Dr. Garth Graham, Deputy Assistant Secretary for Minority Health at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Conversations on Health Care focuses today on addressing the healthcare needs of racial and ethnic populations. Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Dr. Garth Graham, Deputy Assistant Secretary for Minority Health at HHS, about reducing and eliminating health disparities through health care reform, enhanced data collection and a host of community and technology innovations.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: It's the dog days of August and Margaret and I are on vacation
but we planned ahead and we are bringing you a brand new episode for your
listening ears.
Margaret Flinter: Alright, Mark so let’s jump right into today’s show and introduce
our guest.
Mark Masselli: Today, we will be speaking with Dr. Garth Graham, Deputy
Assistant Secretary for Minority Health within the Department of Health and
Human Services. He will discuss federal policy in Minority Health and what work
remains to ensure that health care needs of racial and ethnic populations are
being met. We are happy to welcome Dr. Graham to our show today.
Margaret Flinter: No matter what the story, you can hear all of our shows on our
website www.chcradio.com , subscribe to iTunes and get the show downloaded
or, if you want to hang on to our every word and read a transcript of the shows,
come visit us at www.chcradio.com . And don’t forget, you can become a fan of
Conservations on Health Care on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: Welcome Dr. Graham.
Dr. Garth Graham: Thank you for having me Mark.
Mark Masselli: The Office of Minority Health was created in 1986 and came out
of then President Reagan’s Secretary of Health and Human Services Task Force
on Minority Health. Yet, health disparities continue today even though many
people know very little bit about such disparities in United States. Can you start
out by telling us about the Office of Minority Health?
Dr. Garth Graham: Sure. As you probably know Mark, our office was created as
a result of something called the Secretary’s Task Force on Black and Minority
Health which was issued back in the mid ‘80s and actually was the first federal
document to really document this issue of health disparities and spawned a lot of
different activities both here at HHS but in a number of states across the country
and started up the health disparities research activities over at NIH as well. So
really kind of spawned or really helped to I should say elevate the health
disparities movement. Our office has been charged over the years with
coordinating all the policies across HHS, and when I say HHS I mean the Food
and Drug Administration, CDC, NIH as well as the Health Resources and
Services Administration, and a whole bunch of other agencies so coordinating
much of those policies. But we also work with states and over the years have
helped to support and create a number of State Offices of Minority Health that
also exist at the state and local level. So it's been a journey so far in terms of the
role and the responsibilities of this office but certainly an exciting journey so far,
and a lot under the Affordable Care Act having to do with our office as well.
Margaret Flinter: So Dr. Graham, I would like to step back in time a little bit even
before the Office of Minority Health was established and go back to the Civil
Rights Movement of the late ‘50s and ‘60s and certainly the Reverend Martin
Luther King spoke eloquently to the issue of disparities saying, “Of all the forms
of inequality, injustice, health was the most shocking and the most inhumane”.
Can you give us a perhaps bit of a historical perspective on how federal policy
has affected health and health care for minority groups in the US over these past
50 years, specific legislation or programs that were implemented?
Dr. Garth Graham: Sure. Yeah you are right in going back to the 1960s because
there were a number of important things that happened in the 1960s. The
passage of legislation on Medicare desegregated hospitals and interestingly
enough, when you look back to exactly what that meant and going back some of
the words of Martin Luther King, it really pointed to the issue of up until that time
minorities were quite frankly receiving segregated care I should say and care
where people would only be physically located in one section of the hospital and
be seen by only one set of clinicians as well as health care services. So you are
right in really articulating that. This issue goes way, way, way, way back before
the Secretary of Task Force of Black and Minority Health. So Martin Luther King
articulated things well in terms of highlighting just how important this issue of
health and health care is to not only the health of a community but the future of a
community.
So what you saw from the late 1950s and 1960s and onwards, first the
desegregation of health care for minority populations which was a big move back
in the mid 1960s. In the 1970s, there was a Surgeon General Report that also
articulated much in terms of the disproportion and burden of illnesses that
minority communities faced so there were a lot of different not only reports but
activities. Interestingly now, when you look at the health disparities, health
disparities has a lot to do not just with the race and ethnicity of a person but also
more importantly I should say where they live. So we still to some degree see
health care that is based on the quality of care that a person receives in a
particular location depending on the location that the person lives in, there is a lot
of history that leads to the actual residential area in which a number of
communities end up in.
