Bryan Sivak, Chief Technology Officer, Health and Human Services
This week, Mark and Margaret speak with Bryan Sivak, Chief
Technology Officer of the Department of Health and Human Services. Mr. Sivak talks about programs underway at HHS to harness the power of data, technology and innovation to improve the health and welfare of the nation. He discusses numerous programs that have been launched to improve access to health data for researchers, governments and individuals.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: Margaret, we are only a few weeks away from the Presidential
election and now the race is a horse race.
Margaret Flinter: And as people look at the choice they have to make to select a
President, Mark, it might be a good time to remind folks that they might be
selecting the future of health care in America as well. Depending on who wins
the election, the health care reform law may be somewhat in jeopardy at least
certain elements of it
Mark Masselli: A lot of historians and policy analysts are looking at this selection
as the single biggest referendum on a piece of social legislation since FDR’s
New Deal won the day in 1936.
Margaret Flinter: And I would say Mark it’s been kind of a crash course in
educating the American public about the health care system and the health care
issues over these last months. So it's pretty clear health care, the future of
Medicaid and Medicare, will continue to be very important elements of the
discussion in this path towards the election as these areas could look very
different in the future depending on the outcome.
Mark Masselli: There is quite a lot at stake Margaret. But there are numerous
changes underway as a result of the Affordable Care Act and many of these
reform initiatives will continue no matter what the outcome of the election.
Margaret Flinter: And our guest today is an individual who can speak to some
dramatic and innovative changes underway at the Department of Health and
Human Services which is the federal department that oversees Medicare,
Medicaid, the Federal Drug Administration and other organizations that have a
profound impact on health care in this country.
Mark Masselli: We are going to be speaking with Bryan Sivak, who is the Chief
Technology Officer at HHS. Having taken over last year from Todd Park, he is
overseeing the department’s effort to advance the power of technology and data
to improve the health and welfare of the nation.
Margaret Flinter: Mr Sivak has an impressive background having created
successful tech startups and he will be talking about the tremendous amount of
innovation underway now at HHS using new tools to harness and then liberate
health data and make it more accessible to all Americans.
Mark Masselli: And we will also hear from FactCheck.org’s Lori Robertson who
has a long list of comments made during the recent debates that need correcting.
Margaret Flinter: But no matter what the topic, you can hear all of our shows
featuring thought leaders and health reform and innovation by Googling us at
CHC Radio.
Mark Masselli: And as always, if you have comments, please email us at
www.chcradio.com , or find us on Facebook or Twitter; we love to hear from you.
Margaret Flinter: We will get to our interview with Bryan Sivak in just a moment
Mark Masselli: But first here is our producer Marianne O'Hare with this week’s
Headline News.
(Music)
Marianne O'Hare: I am Marianne O'Hare with this Headline News. The
Presidential race is locked in a dead heat, heading into the final stretch of the
election. The second of three debates in town hall format this week pitted a more
engaged President Obama against an emboldened Governor Romney both of
whom focused their attentions on matters of health care; Medicaid and Medicare
among many topics covered. No matter who wins in this election, Medicare
looms large as a problem that needs attention. The threat of insolvency has to
be dealt with at some point in the near future by whomever takes the helm in the
next turn and whether the Affordable Care Act stays or goes is also in the
balance.
So the companies are trotting up the big guns in New York where the mayor’s
proposed ban on large sugary sodas is poised to go into effect in March of next
year. Lawyers representing the soda industry and several restaurant groups in
New York have filed suit in the state Supreme Court saying the New York City
health department did not have unilateral authority to approve the mayor’s
proposal banning the sale of sugary drinks larger than 16 ounces in restaurants
and public venues. And the reason for the large soda ban, Mayor Bloomberg is
adamant in creating public policy that will stem the rising tide of obesity in spite of
these Herculean efforts. A report just out from the Robert Wood Johnson
Foundation projects that over half of the nation will be obese by 2030 unless a
major public health initiative is passed. I am Marianne O'Hare with this Headline
News.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: We are speaking today with Bryan Sivak, Chief Technology
Officer for the Department of Health and Human Services. Mr Sivak recently
served as the Chief Innovation Officer for the State of Maryland and as Chief
Technology Officer for the District of Columbia. He got a start in the private
sector as an IT entrepreneur and is cofounder of several successful startups
including Electric Knowledge which created one of the world’s first natural
language speaking search engines. Mr Sivak has also been a long time
promoter of co-chairing open source methods of expanding IT innovation. Bryan,
welcome to Conversations on Health Care.
