Susan Dentzer, editor-in-chief of Health Affairs
Conversations on Health focuses this week on the critical policy issues for innovation and legislation. Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Susan Dentzer, editor-in-chief of Health Affairs, the nation’s leading journal focusing on the intersection of health, health care and health policy in the United States and around the world.
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.
th
Mark Masselli: Margaret, I hope everyone had a fun and safe 4 of July, and one
thing I would like to do is to read the Declaration of Independence which is found
th
on the back of almost every newspaper printed in America on the 4 . And you
know, I found out something that I hadn’t realized that the last paragraph of the
declaration was really the major driving force for the first 20 years after the
declaration was written and that really declared that we were independent from
England, and that’s why we have those celebrations and fireworks. And
obviously, it was a good time had by all.
Margaret Flinter: Well, I think it might be my favorite holiday of the year. And
interestingly, I read the whole Declaration of Independence again myself and
moved as I always am, last night got a little bit of the fireworks over New York
and just the spectacle combined with the verse of the national anthem is always
a very moving moment. It makes us very appreciative of what we have. And
th
right here, closer to home, on the Friday before the 4 , we kicked it off with the
start of the Farmers Market, now going on all over Connecticut, really focusing on
making sure that all people have a chance at fresh fruits and vegetables, a
chance to connect with farmers in our community and all in all quite a positive
event and very much in keeping with the spirit.
Mark Masselli: It really was. And our members of Congress were doing the
th
people’s work in Washington, D.C. Their July 4 recess was canceled, and they
are staying there because their president is really trying to craft a deal between
nd
the Senate and the House to raise the debt ceiling by August 2 and that’s the
deadline when the U.S. Treasury could go into default if Congress doesn’t raise
the debt ceiling. I am worried about this date. It's a very complicated bill. We
have been talking about it here. It's going to take a number of weeks to write it.
And I think if we don’t see some action in the next couple of weeks, we are going
to be in trouble.
Margaret Flinter: Well, the debate continues and every day, there are certainly
news articles on it. But the issues that we spoke about a few weeks ago really
aren’t any different now. The White House has identified at least $1.3 trillion in
spending cuts over 10 years and is proposing up to $400 billion in new tax
revenue. And just recently, President Obama said that the corporation should
give up some tax breaks before the United States asks seniors to pay more for
their Medicare benefits. But at the same time, he has signaled an openness to
make change and spending reductions to Medicare. Meanwhile, Republicans
are saying no tax increases and we want more spending cuts.
Mark Masselli: And thus, speaking of what other people were saying, the courts
are now taking up the President’s Health Reform Bill. I shouldn’t say the
President’s Health Reform Bill, it's America’s Health Reform Bill. And the
Appeals Court in the Sixth District became the first to rule affirmatively on the law.
There are two other Court of Appeals who have heard arguments in May and
June. But the Cincinnati Court said the law’s requirement for most Americans to
carry insurance or pay a penalty is constitutional.
Margaret Flinter: So out of Ohio, some very welcome news into Washington,
D.C. for the administration. Now, looking at the larger picture of health policy,
today we are very pleased to welcome Susan Dentzer, Editor-in-Chief of Health
Affairs, the nation’s leading journal on health policy. Health Affairs focuses on the
intersection of health and health care and health policy in the United States and
also around the world.
Mark Masselli: We are happy Susan can be with us today. But no matter what
the story, you can hear all of our shows on our website Chcradio.com . You can
subscribe to iTunes to get our show regularly downloaded. Or if you would like to
hang on to every word and read a transcript of one of our shows, come visit us at
our Chcradio.com site. If you are a social media aficionado, you can become a
fan of Conservations on Health Care on Facebook and also follow us on Twitter.
Mark Masselli: And as always, if you have feedback, email us at Chcradio.com ,
we love to hear from you. And before we speak with Susan Dentzer, let’s check
in with our producer Loren Bonner for the Headline News.
Loren Bonner: I am Loren Bonner with this week’s Headline News. With less
than a month to go before the U.S. Treasury Department could go into default, if
Congress doesn’t raise the debt ceiling, President Obama discussed whether he
could be open to accepting a deal with Republicans. Obama Administration
officials are offering the cut tens of billions of dollars from Medicare and Medicaid
and negotiations to reduce the federal budget deficit. But the depth of those cuts
depends on whether Republicans are willing to accept any increases in tax
revenues. On Tuesday, The New York Times reported that administration
officials and Republican negotiators might take the money from health care
providers like hospitals and nursing homes. This way, beneficiaries wouldn’t be
affected nor would there to be a need to restructure the Medicare and Medicaid
programs.