So it's an interesting intermixing of not only the health care system but really
telling the story of social infrastructure and how social infrastructure has
interacted with minority communities.
Mark Masselli: Now Dr. Graham, you mentioned a few minutes ago that the
Affordable Care Act lays out some opportunities to improve health outcomes and
specifically requires that the Secretary of Health make sure that federally
supported health surveys collect data on race, ethnicity, sex, primary language
and disability status. But the new rules that HHS put forward require federal
agencies collect health information at a much higher and more specific standard
and I think and hope that you will better understand the significant health issues
in specific populations. So tell us about your hope what you learned from the
enhanced data and how do you envision it being used to improve health
outcomes and reduce health disparities.
Dr. Garth Graham: Sure. So as you just pointed out, we just put out our
proposed standards for data collection around race, ethnicity, primary language,
sex, and disability status. And on the race ethnicity portion, previously in the
1990s, Office of Management and Budget, OMB had put out a series of
standards for race and ethnicity. And over the past couple of years even prior to
those standards, the country had become more and more and more diversified.
So it means that when we say Asian-American, there are a lot of differences
between the Hmong population and the Japanese population, great differences
between the Vietnamese population and Korean population. When we say
Hispanic and the Latino in terms of ethnicity, there are differences in terms of
health outcomes between Puerto Rican population and Cuban American
population. So there are differences even within category. So what we are trying
to do with these new standards is building on the OMB, the Office of
Management and Budget criteria that was put forward in the mid 1990s. It's to
further disaggregate data for race, ethnicity so when you look at and when we
talk about Asian-American, we go on to talk about Korean-American,
Vietnamese-American and other sub-segments of the Asian-American
community. Similarly, when you look at the Hispanic community, we are also
again looking at different sub-segments of the community. So really what we are
trying to do is to further and further disaggregate data on race and ethnicity as
well as looking at this issue of getting more definition around the primary
language that people speak. So we are hoping that that will be the new baseline
but certainly we hope and expect that there are many other surveys and data
collection activities that will go into more detail and granularity than even just
those surveys.
Margaret Flinter: Today, we are speaking with Dr. Garth Graham, Deputy
Assistant Secretary for Minority Health at the Department of Health and Human
Services. Dr. Graham, not so long ago the Commonwealth Fund issued a report
and made a bold statement based on their research that a high performance
health system can markedly reduce or even eliminate disparities in health and
health care. But we still see some disparities in health such as the persistent gap
in birth outcomes for African-American women for instance even when the gains
have been made in income and education and in access to health care. Tell us
little bit about the state of research in this area on health care disparities but also
on health outcome disparities even when other factors seem to have improved
for the better.
Dr. Garth Graham: Sure. The statistics around infant mortality in minority
communities really point to the complexity of the problem in terms of just all the
different factors that go into the health outcomes in minority populations. So you
are right that when we look on that infant mortality rate from comparing African-
American women to the rest of the general population, in many cases the infant
mortality rate which is the rate at which babies die within the first year of life,
babies of African-American women who have graduate degree, their infant
mortality rate is still higher than other women from a majority community who
have not graduated high school. So we see those disparities that still persist
even when you for lack of better terminology control for socioeconomic status.
So what does that mean in terms of moving forward? Well it means one, that
there is no simplistic way to deal with issue of health disparities, you can't just
categorize it as a socioeconomic status issue and just kind of chalk it up to that.
There are other issues that go beyond that and certainly access to cure is an
issue, certainly understanding how we interact with all the different for lack of a
better terminology social determinants of health, those things outside just the
definition of health, talking about jobs and education and all that kinds of things,
and how those things interact. Now one of the interesting things around the
infant mortality data is there is some data about the role of stress and just how
the role of stress in minority communities play a role in terms of those infant
mortality numbers. So it’s really a multifactorial kind of issue but as we move to
the high performing health care system that not only the Commonwealth Fund
but all of us involved in health and health care would like to see happen. I think
it’s going to be important to keep the patient at the center of that and understand
all the different dynamics that the patients go through.