Bryan Sivak: Thank you very much.
Mark Masselli: You know, your job at Health and Human Services is to harness
the power of data, technology and innovation to improve health and well-being of
our nation, and you took over from Todd Park who initiated that role and are
monitoring everything from health care options for billions of Americans from
keeping food safe to infectious disease outbreaks at bay. So tell us a little bit
about the programs like HealthData.gov as well as the health data warehouse
and how they are helping HHS shift to a more open and transparent government.
Bryan Sivak: Sure. One of the most amazing assets that we have here at the
Department of Health and Human Services is really the vast quantity of data.
And it's been realized for a while now that this asset really needs to be leveraged
to a greater extent. And so as you mentioned a few years ago, my predecessor
Todd Park came in and really started focusing on getting this information out to
the public, to the entities that could actually take advantage of this,
entrepreneurs, insurance companies, providers, anyone in the system actually
consumers I mean anybody who touches the health care system at all. We, over
the last few years, have undertaken a fairly significant program to liberate this
data which really means changing the default setting inside HHS from one of sort
of protection of this asset to one of release of this asset. And we have done a
great job I think to this point of really changing that default. The I would say most
recent manifestation of this is the HealthData.gov website which is sort of the
second version of our data warehouse and we are building this actually all on
open source technology. We in the next couple of weeks will be releasing our
code base to the public on GitHub so that anybody can use this for themselves,
contribute code, improve the system itself. But internally the whole idea is that
we are making a system that should be easy for people to interact with in order to
upload their datasets or the metadata about those datasets so that we can make
it available to just about anybody out there.
Margaret Flinter: Bryan, you have said that in the past you had a ton of fun
during your early days as an IT entrepreneur but much of what spawned that
early innovation was collaboration with peers on how to build these better
platforms for data sharing. Now you have shifted your skills to the public sector
and you have an opportunity to help government, help innovators which you have
euphemistically called an interesting challenge. So tell us about these unique
and interesting challenges that you face in bringing public entities and bringing
st
government into this 21 Century exciting world of data sharing and IT
innovation.
Bryan Sivak: So the first thing I will say is you should always beware when a
geek calls a problem interesting because that’s usually code for very, very
difficult. But as you mentioned, I started my career at a college basically writing
code for a startup that I co-founded and I am a tech entrepreneur at heart. But
one of the things I think I realized in this role or in that world I should say is that
success is really all about being able to accept risk and learn from mistakes and I
think that’s one of the biggest challenges in the public sectors is just the
willingness to take on risk and the incentives that drive the ability to take on risk.
If you think about the idea of innovation either in technology or in any sense, it
requires experimentation. So I think if we want to innovate in the public sector
we need to learn how to take some chances. And my job is really to help people
assume this risk. The other thing I would say is that governments in general are
sort of large somewhat ossified entities that have very established silos and walls
between various programs and entities and there is a huge amount of value
that’s trapped up in those silos. And just from being here at HHS in the first
couple of months that I have been on this job I have seen examples of
complementary programs that if they were connected and put together we would
be able to really drive some change in a big way. We can bring some of these
people together, we can break down some of these walls, we can try to change
that sort of paradigm that exists here and get things moving in a really positive
direction.
Mark Masselli: You have also been engaged maybe at Maryland when you
launched the program called Civic Commons which inspired by an attempt to get
more interconnectivity between the states and the governments. It seems to me
it's sort of a virtual backend for states if you will. Can you tell us more about how
Civic Commons Initiative works in sort of the policy behind it and what's the
funding mechanism moving forward?
Bryan Sivak: Yeah. So not just within organizations but across jurisdictions,
people are working on pretty much the same thing over and over and over again.
So if you look at cities, almost every city has to have a certain set of
infrastructure that they need to create in order to operate that city effectively. And
we end up not doing a good job of sharing some of those things. And you see
this repeated over and over again as you go up the jurisdictional ladder. And so
really what Civic Commons was it's an attempt to provide a relatively frictionless
platform for sharing not just code or applications but also ideas or policies or
funding methodologies in order to reduce the initial cost of development, reduce
the cost of maintenance going forward, spread good ideas. That was really the
intention behind it.
