Robert E. Mechanic, Senior Fellow at Heller School, Brandeis University
T
his week, Mark and Margaret speak with Robert E. Mechanic, Senior Fellow at the Heller School for Social Policy and Management at Brandeis University. Mr. Mechanic is the lead author on a report in this month’s Health Affairs that offers the first in-depth analysis of the effectiveness of cost containment measures in the State of Massachusetts since near-universal health coverage was achieved in that state. The report looks at the rise of Accountable Care Organizations and the creation of an independent commission to oversee health care system performance as having a positive impact on cost controls.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: Well Margaret, I just want to take a moment to remember a
pioneer in our midst and a woman who stood at the very foundation of our health
care journey here, one of our founding board members of the Community Health
th
Center, Lillian Reba Moses, passed away on October 18 and I can't stress
enough how inspirational, how vital, how important she was to our mission. She
inspired us to do great work for people who have been forgotten and unseen.
Margaret Flinter: Well Reba was really the heart and the soul of our founding
belief that health care is a right and not a privilege. And she showed that spirit in
her words, in her deeds and her life, always inspiring us try to do better, do more
in our health care quest.
Mark Masselli: She was so many things to so many people: a community
activist, a pioneer, a mother of her own to six great children and to many more, a
tireless advocate, a foot soldier in the war on civil rights and poverty in America
and right here in Connecticut but most importantly, she was a caring, gracious,
inspiring lady, a great friend and certainly somebody who we will miss.
Margaret Flinter: And she gave us this opportunity to continue to serve all of
those who need quality health care. So I would say her legacy and her work
goes on.
Mark Masselli: You are right. The Affordable Care Act will likely go down as the
lasting legacy from President Obama. Here we are down to the final two weeks
before the Presidential election and it's just simply too close to call.
Margaret Flinter: Too close to call and if ever was time for a good cliché I will use
the one ‘every vote matters’; this no time for voter apathy.
Mark Masselli: And it would be a shame to see those efforts derailed after so
much hard work and progress on health reform.
Margaret Flinter: Well Mark, I am sticking with the position that most of the
reforms that are legislated under the Affordable Care Act are going to go forward
no matter what happens.
Mark Masselli: And our guest today can shed some light on how near-universal
coverage is working in the State of Massachusetts. Robert Mechanic is a lead
author on a report. And it's the first in-depth study looking at the impact that
statewide health coverage has had on cost containment in health care.
Margaret Flinter: And he will share his insights on how measures passed in
Massachusetts have set health care spending targets for the state that lead to
real cost containment.
Mark Masselli: You know, and he will also look at the rapid growth of the public-
private partnership to meet the (02:22 inaudible) in the health care law in
Massachusetts that could provide an excellent example for other states to follow.
Margaret Flinter: And in our neighboring State of Massachusetts, Governor
Deval Patrick announced last week that the expanded health law in that state
was having a real impact on outcomes as well as an effort to contain cost.
Screening for cancer up, smoking down as more people get regular preventive
care and have access to primary care.
Mark Masselli: Well the governor was a great guest on our show and you can
hear that interview and other shows just by Googling us at CHC Radio.
Margaret Flinter: And as always, if you have comments, please email us at
www.chcradio.com , or find us on Facebook or Twitter because we love to hear
from you.
Mark Masselli: We will also hear from our own FactCheck.org’s Lori Robertson.
Margaret Flinter: We will get to our interview with Robert Mechanic in just a
moment.
Mark Masselli: But first, here is our producer Marianne O'Hare with this week’s
Headline News.
(Music)
Marianne O'Hare: I am Marianne O'Hare with this Headline News. It's the home
stretch of the campaign and the political ads are amping up at least in the key
battleground states like Florida and Ohio, and women and seniors are figuring
prominently in both campaigns. In one ad, President Obama is shown in a café
setting, surrounded by seniors, promising not to voucherize their Medicare.
Romney’s ad is showing a concerned woman sitting at a kitchen table worried
about the growing national debt. The third and final debate between the two
candidates focused on foreign policy, little mention of health care. Meanwhile the
race is still a statistical dead heat.
One of the provisions of the Affordable Care Act is starting to have an effect.
Insurers were ordered by the act not to deny coverage to any children up to age
19 with preexisting conditions. Initially some insurers stopped selling child-only
policies. Now some 22 states across the nation have plans for children that
insure their complete access to coverage.
