said
they won't consider an early challenge to the healthcare law. Virginia’s request to
expedite the review of the law was turned down by the Supreme Court. It offered
no reasoning and there were no noted descending votes. The Supreme Court’s
usual practice is to consider cases only after an appeals court has ruled. The
court of appeals for the fourth circuit in Richmond, Virginia will hear arguments in
th
the Virginia Case on May 10 . The Department of Health and Human Services
has decided to award quality bonuses to hundreds of Medicare Advantage Plans
th
rated with the average 3 or 3 ½ stars. Roughly 1/4 of Medicare beneficiaries are
enrolled in Medicare Advantage Plans. They are for lower out of pocket costs
and more comprehensive benefits than the traditional program. President
Obama’s healthcare low gradually cuts $145 billion over 10 years from Medicare
Advantage starting in 2012 mostly to correct a problem with overpayments to the
plans. Medicare has classified the bonuses as a demonstration program, relying
on broad legal authority congress gave to the agency to experiment with quality
improvements. The money will come from the Medicare Trust Fund.
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare. Today, we are speaking
with Dr. John Wennberg, the Peggy Y. Thomson Professor for the Evaluative
Clinical Sciences at Dartmouth and Founder and Director Emeritus of the
Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice, as well as the
Founding Editor of the Dartmouth Atlas. His latest book Tracking Medicine: A
Researcher’s Quest to Understand Health Care is published by Oxford Press.
Welcome Dr. Wennberg. In your career for the last 40 years which is chronicled
in your book is focused on the variations and healthcare across the country and
its affects on the health of individual patients. What exactly is the study of
practice variation which you also called the science of healthcare and why have
you found it so important through the years and tell me does my zip code really
matter in the type of in quality of healthcare that I received.
Dr. John Wennberg: Well let me start with the basic observation is that if you
compare the healthcare in one community with another and you take the trouble
to adjust for the different factors that might explain it on the basis of illness for a
patient preferences, you end up with huge differences between the amount of
healthcare received by population A and population B and they can be right
neighboring communities. We first ran across this in Vermont where we looked
at a whole bunch of different attributes of healthcare system, the one that sticks
out in most people’s mind is the incredible variation that we saw in _______ 7:43
rates where literally by going 5 miles up the road and entering a new hospital
service area, you could jump from about a 20% risk of having a ______7.52 by
age 15 to well over 60%. So, that gives you an idea of what you know the basic
variability was, and this variation simply could not be explained on the basis of
differences in the incidence of sore throats, tonsillitis or anything like that and it
was traced pretty much directly back to the medical opinion of the physician
within a different community.
Margaret Flinter: Dr. Wennberg, I think that certainly gives us a hook on looking
at these variations and certainly you have made the point that illness doesn’t
explain it all and nor does anyone factor not genetics or environment or age or
anything else I guess but when you try and understand these variations across
the country so that we can build some effective health policy and practice
procedures, it seems that you are left always looking at the Medicare data
because that’s what we have got on a national basis, and yet you use the
example of tonsillectomy and I know hysterectomy was another one you know in
certainly less than Medicare age people often, how do you get at the data on the
rest of the country? I know there are special populations like Medicaid and the
commercial populations so that we have a complete sense of what is going on
with variation.
Dr. John Wennberg: The earlier studies that we did in Vermont, Maine, Rhode
Island, Iowa and some actually in California, were all based on 100% hospital
discharge data. So we were looking at both 65 and under 65 and certainly we
found them and there are still plenty of evidence that this is true is that the
experience of older people above 65 and older when it comes to surgical
variations pretty much mimics that as under 65 or vice versa.
Mark Masselli: Dr. Wennberg we are having a déjà vu moment again in our
country when we are fixated on the federal budget deficit in rapidly increasing
healthcare expenditures and obviously in the cross areas of Medicare, what can
the politicians learn from your research about the most beneficial ways to
restructure Medicare and how to contain cost while providing the best outcomes
that are possible.
Dr. John Wennberg: Politicians will have to understand that not all healthcare is
the same. Some things that vary and do so because they are essentially
measures done to improve the quality of life and patients have different
preferences for those treatments. But all the policy way I know of getting at to
which rate is right question is to actively involve the patient in decision process
because after all it's the patient’s preferences that need to be driving the decision
not medical opinion, opinion of local physicians. And at this time in our history
we can certainly see in the patterns of variation that it's medical opinion, not
patient’s opinion or preferences that are driving these. Now that’s just one of the
categories and I would say in terms of Medicare that makes up about 25% may
be 30% of cost, those kinds of procedures. Most of it basically going for
managing chronic illness, for managing patients who ultimately are going to
succumb from their diseases so it's a long term management of chronic illness
that is where most of the money in Medicare goes I would say about 60% would
be a pretty good answer to it. And here the variation that we see around the
country is driven primarily by the differences in frequency with which chronically
ill patients visit their physicians are referred to specialists or hospitalized or put in
intensive care units, receive MRIs or other forms of imaging and other laboratory
tests. So it's the intensity of care which differs so much from one community to
another which also is the driver of cost. So if we want to deal with cost and
Medicare and the trends upwards we got to somehow figure out how to deal with
supply sensitive care to bring now chaotically we manage chronic illness over
time under some form of organized systems. The organized systems such as the
Mayo Clinic and Intermountain Health Care, Geisinger Clinic do much better in
terms of continuity of care over time. They use fewer resources and spend less
money and I don’t think it's not just an accident. It’s the organized system that’s
there that permits the timely tradeoff between primary care and specialist and the
judicious use of hospitals and results in lower overall cost.