Margaret Flinter: Bryan, it seems as we look back the Obama Administration
made a pledge and I think substantially has kept it to continue to work on making
government more open and more transparent. And one of the initiatives in
keeping with this goal is a partnership between Health and Human Services and
the Institute of Medicine to launch the Community Health Data Initiative making
the data more available to innovators and entrepreneurs. HHS recently
participated in the Health Datapalooza Forum in Washington DC. Tell us about
some promising innovations that are growing out of those efforts that were
unveiled there.
Bryan Sivak: Sure. So the Datapalooza started a couple of years ago with 40
people sitting in a room in a pile of data and a challenge to come back 90 days
later with some interesting applications. It turned out that 90 days later, 2,000
different applications were presented that showed us the potential for utilizing this
data that we have. And it's grown ever since. The Datapalooza III that was just
held at the Washington Convention Center in June of this year had 1600 people,
there were over 200 apps that applied to present; I mean it's really been quite
phenomenal. You know, couple of good examples that have come out of this,
there is a company called iTriage that we talk about a lot. This is an entity that
was started by an ER doc basically trying to use mobile applications to diagnose
individuals based on certain symptoms that they were presenting and then they
leveraged some of our data in order to help drive people to the right provider at
the right time based on the diagnosis of the symptoms. They were actually
bought by Aetna recently. They have got 80 people, they are growing, they are
doing really well and so that’s a great, great example.
Another good example is a company called Humetrix which for those folks out
there who have heard of this I think called Blue Button, basically there is this
technology that we have been working on in conjunction with the Veterans
Administration for the last couple of years which allows people to click a little blue
button on a website and get their personal health record. And so what Humetrix
did was created an application called iBlueButton which essentially takes this
download of personal health data and translates it into a visual representation
that’s useful for the patient and for the doctor and for whoever else needs to see
it.
Mark Masselli: We are speaking today with Bryan Sivak, Chief Technology
Officer for the Department of Health and Human Services. Mr. Sivak recently
served as the Chief Innovation Officer for the State of Maryland. He was Chief
Technology Officer for the District of Columbia and is Cofounder of several
successful tech startups. Let’s talk a little bit about innovation and it seems to be
central to the new paradigm at HHS and in fact the department just announced
th
its 5 round of winners in the HHSinnovates Program. And so for the first time,
you had a people’s choice winner and allowed the public to vote on this. So can
you share with us some of the more exciting innovations that came out of this
program and also how much participation did you get from the public on this?
Bryan Sivak: Sure. So as you said, this round, we had the first iteration of the
people’s choice awards which was pretty exciting. We let the world basically vote
on the finalists.
Mark Masselli: By Twitter or how did they vote?
Bryan Sivak: No, they voted on the Internet.
Mark Masselli: Oh the Internet.
Bryan Sivak: We had a webpage up on our site. But Twitter is a good idea;
maybe we will do that next time. We actually had remarkable participation, it was
kind of cool. Tens of thousands of votes were cast so it was really I mean it got a
lot of people really involved which was fantastic. One of the winners actually of
this round I think the story is pretty awesome. The National Institute of Allergy
and Infectious Diseases basically came out with this application they call
FreeStuff and it's a really simple idea I think but it's a powerful idea. Basically in
the past, you would have a bunch of stuff within the organization that people had
bought overtime that were either going to be replaced because they needed
newer models or they didn’t need anymore. And typically, these things whether
it's like a piece of lab equipment or a piece of furniture, would go back into some
warehouse in the middle of Maryland to sit there for a while until some
government process actually took care of it. These guys realized that just
because I didn’t need this centrifuge anymore somebody else might be able to
use it. And so they put together essentially think of it as Craigslist for
government equipment, a website that internal employees can actually look at.
Mark Masselli: Is there actually a big room like Raiders of the Lost Ark at the end
where they find the Holy Grail, is that --?