Speaking of children, boys are hitting puberty at an earlier age than in recent
generations. A study out shows African-American boys start the process the
earliest at around 9 years of age, Hispanic boys on average are now launching
into that process at 10 years of age, and Caucasian boys 10.1 years of age.
Experts who conducted the study say they don’t know what the cause is but they
suspect it's something in the environment. I am Marianne O'Hare with this
Headline News.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: We are speaking today to Robert Mechanic, Senior Fellow at the
Heller School of Social Policy and Management at Brandeis University. Mr.
Mechanic is Executive Director of the Health Industry Forum, a national program
established to develop practical strategies for improving the quality and
effectiveness of the US health care system. He is the lead author of the report
out in health affairs this month which analyzes the recently passed laws
governing health care cost containment in Massachusetts. Robert, welcome to
Conversations on Health Care.
Robert Mechanic: Yeah. Well Mark, it's a pleasure to be here. Thank you.
Mark Masselli: You know ever since Massachusetts passed health reform for all
six years ago it's really been a laboratory for researchers. And your team
recently published an in-depth analysis of the progress being made in the State
of Massachusetts on health cost containment and payment reform and we have
had several great guests from Massachusetts on the show including Governor
Patrick saying coverage was the first step but that cost containment was going to
present a much bigger challenge. I wonder if you could describe how achieving
near full coverage in Massachusetts has changed the health cost landscape in
that state.
Robert Mechanic: Well, you know as you recall, Massachusetts expanded
coverage in a way that’s similar to the Affordable Care Act. First of all, there is
now mandate that individuals have coverage. Secondly, we have significantly
expanded the Medicaid program. And then the third is we have created a series
of new subsidies for individuals to purchase private health insurance whose
incomes are below a certain threshold. And the costs of these expansions are
primarily going to be shared between the state government and the federal
government. So when this bill was passed, there was a broad coalition of
support in the state, which included the health care providers, insurance plans,
employers, consumer groups, and of course, the policy community. But, as they
were passing this they realized a couple of things; one is, you can't force
individuals to buy coverage if coverage isn’t affordable and the second is,
because the state is picking up new cost for this coverage, state spending has
been very tight not just in Massachusetts but all over the nation. And I think
people realized it would be very difficult to sustain these reforms over a long term
if they did not at the same time address costs. In sort of traditional thinking of
how to contain costs there are some simple ways you can do it. One is that you
can limit coverage from programs; obviously the state was not going to do that.
The second is reduced benefits. Third is to cut payments to providers and fourth
is to try to improve the system. And once you have made the commitment to
universal coverage, well coverage and reducing benefits are off the table so you
are really left with provider payments improving the system. And I think as we
look to this bill, the focus here is on improving the system going forward.
Margaret Flinter: Rob, Massachusetts, as you have said, had this challenge to
get to this near full coverage in the state, and that generated a public policy
culture that really seems to now support cost containment measures. And
maybe other states have focused more their efforts just in the Medicaid arena but
in Massachusetts the cost containment culture really focus both on public and
private sector. So I would like to take a look at the first of the three cost
containment measures in Massachusetts, the act to promote cost containment,
transparency and efficiency that focused on cost transparency. But one of the
things that they revealed in that transparency was these enormous differences in
payments being paid to providers by insurance companies for the same
procedures and services. Maybe you could share with us what did this revelation
accomplish and has it affected the cost and payment models at all?
Robert Mechanic: Well I think there has been lot of focus particularly in the
difference in rates and so there has been a lot of focus on the provider groups
that have been on the high end of the rates. And I think a lot of public pressure,
pressure on the newspapers and so forth because nobody likes to see
themselves up there as being the most expensive. The other thing though that
they looked at besides the specific rates was there are wide differences in the
total cost of taking care of a population of patients. And so I think that’s gotten
people to focus on the second piece, price is important but also what's important
is how effectively is care coordinated. Particularly as we think now about
budgets or global payments, you want the health care system to really think
about making sure that people get the right care at the right time, that they use
appropriate settings of care and not use the emergency department when care is
available in clinics or urgent care, and you want to avoid unnecessary care or
duplicative care. So I think this report put some of the focus definitely on the
overall cost of care and both the price issue but also the care coordination issue.