Mark Masselli: Well that seems like the mountain to climb if we only have four
organizations that you can site and we have a 100,000 people providing
healthcare out there multiple of that, you know what’s the crosswalk over for the
system that will get us to develop world class organization who are focused in on
patient outcomes and not always about volume and bottom line.
Dr. John Wennberg: Right that is the bottom line question, isn't it? Now the
Health Reform Act does have the so-called accountable care organizations which
could be viewed as a, and I think should be viewed as a bridge to the future and
the sense that it provides opportunities for Chief of Service Medicine to become
more organized to begin to move towards a budgeted approach and to develop
the infrastructures necessary to really manage chronic illness over time. And I
might add also the infrastructure to make certain concept of shared decision
making and informed patient’s choice gets implemented for surgical procedures
and other conditions or treatments that are definitely preference sensitive.
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Healthcare. Today we are speaking
with Dr. John Wennberg the Peggy Thompson professor for the Evaluative
Clinical Sciences at Dartmouth, Founder and Director Emeritus of the Dartmouth
Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice. Dr. Wennberg you mentioned the
Affordable Care Act and certainly it gives our nation an opportunity to reform the
delivery of healthcare but I would tell you that one of the most remarkable
outcomes of the work of the Dartmouth Atlas and I think it was brought to the
public consciousness probably through Dr. Gawande’s New Yorker article looking
at McAllen, Texas is that it was the first time I saw this issue of variation and price
variation in utilization make sense to the person in the street if you will. Our own
local Chamber of Commerce sponsored a workshop certainly thereafter with the
business community to talk about the Atlas about these variations and looked at
our own local communities in the State of Connecticut to try and make sense of
why these variations happen. Is this a sea change that you are now seeing
where business people Chambers of Commerce consumers are finally engaged
in this discussion and get that variations may not be so good for your health
either?
Dr. John Wennberg: I think that’s really incredible sea change and let’s keep the
sea moving. The Dartmouth Atlas was started in the early 90s when we were
assuming that the Clinton Health Plan would come true and we got support in
order to show what the regional differences were because it was so organized
around regions. When it failed basically we had a data, we had an atlas but we
didn’t have a customer base and what we hoped it would be that if we could
begin to publish this information and do it consistently over time that ultimately it
would surface as a major issue and it would probably be time to the next health
reform cycle, which in fact, that’s pretty much what’s happened. So yes I really
think these conversations are happening, we see it in the press coverage to the
Atlas. We are getting reports of all sorts of feedback and discussions going on. I
think we have gotten beyond the death panel kind of problem that we saw a
couple of years so, people begin to take it very seriously at the end of life
variations, the cancer treatment intensity varying so much as it does from place
to place. We are getting debates over End-of-Life Care, we are getting debates
over efficiency in Chronic Disease Management. And I think that’s the essential
start to some strong consensus I believe it’s going to have to come out of this.
Mark Masselli: Dr. Wennberg certainly in terms of cultural changes we have,
here on the show we would like to talk about the next generation healthcare
providers and how they are being trained and so talk to us a little bit about is the
science of variation being taught at these institutions and what can we do on the
side of training that next generation to help address some of the structural
problems that you have identified?
Dr. John Wennberg: I think that’s probably one of the most disappointing
features of the trip so far is that medical education is so hide down to the
th
traditions in the 19 century in terms of what’s taught, who teaches, what’s
important and there is basically very little room for the science of healthcare
delivery in the modern medical school curriculum. And this is a shame because
this is where we got it somehow the cultural change is going to happen ultimately
when the providers themselves change.
Mark Masselli: Yeah, hold the thread a little, the issue of how we inform, how we
have an informed consumer out there. And I don’t know if there is an app out
there or if we start with sort of assessment level education drive in our country to
make consumers more discerning in their selection of providers, in the selection
of procedures that are done. What are your thoughts about, what do you see as
models out there that we should be looking at?