A new study by a national health care group called Change Healthcare found that
patients pay as much as 683% more for the same medical procedures in the
same town, depending on which doctor they choose. Change Healthcare looked
at claims data from May 2010 to May 2011 for thousands of employees of small
businesses to determine price differences for several procedures like MRIs, CT
scans and ultrasounds. The findings show that patients who pay for percentage
of their care as opposed to a co-payment may end up spending much more for
certain procedures than they would if they choose treatment somewhere else
locally.
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. Today, we are speaking
with Susan Dentzer, Editor-in-Chief of Health Affairs, nation’s leading journal on
health policy. Welcome, Susan.
Susan Dentzer: Great to be with you.
Mark Masselli: Susan, there are so many wonderful things to say about Health
Affairs but every month, you offer expert thoughtful commentary on a range of
important health care and health policy issues. In January 2010, Health Affairs
redesigned, or should I say reinvented, itself in your timing nicely aligned with our
country’s renewed focus on Health Reform. It has been a boon for the growing
audience of people you are going to be better informed. Can you share with us
your vision on how Health Affairs fits into the broader discussion of health care
and how you hope to shape these discussions?
Susan Dentzer: The tagline for our journal is that we are “at the intersection of
health, health care and policy,” and we take that very seriously. We think it’s
really important to be at that intersection and to be essentially a neutral party in
communicating among the various entities in that intersection. Let me give you
an example of what I mean. We know, for example, that if you look at what
contributes to premature death in the United States, why do people die before
their eventual life expectancy would tell you that they are likely to die, why do so
many people have chronic illness and die at younger ages than others. And as
we know we have a 33-year or more difference in life expectancy in this country,
depending on who you are, what your racial and ethnic background is, what your
level of educational attainment is or that of your parents’ was, etc.
So if you ask why do some people die earlier than others, we know some of it
has to do with your genetic predispositions but that’s relatively speaking only
30% of the contribution probably. Your behavior has a lot more to do with it,
whether you are eating right, exercising, etc. Your social circumstances have a
big role. 15% or more of your likelihood that you will die early has to do with
what is your status on life, what is your level of educational attainment or your
overall socioeconomic level. And only relatively minor contributor to that whole
equation is whether or not you have got adequate medical care.
So you put all of that in a big ______ 8:36 and what do you have, you have
where we are born, who we are, what our education was, what our parents’
education was, all of those things have as much, if not more, an impact on your
actual health status than your health care. So it’s very important to have a place
where we talk about all of those things, what are the contributors to our overall
level of health in this country, what is the role of health care in all of that, and
what can we do with health care to maximize health given all the other things that
contribute to our health and then very importantly, what should our policy be at
the state, at the federal, at the local level to maximize our health because we
could all agree that what we really want is for our population to be as healthy as
possible and therefore able to contribute to events in a society and really pursue
life liberty and happiness.
Margaret Flinter: Certainly, the big goals of America, and let me ask you, Susan,
that intersection between health care and health policy is pretty big intersection in
and of itself but Health Affairs really goes beyond the U.S. health care system
and U.S. health policy to look broadly on a global and international level. You
have had many very fascinating articles looking at health care and Health Reform
in other countries, certainly Great Britain, Switzerland, Spain, Germany and
others. During the Health Reform debates, we often heard Americans want
uniquely American solution but probably a lot for us to learn from other countries.
What would you say are some of the key lessons that we could learn both from
the health care system and the health policies in other countries?
Susan Dentzer: Well, it is certainly the case that the thing we have in common
with people of other countries is we are all the people and obviously there are a
number of things that stem from the fact that we all have essentially the same
basic biology. And so that with respect to all the industrialized countries, the
things that afflict us afflict them. So chronic illness, the fact that so many of us
have cardiovascular disease are fighting overweight or obesity, have high blood
pressure, the other factors that feed into cardiovascular disease and very
importantly are battling cancers, those are universal across – first of all, across
the world increasingly but certainly with respect to the industrialized countries.
So to the degree that other countries are trying to figure out how to develop
health and health care systems that grapple with these chronic illnesses, these,
they say, non-communicable illnesses, we just have a lot to learn with from other
countries. Every industrialized country is struggling with how to do that well.
When you have got people who are not acutely sick but are somewhat stick over
a long period of time, you have essentially got to deal with them being in the
community, getting up every day, going to work, not spending all your time inside
a hospital. Thank goodness, we don’t want that. But that sort of good structuring
system that they can meet the needs of people in the community and actually
keep them as healthy as possible and keep their chronic illnesses from getting
worse and of course ideally preventing them, those are universal across all
countries.