And I think it's made the whole system really look inwardly and I think the people
who are on the high end of the list have some motivation to move themselves
down towards the middle if possible.
Mark Masselli: You know Rob, I want to pull on the thread of “As Goes
Massachusetts, So Goes The Nation” and you guys are leading the bell curve on
so many things. And there is a lot of scrutiny on health care payment reform in
Massachusetts, and with that, new transparency has led to a push towards global
payments to providers, again, a big shift in payment culture in Massachusetts.
Describe the global payment model on how the state was able to enlist the
supported health care and business community to make the transition to this
model and what does this really mean for the various stakeholders as well.
Robert Mechanic: You know Mark, the first thing I would say is we are part of the
way along the way with global payment but it's not all the way. It's not clear that it
would really make sense to try and get the entire state under a global payment.
In Massachusetts, we have a large number of integrated health care systems.
They have hospitals and doctors that work together; they have shared electronic
medical records and so forth. And these type of health care systems, they have
the tools and the integration that would allow them to manage health care on a
budget or a global payment. It's probably true that small physician offices or
some of the independent community hospitals, if you try to put them on a budget,
you are really putting them at risk for total health care spending. And so I think
we moved quickly in part because of the structure of our system but I would also
question how far down that continuum we should go.
One of the benefits of global payment is for an integrated system it allows them
to say rather than to get paid we have to do more services. They say we are
working on a budget now, what's the best way to provide that care; how can we
provide it more efficiently? And so I think ultimately, these integrated systems
combined with a budget that is perhaps growing more slowly than it has
historically provides the best way to really reward these groups for improving the
way they deliver care. But it's going to be slower I think in many parts of the rest
of the country than it is here and the federal government is going in with a
somewhat alternative model. So you have heard of the Medicare ACO program
or Shared Savings Program, they are starting that I will call it sort of a foot in the
water by putting people on a budget but saying you can keep the proceeds if you
save money but if you spend more, well in the first several years, we are not
going to make you pay the money back. But overtime I think the federal
Medicare Program wants to move in the same direction with their ACO Program.
Margaret Flinter: Rob, the next set of cost containment measures, and these
were passed in 2010, focused on the individual insured and the small business
market, which is the same market that we think will see the biggest growth in
coverage under the Affordable Care Act in the exchanges. And that measure
gave the Insurance Commissioner of Massachusetts the power to decide
whether changes to insurance rates for that group were excessive or
unreasonable, and I understand it also required insurers to offer a discounted
plan option and also maybe describe these discounted plans, how do they
compare with the concept of the essential benefit plans as outlined under the
Affordable Care Act and what kind of impact has this had on both cost
containment.
Robert Mechanic: Sure. Well let’s start with the issue of setting a cap on the
small group growth. And that was a little bit of a shock to the system. Now
remember that insurance plans don’t negotiate difference sets of rates for the
small group market and for the large group market; they have one contract with
each major provider. So with the state coming in and saying, wait a minute, you
can't raise your rates more than a set level, they look at that and say, oh boy, well
we have got all these contracts out there and we have to find a way now to get
our contracts in line with where the state is holding us on a small group in
individual market. So actually it affects the whole market not just the small group
from the perspective of the insurers. That really I think has changed a little bit of
the dynamic of negotiation. It's forced them to go back and be much tougher as
they sit down with the groups looking at the rate increase because they have got
the state axe over their head to keep the rates down. So it really changed
expectations in the market. So providers are looking at it and saying, they are
expecting the insurers to come in and negotiate harder and try to bid lower rates.
With respect to the discounted plan option, that’s a so-called tiered benefit option
or a narrow network option. So what the law required is it required insurers to
offer at least one of these plans. They would pick a network of lower cost but
good quality providers and say this is your provider network, you cannot go
outside of this network, or at least not with paying more. And so by virtue of
using these lower costs more efficient providers, it would bring the premium down
12% below a standard plan. Now you asked about the essential benefit plan.
Massachusetts actually setup its own what they call the Minimum Creditable
Coverage. So when they passed health reform in 2006, they gave our health
insurance exchange which is called the Connector and they said, look, we have
to make a decision about what is the base minimum coverage. So the state set
its own minimum creditable coverage. This new law for these discounted plans
doesn’t change the benefit per se, what it is asking for is for the insurers to come
out with a more limited network of providers that I will say it reduces access to
the highest cost, most expensive hospitals and doctors out there.