Bryan Sivak: In my imagination, yes. And I hope that somewhere on one of
those shelves is an ark. But yes, I mean this story to me is pretty cool because
basically the idea for this came up literally when this employee of this agency
was out for a run one day and it just sort of hit her while she was running that hey
this is a great idea. She goes back to the office, recruits a couple of people and
in their spare time they put it together. And a little while later, now it's being
nominated for the HHS Innovates Program and it wins and it's great. So that’s a
great example. Another great example I think is the Center for Disease Control’s
Zombie Apocalypse story; I don’t know if you guys have heard of that. But
basically they used this marketing campaign of a zombie apocalypse for disaster
readiness. And it won because I think it was very unique and different for
governments to start marketing from this perspective. But the coolest thing
happened to me the other day. I was on an airplane back from San Francisco to
DC and I was sitting there the whole flight working, putting my stuff away at the
end and the guy sitting next to me, he had seen me kind of working this whole
time and asked me what I did. I told him my job. And he looked at me and says I
have one question. I said what’s that? He said, what are you guys doing about
the zombie apocalypse? It blew my mind right because there is a random guy
living in Texas kind of on this airplane who had heard about this stuff and knew
some of what we had been doing which probably wouldn’t have gotten out there
had we not done a program like HHS Innovates. So I think these things really
have some very significant effect.
Margaret Flinter: Well Bryan, I have to tell you the zombie apocalypse was a little
bit like the Martian Invasion in some communities where people did take it kind of
seriously. But those are great ideas. One of the words that keeps coming up
over and over in various manifestations is “connect’ and this is sort of central to
the work that you are doing. It seems connecting such disparate data that is
stored and managed by HHS. And when you go to your www.healthdata.gov
website, there is a nice visual there that links all these programs into a
constellation, Medicare, Medicaid, the Center for Disease Control and anybody
can access the site and find all kinds of significant health data on numerous
topics. So the question to me is who is using the site and who is mining the
data? Is it public health officials, clinicians, app inventors? Are you able to glean
some intelligence on who is using the data in the public?
Bryan Sivak: Well, we are working on that. I mean we have ton of anecdotal
evidence that people across the spectrum are actually using www.healthdata.gov
and doing interesting things with the information. But we are constantly working
on engagement and trying to get other folks and different communities involved.
In fact, one of the big efforts that we are undertaking right now is really one of
kind of connecting different groups of people that aren’t typically -- that don’t
typically think about health data or think about ways to do interesting things with
health data and kind of bringing them into the fold. So I think in the past you
really needed to be a subject matter expert to understand a lot of this stuff. We
are going to try to make some of these pieces of information more accessible, we
are going to try to reach out to developer communities, to entrepreneurs, to
venture capitalists, to providers, to any doctor out there; I mean all of these
different communities that we want to get involved. We are going to try to
broaden the tent a little bit and get more and more folks involved. The neat thing
is that since we launched HealthData.gov, I mean we have had hundreds of
thousands of visits on the site and we are constantly improving the functionality.
We are absolutely open to feedback. I mean one way that I would -- I would
stress one thing is that this is sort of I would slap a beta label on this in a lot of
ways because we are constantly looking at different things that we can do to
make it more usable and more functional, and we are going to be doing some
stuff around that in the near future so keep your eyes on it.
Mark Masselli: Is that part of the government’s new digital strategy? I know it's
focusing on three things making content more accurate, available and secure,
and you have been promoting application programming interfaces or APIs which
are tools for building software applications as an important part of that process.
So tell us about these APIs and why they are so important securing meaningful
use of government health data.
Bryan Sivak: Sure. So basically what an API does is it allows a developer to
access content and data in a machine readable but more importantly a
predictable way so they can make a functional call to a service and actually get a
piece of data back that they expect in a certain format and then they can do
something with it because it's in a certain format. You know, in the past, I think
developers have had to resort to techniques for example like screen scraping
where they literally tried using a program read what’s on a screen. And that’s
obviously a very brittle way to do something because if the format of the display
changes then we obviously have a challenge with having to update the program.
So there are some great examples out there. I think one really quick one is an
app called Healthline that was built basically using APIs that the National Library
of Medicine puts out and that’s all about basically providing information to
consumers, beneficiaries about diseases and conditions and all kinds of stuff like
that. And that’s just one example I mean there are plenty of other ones. And one
of the components of the digital strategy is actually to API enable as much
content and data as we possibly can to make this even easier for everybody.