So there are lots of opportunities for us to look at how other countries are
grappling with it. The other important thing is that all countries overall, but
particularly the industrialized countries, are all struggling with the rising cost of
health care and the fact that as they spend more and more on health care, to
some degree, that threatens the inability to spend money on other things that
they value. Now, it’s true on the one hand that as countries get richer, they do
tend to shift more and more money into health and health care. But it’s also the
case that there is a tipping point with that, and we clearly have encountered that
tipping point here in the United States.
Across the country, we have states where the budget and the state board, say,
the Medicaid program or for other aspects of health care that are financed in part
by the states are sort of crowding out the ability to spend the money that those
states might want to spend more on the education. And I just finished saying that
our level of education has a lot to do to contribute to our health. So we are kind
of in this vicious cycle at this point in this country and other countries feel that
they are getting close to that, too. So to the degree that other countries are
figuring out ways to try to restrain the cost of health care or even lower the cost
of health care, we have got some opportunities to learn from them as well.
Mark Masselli: Let's talk a little bit about some of those big challenges that you
have laid out in terms of rising costs and limited resources here in the United
States and our effort to improve our own health care system. Health Affairs has
written about the unfinished business with the Affordable Care Act and as we
know, the act has some hidden gems embedded within it and it also has some
gaping holes. Can you share us with your thoughts on both of those?
Susan Dentzer: Yes. I think very much the unfinished business is what we are
all really grappling with right now because despite what a lot of the pundits and
pontificators say, you will frequently hear the statements made that the Affordable
Care Act did nothing to restrain the rate of growth of health cost, that’s really not
accurate. What the Affordable Care Act did though was set up a series of very
elaborate experiments that we can undertake to try to figure out how to restrain
the rate of growth of health cost.
Now, the important point to make here is if we knew exactly how to do this and to
do it in a way that was in sync with our other values, believe me we would have
done it as Americans. So all of the struggle here is to figuring how we do this
and how we get the other things that we want. For example, we obviously want
innovation in health care, and we want better drugs, we want better devices. We
don’t want to much of that that we crowd out the spending on the things that we
think will influence health in long run as I have just said.
So how do we have an environment where we have a lot of innovation in health
care and health care products and services but we still have that at affordable
cost? That’s a really tough issue. How do we have what we want in terms of
access to health care without breaking the bank and who decides – we know
that this country reviles that the notion of rationing at the governmental level.
Well, then what’s the alternative if we are not going to ration at the governmental
level overall? Again, if people had figured all of this out and could quantify it into
law, believe me it would have been done.
So what the Affordable Care Act does is okay, let’s set up some experiment of
new kinds of systems that operate in a different way than we have operated our
system so far, and let’s see if those work. And some of those systems that now
people are hearing a lot about are, for example, so-called accountable care
organization. And what this really is is an attempt to create a health care delivery
system that first of all is not paid the way our current system is paid. We pay
health care providers nowadays mostly almost on the fee-for-service basis.
So every little thing that a doctor does, he builds separately for and you can
imagine what this leads to as George Bernard Shaw once memorably said, “If
you pay surgeons to chop off legs, each leg you are going to have a ______
16:38 lots of amputees.” It's just inherent in the process, even well meaning,
they will just find reasons why it's probably in your best interest to have your legs
at all. That’s what fee for service does, it incentivizes volume. So we are looking
at new way of paying system that doesn’t do that.
The second thing we are doing is trying to figure out ways of rewarding health
care delivery systems so they actually improve our health and so that these
systems are rewarded because they improve our health or keep us healthy.
Now, you would say, well why didn’t we think of that before. Well, for various
reasons, we structured a system what incentives do hospitals have, they have
incentives to fill up their hospital beds and get paid. Wouldn’t it be a wonderful
thing if we had a system where hospitals were paid to keep themselves empty?
Ideally, we want to keep people out of the hospital as much as possible,
especially in the context of chronic illness. We want to keep you so healthy that
you don’t have to go into the hospital.
So figuring out a way to incentivize a health care delivery system to keep us as
healthy as possible really becomes the name of the game. And so that’s what
the Affordable Care Act does. These are big important national experiments to
figure out if we can try to create systems where we pay people to keep us
healthy or as healthy as possible. Hopefully, we continue to incentivize
innovation, and we do it in a way that distributes the care more equitably than we
have historically because we are also giving coverage to the people who were
previously uninsured. That’s a pretty important set of experiments and that’s the
unfinished – that’s the overall most important unfinished business of Health
Reform.
Margaret Flinter: Great, and that’s a very good overview of those issues. Susan,
no surprise you probably we are both devoted readers of Health Affairs, and we
certainly observe that you have really kept a spotlight on the issue of the need for
transformation of primary care and examples of where primary care has been
transformed. And almost from the beginning of the patient-centered medical
home recognition programs and standards, we have seen a lot of focus on that.