Mark Masselli: Dr. Graham, Margaret and I have both been involved in health
care movement for quite a time and I think it’s axiomatic in our field that having
health insurance and having access to health care is fundamental to reducing
and eliminating health disparities. Now the Affordable Care Act speaks to that for
all Americans but what elements of the Health Reform Bill specifically addresses
health disparities either in terms of access or innovation or research or training.
And have any of those elements been implemented to date, can you let our
listeners, give them a little look at the waterfront?
Dr. Garth Graham: Yeah. So as you have pointed out, the insurance part of it
has been the part that has gotten the most attention and certainly we are trying to
improve the health system and access to the health system by providing various
options for improve the access whether that be through strengthening Medicaid
as well as other things like the Pre-Existing Condition Insurance Plan and other
kinds of plans like that to increase access to care. But you are right, the word
health disparities is mentioned numerous times across the Affordable Care Act
not just in the area of the insurance provision and to give you kind of a preview, it
talked about one of those things in terms of improving data on minority
populations, and that’s certainly one aspect. Also it does a number of things to
improve the infrastructure of how Department of Health and Human Services
deals with health disparities, it puts in health disparities infrastructure into the
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, it puts health disparities
infrastructure in a number of different ages from Substance Abuse and Mental
Health Services Administration to the Food and Drug Administration to a number
of places to have specific _____ 13:57 in those agencies that deal with health
disparities. It goes beyond that to also directing the department to put more of an
emphasis on cultural competency and things that we do around cultural
competency to help improve access to cultural competency curriculum and things
like that. So these are all things that have either been implemented or are in the
process of being implemented. So it’s really a transformative time period but I
think it’s also important to understand that the Affordable Care Act is not the end
all be all for all things health disparities related and there will need to be ongoing
and continued efforts outside of that. It’s certainly a step forward but it’s not the
panacea for the reduction of health disparities.
Margaret Flinter: Well you know Dr. Graham certainly one of the hallmarks of
everybody at HHS these days seems to be a commitment to innovation and to
strategic thinking and certainly inserting those centers for health disparity within
all the different agencies is a great step forward. But on the innovation front I
know I have heard you speak I think about the interest within your area of looking
at community health workers, something people don’t generally think of as part of
the traditional health care system although in many parts of the country that’s a
very proven model. Tell us a little bit about why that rises to the level of an
innovation that you would like to see put forth and what it promises to offer in the
area of reducing or eliminating health disparities.
Dr. Garth Graham: Sure. So community health workers have been quite frankly
a part of the community for a long time. I think the health care system is just
catching up to figuring out how to utilize those kinds of individuals and people in
communities that have been the go-to a person for understanding how you
navigate systems and for understanding all kinds of things about local
communities. And so that’s been in place historically in a number of underserved
communities, you kind of have that one person who can help people understand
what it is they need to do. What we are finding more and more is that the
incorporation of those kinds of individuals into the health care system, into health
care teams allows us to be able to reach folks in a number of different ways and
allows us to interact with the community like never before. So, as part of our
departmental strategic plan, our own health disparities, we have put a big
emphasis on community health workers. In the Latino community, they are
referred to Promotores and in fact our secretary, Secretary Sebelius, just
announced a Promotores initiative that we are doing; she announced it about two
or three weeks ago. And the long and short of it is what we are trying to say is
the department is going to be funding as well as working with forming partnership
with community health workers/ Promotores at a number of different levels and
the goal there really is to come up with new and innovative ways to reach people.
I understand that in many ways communities have already defined how they
interact with each other and it's about the health care system interacting with
communities at the grassroots level.
Mark Masselli: Well I think that’s an exciting work and certainly I think it flies in
the face of most people’s thinking that the Federal Government is here to help
but it’s not here to help at a local level, and you have really transformed that with
your initiatives there. Pull the thread a little if you will on how you are using
social media. I think so many of the younger people today are texting, they are
on Facebook and Twitter and I am probably dating myself because there are
probably newer things I should be saying here already. So talk to us a little bit
about how you start to conceptualize this local commitment using those outlets.