Mark Masselli: We are speaking today with Robert Mechanic, Senior Fellow with
the Heller School for Social Policy and Management at Brandeis University. Mr.
Mechanic is Executive Director of the Health Industry Forum, a national program
established to develop practical strategies for improving the quality and
effectiveness of the U.S health care system. He is the lead author of a report out
in this month’s Health Affairs, which analyzes the recently passed laws governing
health care cost containment in Massachusetts. Rob, the state most recently
passed a cost containment measure this summer that had very stringent
regulations to govern cost growth but you say it lacks enforcement measures.
So tell us a little bit about the things that are lacking but also tell us about what it
does do and why this should accelerate the pace of cost containment efforts in
Massachusetts.
Robert Mechanic: This is the first time that a state has ever set a health care
spending target that covers the entire system. So it really encompasses
spending for Medicare, for Medicaid and for private health insurance and for what
consumers pay out of the pocket. And they have tied this spending target to the
economy. So essentially what they would like to do is bring the long term growth
in health spending down to a rate of the long term growth of the state’s economy,
which they peg in the first year had about 3 ½ %. Now remember historically,
heath care spending has consistently overtime grown at 2% to 3% points faster
than the national economy. So by saying, we are setting this target at the rate of
economic growth that is a very, very stringent change. Now the second thing
beside the target they have done is they have set up a new quasi-public agency,
it's called the Massachusetts Health Policy Commission. So I would say the next
couple of years they will be setting up the infrastructure, really an ability to track
the health system that has never before existed. And then we will see how it
goes and then the legislature will have to make a decision if they feel that the
system isn’t performing whether they are going to give the commission more
powers.
Margaret Flinter: So Rob, as we look at all of these cost containment measures
and payment reforms, it's clear there is a lot of change, an increased emphasis
on creating and leading the ACOs on patient-centered medical homes, on the
global payment models. Where is the expertise to lead all of this enormous
systems change coming from? And I guess the secondary question would be,
what are these institutions and organizations doing to prepare a next generation
of leadership to lead radically different health care systems than what we have
seen in the past in Massachusetts or anyplace else?
Robert Mechanic: Yeah. Well this is a very challenging thing because you are
taking on these big complicated organizations that span across multiple sites and
multiple providers and you are asking them to do their work differently. But the
truth is this is very hard, very challenging long term work. You know you have to
change culture; you have to get physicians who have been trained to be super
smart and resourceful to now to work in teams. I think that the combination of
the global payment model along with now this threat of really keeping the cost
trend down has energized systems to begin doing the work they need to do. You
said, where is the leadership? I mean I think this law sort of sets the context and
sets expectations. But the leadership comes from within these systems,
individuals, individual doctors and nurses and administrators who recognize that
they are going to have to do their work differently. And I think these groups are
most effective if they also think about how do I put the patient in the middle of
this, how do I look at how we deliver care and think about what is really value
added for the patient and where can I take out waste. What (18:35 inaudible)
global payment are doing are creating a different set of incentives. But I think the
leadership is going to come from the rank and file, the people doing this work.
Mark Masselli: Rob, we like to ask all of our guests this final question. When
you look around the country and around the world, what do you see in terms of
innovation and who should our listeners at Conversations be keeping an eye on?
Robert Mechanic: I have had the ability to spend some time over the last couple
of months with a group in Cambridge Massachusetts, Cambridge Health Alliance.
They are a safety net delivery system. They are actually in -- the majority of their
patients were previously uninsured or on Medicaid coverage so they treat a low
income patient population. And they have been working very hard to develop a
series of medical homes and into an accountable care type of model. So we
were going in to talk with a gentleman who was the Chief of Emergency
Medicine. So we got there. There was one person sort of standing behind a
podium; she took our names, she said, well let’s go back and find (1928
inaudible). She comes out and says, well come on in. So we walked in and we
sat down with them and I said, well it must be a slow day today, there is nobody
in the waiting room. And he looked at me and said, no, he says, there is never
anybody in the waiting room. He says, we are at 130% of capacity today but we
have made the decision that nobody waits. We see them within 5 minutes; we
don’t worry about paperwork or their insurance until after we have taken care of
them. And basically, this gentleman and his team had said, we are going to take
on a different philosophy of taking care of patients, and it blew me and my
colleagues away because all of us had taken a kid or been in emergency rooms
ourselves and waited for hours and here is a system that decided to change and
they did it, and I went ‘wow’. There is one organization to look at but there are
hundreds of them out there and the question is not whether we can develop
these new models, the question is can we spread them and can we spread them
fast enough.