So as the editor-in-chief, I would like to ask you this question, is the
transformation of primary care from your view a sweeping transformation across
the country or a slow crawl to a very uncertain outcome or somewhere in
between at this point?
Susan Dentzer: I think it's probably closer at this point. Let’s put it this way. To
this date, it's been a slow crawl. I think the crawl is picking up a lot of momentum
now because it is very, very clear, the evidence shows unequivocally that if you
have systems of primary care that are really vibrant and very importantly well
enough funded that can be vibrant, those systems produce better health and
better health care and cost less, very important. And what we have done without
intending to really in this country is we have let our primary care systems such as
this, first of all, not become a non-system, a nonfunctional system and pretty
much atrophy.
And why have we done this? Somebody is going to do some deep historical
investigations someday and figure out how it happened, but I think briefly what
happened is we put a lot of stock in very, very sophisticated, very advanced
medicine. We structured the payment system that tends to reward that type of
medicine, and we just forgot that we really need to pay people on the front end
better than we do. And in particular because a lot of primary care is not
intervention oriented, you know in a perfect world, your primary care doctor is
saying things to you like, “You really have to have a very sensible and
appropriate diet. You really have to exercise appropriately. You really cannot
smoke.” A lot of those prevention-oriented things, we either haven’t paid primary
care to do or we have paid them very poorly to do. And meanwhile, we pay
extraordinarily high rates for people to get stents inserted in their hearts once
they have serious heart blockages or what have you.
So we kind of have to chop the system back and say, “You know what, it really
matters to have primary care people who are very, very confident and well
compensated or compensated well enough that they can stay in business and
make a go of it.” And what we see now is a movement to, as you said, the so-
called patient-centered medical home or as it’s sometimes called in a way that
seems to scare people less the advanced primary care practice. And that’s
where, in essence, you have individuals who have a very close relationship with
a team of health care providers who are focused on their primary care.
It may or may not be led by a physician and may be led by a nurse practitioner. It
could very frequently involve very intensive regular connections with not just
nurses and nurse practitioners but also community health workers because
goodness knows we have plenty of examples where sort of pure relationships
with community health workers talking to people in their communities, helping
them understand the importance of good diet and exercise. And if they have
chronic illness, they being inherent to their medication regimens and things like
that, sometimes just feeling with the fear is more effective in having people –
have those kinds of behaviors than talking to a physician about it.
So we can put together teams like this, primary care team, that really work very
closely with individuals in their communities to keep them as healthy as possible
and to address whatever illnesses that they do have. And over time, if we make
that investment, I think it's fairly clear that we can keep people healthier, the
literature shows that, and that we will probably have cost savings at the end of
the line as a consequence of doing this.
Margaret Flinter: Today, we have been speaking with Susan Dentzer, Editor-in-
Chief of Health Affairs, the nation’s leading journal on health policy. Susan, thank
you so much for joining us today on Conversations.
Susan Dentzer: Great to be with you.
Mark Masselli: Each week, Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities into everyday lives.
Margaret Flinter: This week’s bright idea comes to us from Afghanistan where a
new midwifery training program is making childbirth safer in a country with a
second highest maternal and infant mortality rate in the world. The program was
created by JHPIEGO, an international health organization affiliated with the
Johns Hopkins University. This nonprofit has a track record empowering frontline
health workers for almost four decades, and its efforts have improved health care
for women and children in more than 140 countries worldwide.
Six years ago, JHPIEGO developed a plan to provide remote mountain villages
in Afghanistan, often very far away from health clinics, with the resources that
they needed to stop preventable deaths in childbirth. JHPIEGO has worked with
Afghanistan’s Ministry of Public Health to increase the number of village health
clinics and to establish accredited midwifery schools in every province of the
country. Now, young women can attend an 18-month midwifery training course in
their provincial capital. And although women are not typically allowed to have
jobs or travel alone in traditional Afghan society, a new system has been
developed where village health counsels enable the community leaders to
choose which women will receive the training based on their aptitude and interest
and their relationship with the community. The women return as midwives to
their villages, respected and ready to provide a full spectrum of prenatal delivery
and postpartum health services.
While the presence of a midwife is a new experience for many Afghan mothers,
most welcome the reassurance that these health workers provide. The
percentage of deliveries attended by skilled birth attendance has increased from
8% in 2003 to 19% in 2006. By training midwives to provide the delivery, support
and the infant care education that new mothers need, JHPIEGO is strengthening
Afghanistan’s health care system and improving maternal and infant survival
rates across the country. Now, that’s a bright idea.
This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli. Peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan
University at WESU, streaming live at Wesufm.org and brought to you by the
Community Health Center.