Dr. John Wennberg: We have spent a lot of time figuring out how decision aides
are properly designed and properly structured into every day practice, could in
fact change the dynamic, essentially change the culture at the doctor-patient’s
level. And there is a large number of clinical trials now showing the decision
needs properly implemented really do change the dynamic and lead the
decisions that are higher quality. High quality decision being one in which the
patient was truly informed about the treatments options and the risks and
benefits and also where the patient was invited into the decision process so that
his or her preferences for one outcome or the other, a lumpectomy or a
mastectomy or a knee replacement or some more conservative treatment their
preferences for those kinds of treatment outcomes drill the decision process.
And there is a plenty of evidence that this works and it could be implemented
broadly but to do that it’s going to take both push and I hear again I think the
business community has a lot to say about it, but also push from CMS and also
push from provider leaders for which there are some emerging.
Margaret Flinter: Dr. Wennberg I was struck by your reference to the organized
systems certainly Geisinger, Kaiser Group Health, the Mayo Clinic and as Mark
noted people often tend to speak of those in the same sequence but when we
look at other large systems of care around the health center, our perspective
would certainly be the country’s community health centers represent another,
somewhat different but somewhat organized system with a thousand health
centers caring for 20 million people. Certainly the VA represents another large
organized system and I want to tie this back to the education and training issue
because certainly medicine is not alone among the health professions in the
hideboundedness if that’s a word of how things are taught but it seems to us that
it's the residency is where people get trained to a model of care and we have
certainly been active proponents of we train these practitioner residents in our
organization certainly many health centers have medicine residencies. But that’s
where you get to train people to a model of care. I am curious as to whether you
and your colleagues are working with residency directors around the country to
make these changes at that level around things like shared decision making for
instance which certainly seems to be a core competency for anybody doing the
primary care residency training.
Dr. John Wennberg: The only thing that we can notice that so many of our
residency programs are held in hospitals that do not practice shared decision-
making. And even perhaps more problematic they are practicing a brand of
medicine and managing chronic illness that basically is unsustainable in terms of
the resources they use and that’s not true of all teaching hospitals. You receive
Washington, you receive Oregon are all on the low side of the chronic disease
management spectrum. Residents there are presumably are getting a different
brand of medicine and people who are trained at NYU, New York University
Hospital or other teaching hospitals in New York, or Miami, or Philadelphia. The
concern about that issue particularly concerned about the mix between primary
care and specialist does need to become a public policy issue and we should not
continue to fund postgraduate medical education without reference to the content
and the environment in the context in which their care is being given. So at least
that’s my opinion.
Mark Masselli: Dr. Wennberg when you look around the country and the world
what do you see in terms of innovations and who should our listeners at
Conversations be keeping an eye on?
Dr. John Wennberg: Some of the best systems I have seen for example would
be, some of them would be in New Zealand where they have solved the problem
at least they have satisfied some of the problems of financial incentives. They
have got good IT systems. They are organizing chronic disease management on
a continuum involving both primary physicians and medical specialists. So there
I think you see some systems that are doing things in a very promising way.
Margaret Flinter: Today we have been speaking with Dr. John Wennberg the
Peggy Y. Thomson Professor for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences at Dartmouth
and the founding editor of the Dartmouth Atlas. Dr. Wennberg, thank you so
much for joining us on Conversations today.
Dr. John Wennberg: You are welcome.
Mark Masselli: Each week, Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities into everyday lives. This week’s bright
idea puts the community front in center in an effort to fight childhood obesity.
Although adults in Colorado are the leanest in the nation, obesity among children
in that state is rising at an alarming rate. Today 22% of Colorado’s 10-14 year
olds are overweight or obese. A non-profit group called 2040 Partners for Health
is bringing several communities in Colorado together to confront this issue. The
group has decided to start working in five Denver neighborhoods where the
childhood obesity rate is 30%. With the help of researchers from the University
of Colorado the team is using an approach known as Community-Based
Participatory Research which puts residence in charge of defining their own
problems and finding solutions. Researchers started out surveying families in the
five neighborhoods who had children between the ages of 10 and 14. They
charted height, weight and asked questions about neighborhood safety and
physical activity. They went into neighborhood schools and did the same. Next
they asked adults and children for their input on how to make neighborhoods
healthier. The children requested that school playgrounds be open after hours
and many parents suggested healthier school lunches and neighborhood
recreation center. In the community the message is been well received and
meaningful action is starting to build. More than 60 community members have
signed up to participate in healthy advocacy in their neighborhood. It may take
years for many of these ideas to be fully implemented but policymakers in
Colorado are beginning to understand what these neighborhoods need to be
healthier – an approach to health that’s transforming neighborhoods by engaging
residents. Now that’s a bright idea.
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Healthcare, I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Healthcare, broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan University
at WESU, streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to you by the
Community Health Center.