Margaret Flinter: We have been speaking today with Robert Mechanic, Senior
Fellow at the Heller School for Social Policy and Management of Brandeis
University. You can find the report at www.healthaffairs.org and find out more
about the Health Industry Forum at healthforum.brandeis.edu. Rob, thank you so
much for joining us on Conversations on Health Care today.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: At Conversations on Health Care, we want our audience to be
truly in the know when it comes to the facts about health care reform and policy.
Lori Robertson is an award-winning journalist and Managing Editor of
FactCheck.org, a nonpartisan, nonprofit consumer advocate for voters that aim to
reduce the level of deception in US politics. Lori, what have you got for us this
week?
Lori Robertson: Well, Mark and Margaret, at last week’s debate, President
Obama made a comment about Planned Parenthood and mammograms. He
said millions of women rely on Planned Parenthood for more than just
contraception; he said they rely on it for mammograms for cervical cancer
screening. But actually mammograms aren’t performed at Planned Parenthood
clinics. Doctors and nurses at the clinics do conduct breast exams and they refer
patients to other facilities for mammograms. Some clinics do occasionally
arrange for mobile mammography vans and they help low income patients find
grants to help pay for mammograms. Planned Parenthood of Western
Pennsylvania for example has a Breast Health Care Fund, which helps patients
obtain mammograms. The president is correct to say that Planned Parenthood
does more than just provide contraception. The largest category of services in
2010 was testing and treatment of sexually transmitted diseases, which
accounted for 38% of all medical services, cancer screening and prevention like
the breast cancer screening made up 14.5%, abortion procedures made up 3%.
And that’s my fact check for this week. I am Lori Robertson, Managing Editor of
FactCheck.org.
Margaret Flinter: FactCheck.org is committed to factual accuracy from the
country’s major political players and is a project of the Annenberg Public Policy
Center at the University of Pennsylvania. If you have a fact, that you would like
checked, email us at www.chcradio.com . We will have FactCheck.org’s Lori
Robertson check it out for you here on Conversations on Health Care.
(Music)
Margaret Flinter: Each week, Conversations highlights a bright idea about how
to make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives. In the never
ending quest to find ways to contain health care costs, researchers at Brigham
and Women’s Hospital in Boston have identified at least one possible contributor.
It turns out maximizing the use of hospital observation units has the potential for
generating significant savings in the hospital setting. Lead researcher Dr.
Christopher Baugh, an ER physician at Brigham and Women’s, says, hospital
observation units function something like a wait station for patients visiting the
emergency room. It's for those patients not quite ready for either immediate
release or full admittance to the hospital.
Dr. Christopher Baugh: This is a dedicated area where there are staff that are
trained and prepared to take care of patients who are undergoing observation.
And we put patients there who need more time for evaluation, serial physical
exams, other things that take time beyond their typical emergency department
stay.
Margaret Flinter: These observations units allow for the patient to be moved from
the acute section of the ER to an adjacent area where they can be closely
observed and monitored for another 24 hour period.
Dr. Christopher Baugh: If you are able to get a patient home within 15 hours
versus 30 hours, and the more time that patient spends in the hospital the more
risks you have for those infections or falls or other complications with being
hospital patients and it's a dangerous thing to be. And if you don’t have to be
hospitalized then you shouldn’t be and the observation unit allows us to be very
efficient in getting people home.
Margaret Flinter: The researchers at Brigham and Women’s determined the cost
savings could be significant, as much as $4 million per year per hospital. The
study suggests that number translates into $3 billion a year throughout the U.S.
health care system. Dr, Baugh says this is a great way to meet new demands for
cost containment while ensuring that patients get the quality care they need. The
hospital ER observation unit closely monitoring patients in the ER before
determining if they need further in-patient care, now that’s a bright idea.
(Music)
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the campus of WESU at
Wesleyan University, streaming live at www.wesufm.org , and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.