Dr. Garth Graham: Sure. So,, the story around social media is interesting. I
mean I think the revolution has been happening for some time now and it’s just
now that health care is catching up to utilize the social media in the right way so
there are number of different ways. Now certainly in our practical sense we have
made sure that we are present and availed in all the Twitter world as well as all
the other forms of social media whether it’s Facebook or anything along those
lines to make sure that we connect to people in a way that they are accustomed
to being connected with and interacting with the world. That’s one aspect. More
importantly though, what we are finding out is that these are powerful tools in
terms of reaching people in a very different kind of way. So right now as a
department we have a number of Text for X&Y campaign. So we have been
trying to reach young pregnant women with a Text4baby Campaign which
basically sends text messages to women who are pregnant with health
messages. And we are using that model in a number of other text for X or text
for Y campaigns in terms of using text messaging to reach folks. One of the
interesting things in 1999, the Department of Commerce released a study looking
at how minority communities interact with technology and it was one of those
initial reports to highlight the issue of a digital divide. What's interesting if you
look over the past 9 or 10 years that digital divide those till present is closing.
The Pew Hispanic Research folks published a recent data showing that Hispanic-
Americans as well as other minority communities too are utilizing broadband
technology and mobile phone technology all kinds of those technologies at a
faster rate compared to the general population. So that means that even though
the divide exists, the actual rate of the divide is closing because people are
starting to utilize these technologies as they become cheaper and cheaper. So
with that being said and done it's about us utilizing these methodologies as much
as other people are utilizing them appropriately.
Mark Masselli: When you look around the country and the world what do you
see in terms of innovation and who should our listeners at Conversations be
keeping an eye on?
Dr. Garth Graham: Oh that’s an interesting question. Well, across the country I
think what you see is you see a lot of pockets of innovation at local level. You
see some interesting things in New York City where people are trying to create
local healthier zones and things along those lines. You see some interesting
things in Colorado where people are trying to link hospital systems to a lot of kind
of local health collaboratives, and you see interesting things in a number of
different local communities like that. What I would say we should keep an eye on
is even beyond that there are a number of I would say kind of younger people
coming up. And the other day the USDA had a bunch of us judging young chefs
who were in high schools who were cooking healthy meals on an annual healthy
foods competition. And it’s interesting to me just how many of those young kids
who were 17-18 years old understood how to create food in a way that would be
appealing to young people and old people alike. So my point in saying that long-
winded answer is we have to pay attention to what's going on at the local level
and find some of those young and even older unsung heroes who are coming up
with local solutions to problems that hopefully at some point we can translate to a
national level.
Margaret Flinter: Today, we have been speaking with Dr. Garth Graham, Deputy
Assistant Secretary for Minority Health at the Department of Health and Human
Services. Dr. Graham, thank you so much for joining us on Conversations Today
Dr. Garth Graham: Thank you for having me.
(Music)
Mark Masselli: Each week, Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives.
This week’s bright idea focuses on an initiative that uses a strategic public health
approach to violence prevention. CeaseFire has its roots in Chicago where
youth violence is often referred to as an epidemic. Last year, nearly 700 children
were hit by gunfire, an average of almost 2 a day. So in 2000, when the program
was launched by the Chicago Project for Violence Prevention, finally it began to
be treated as a public health crisis instead of merely a crime problem. CeaseFire
uses public education campaigns, GED Programs, and various counseling
opportunities to target violence but its main tool is community mobilization.
Trained volunteers from the community called Violence Interrupters establish a
rapport with gang leaders and other at risk youth just like outreach workers within
a public health campaign. Many interrupters are from the communities they
serve and many are former criminals who know violence firsthand. The
interrupters work the streets helping to keep minor arguments from becoming
deadly and mediating more aggressive ones between gangs. After a shooting,
they intervene with non-violent alternatives to stop the victim’s friends and family
from retaliating. The program has produced encouraging results. The US
Department of Justice conducted a three year evaluation in 8 of 18 Chicago
communities where CeaseFire has been adopted. Shooting and killings have
been reduced by 41% to 73% and retaliatory killings by a 100% in five of the
communities. The model has been replicated more than a dozen times
nationally. A public health approach to stopping violence with hard statistics to
back it up, now that’s a bright idea.
(Music)
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli. Peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan
University at WESU, streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.