Margaret Masselli: We have been speaking today with Bryan Sivak, Chief
Technology Officer for the Department of Health and Human Services. Mr. Sivak
continues the department’s goal towards more open government and meaningful
sharing of public health data so that we can harness the power of data,
technology and innovation to improve health and well-being of our nation. You
can find out more about these innovation initiatives by going to HealthData.gov.
Bryan, thank you so much for joining us on Conversations on Health Care today.
Bryan Sivak: My pleasure. Thanks for having me.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: At Conversations on Health Care, we want our audience to be
truly in the know when it comes to the facts about health care reform and policy.
Lori Robertson is an award-winning journalist and Managing Editor of
FactCheck.org, a nonpartisan, nonprofit consumer advocate for voters that aim to
reduce the level of deception in US politics. Lori, what have you got for us this
week?
Lori Robertson: Well, Mark and Margaret, this week we will look at Mitt
Romney’s plan for preexisting conditions. The Obama Campaign has repeatedly
said that Romney was wrong when he claimed at the first Presidential debate
that his plan covered preexisting conditions, and we mostly agree with the
campaign’s criticism. Romney implied that he would keep the provisions of the
Affordable Care Act which guarantees access to coverage for all regardless of
pre-existing conditions and regardless if the person had been uninsured
previously. But later, the Romney campaign explained that he was talking about
protections only for persons who had had continuous coverage. Now the 1996
HIPPA Law did get protections to those with employer-sponsored coverage.
Those workers can’t be denied coverage, they can’t be charged more and if they
have had previous employer-sponsored coverage, they get a waiver from any
kind of exclusions to preexisting conditions. But those going from an individual
market plan, people who buy coverage on their own to another individual plan,
they don’t have those same protections. So Romney could extend federal
regulations for those individuals with continuous coverage that means no gaps in
coverage longer than 63 days. His campaign told us that he would extend
federal HIPAA regulation but did not offer specific details. And that’s my fact
check for this week. I am Lori Robertson, Managing Editor of FactCheck.org.
Margaret Flinter: FactCheck.org is committed to factual accuracy from the
country’s major political players and is a project of the Annenberg Public Policy
Center at the University of Pennsylvania. If you have a fact, that you would like
checked, email us at www.chcradio.com . We will have FactCheck.org’s Lori
Robertson check it out for you here on Conversations on Health Care.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: Each week, Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives. The nation is
battling an obesity epidemic and it's hitting our children especially hard. Turns
out the very thing perceived to be one of the causes, the sedentary pass time of
sitting in front of a screen playing videogames could provide a great solution.
The folks at HopeLab have cooked up another videogame aimed at improving
kids’ health. They are the same folks who created Re-Mission, a videogame
designed for kids with cancer to attack their cancer. Now comes Zamzee, a
competitive videogame designed to get kids moving. HopeLab’s VP and
Communications Director Richard Tate says it's a pretty simple concept, equip
kids with a movement monitor which they plug into their computer at the end of
the day and compete against other kids on how much they moved that day and
there are rewards for each kid based on their level of activity.
Richard Tate: The Zamezee website uses sound principles of motivational
science to get kids moving more. And the experience online is built in with a
number of intrinsic rewards features like positive game-like experiences where
they experience success and feel competence and mastery for moving around
and that kind of positive experience keeps kids moving overtime.
Mark Masselli: And as with their game Re-Mission, when kids compete with a
large population, they are more inclined to want to succeed.
Richard Tate: And there is a sense of discovery and excitement to see how
many points you have earned for doing any number of activities whether it's
walking the dog, walking to school, even doing chores, or just running around
with friends. And then with Zamzee, those points actually power your online
experience and points allows you to compare and compete with others on the
site, and it actually can help earn you reward that keep you engaged and keep
you moving.
Mark Masselli: And the results are significant. Kids playing the Zamzee
videogame moved an average 60% more per day than kids in the control group
that didn’t have the game at their disposal. A simple movement monitor
connected to a competitive videogame that could motivate millions of kids to
move more during the day, now that’s a bright idea.
(Music)
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the campus of WESU at
Wesleyan University, streaming live at www.wesufm.org , and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.