Drs. Jerome Groopman and Pamela Hartzband, authors of the new book Your Medical Mind.

This week, Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Dr. Jerome Groopman, a Harvard physician and New Yorker staff writer, and Dr. Pamela Hartzband, an endocrinologist and faculty member at Harvard Medical School, about their new book Your Medical Mind: How to Decide What is Right for You. They explore what influences our medical decisions– from personal biases to statistical influences on decisions to test and treat.

To download a full transcript of this episode click here.

(Music)

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.

Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.

Mark Masselli: Today, Margaret, and I are speaking with Dr. Jerome Groopman,
and Pamela Hartzband about their new book Your Medical Mind; How to Decide
What Is Right For You published by Penguin Press. Dr. Groopman is an
oncologist at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston on the faculty at
Harvard Medical School and staff writer for the New Yorker. Dr. Hartzband is a
noted endocrinologist at Beth Israel as well as a faculty member at Harvard
Medical School. Welcome to you both. Medical decisions are some of the
toughest and most difficult decisions we need to make in our lives and your book
is full of stories about how different people have made medical decisions. If
there is one key idea that you would like people to take away from your book
about making these decisions, what would it be?

Jerome Groopman: I think the key message is there is no single right answer for
everyone. So unlike mathematics where you are posed a problem and there is
one correct solution, in medicine there is a very, very large grey zone. So what is
the right choice for one patient is not necessarily the right choice for another
patient.

Margaret Flinter: So, I thought you both pointed out in very compelling ways
different people bring different sets of biases to this decision making process and
some people perhaps want the most intervention possible, others want the least.
Can you tell us more about these biases and maybe explain this concept of
availability bias and the role that anecdotes and stories and data all play in
influencing health care decision making?

Pamela Hartzband: We found that patients made their decisions in different
ways. Some people were maximalists; they wanted to be ahead of the curve,
very proactive, and do everything and more to take care of their health problems.
And other people were minimalists; they wanted to do just the absolute minimum
that was necessary, for them less was more. And then we found that people
segregated out. Some people wanted to follow more natural remedies things like
acupuncture, herbal remedies, natural supplements and so on and at the other
end of that spectrum were people with a technology orientation who wanted the
latest greatest technological breakthrough in the laboratory and then finally, the
last category were believers and doubters. So believers were convinced that
there is a good solution for their medical problem and all they had to do was find
it and then they would go for it and doubters are always worried about side
effects, unintended consequences, maybe the treatment is going to be worse
than the disease.

Jerome Groopman: So these mindsets then are sort of where you began with
regard to your personal approach to health. And then we are influenced very
deeply by stories. We all live our lives hearing stories and stories make the world
concrete and accessible to us. And because stories are so powerful, they
become deeply imprinted on our minds and therefore available. So when we are
considering choices, we remember or we access what is most available in our
minds. So if your Uncle Fred took a pill and had a terrible side effect from it it's
not likely that you would want to take that medication. But if a friend at work had
a surgery for a certain problem and came out just with a wonderful outcome, you
would be predisposed to pursuing that treatment, that surgical approach. But
that may not be what’s right for you. So you need to step back and consider the
stories but put those stories in the larger context of information.

Mark Masselli: You know in addition to biases that can shape our decision
making, they also shape the way that we look at data. And I think our country is
probably best captured, or culture of our country is best captured maybe by Mark
Twain who said, “There are three types of lies: l ies , damned lies, and statistics "
so. But we really need to base our decisions on sound data, on sound stats and
unfortunately, too often people only look at part of the data for example the
probability of curing an ailment without looking at the probability of complications
from the treatment. Can you tell us more about conflicting health care data and
how patients and doctors should work together to fully understand data related to
patient conditions?

Jerome Groopman: Well I think something that we propose in the book which
should be the starting point and addresses your question is every patient should
ask what is the likely outcome with no treatment. With regard to the Mark Twain
for example, we tell the story of a woman we call Susan Powell who has a high
cholesterol and her doctors gives her a statistic. This statin medication will
reduce your risk for a heart attack by 30%. Now that sounds very impressive.
And the reason it sounds so impressive is because when we hear that it's going
to reduce our risk by 30%, our mind plays a trick on us. We imagine we are
100% at risk for a heart attack. But in fact Susan discovered when asking the
question what if I do nothing, a woman in her 40s with an elevated cholesterol
but no other risk factors that the likelihood that she would have a heart attack in
the ensuing 10 years was one in hundred, 1%. So that’s a place to begin. And
then when you hear it reduces your risk by 30%, 30% of one is not a very big
impact, not in her mindset because she is a minimalist, she is a doubter. So I
think that you are completely correct that there are statistics that are framed or
presented to us in ways that can be very misleading not only for patients but also
for doctors.

Pamela Hartzband: There have been a number of studies that show that
depending on how you present information whether it's absolute benefit or
absolute risk versus relative benefit or relative risk that your understanding of

those numbers is very different. So for medications like cholesterol-lowering
medications, patients would believe that a medication was 10 times more
effective than it really was depending on how the information was presented.
And what was even more surprising you said in a very recent study it was found
that doctors were just as confused by the numbers of patients when information
was presented as relative risk or relative benefit rather than absolute.

Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. Today, we are speaking
with Dr. Jerome Groopman and Dr. Pamela Hartzband about their new book Your
Medical Mind: How to Decide What Is Right For You. So one thing I think we
would all agree on and we are sure recommendations do change and we have all
seen this many times in the course of our careers. We have a very current
example, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force with their new
recommendations advising against the PSA blood test screening meant for
prostate cancer and this one of course has been debated for a long time in health
care but now they are coming out against a recommendation for screening. So
maybe you can take us through how you communicate and how your colleagues
communicate with patients about recommendations which really don’t even have
the feeling of black and white at the time that they are being made because we
have seen change before we know it may come. What's the communication with
patients where we just aren't sure?

Pamela Hartzband: Prostate cancer is a great example of conflicting expert
advice. There are three different groups looking at the same information and
coming out with three different sets of recommendations.

Jerome Groopman: I think what hasn’t come out clearly in a lot of the _____8:46
reports which struck us because we actually refer to it in the book and we have
an extensive set of notes about PSA screening is that there were two very large
studies, one done in the United States one done in Europe that were published in
2009 that were supposed to settle this, supposed to be a black and white answer.
But both of these studies actually were not designed or executed in a way that
gave definitive answers. In United States Study which showed no clear benefit to
PSA screening, there was one group that had regular screening every year and
then a control group which you would think would not have PSA screening but
instead they left it to the discretion of the patient and the doctor. So, more than
half of the men in the control group actually had PSA screening so this study is
muddled. And in Europe, they didn’t even have detailed information on the
control group with regard to the active grouping, PSA tested, and the control
group in one center, about a third of the men had a PSA screening. And in the
European study, in younger man, there appeared to be a survival benefit saving
lives. The other problem which I think is hard for the public to grasp but once it’s
communicated it’s clear is that it’s very easy to measure life and death, you are
alive or you are dead. But how you weight for example someone who doesn’t die
from prostate cancer but the tumors grow in his lower pelvis, they move into his
bones and so on, he may die of a heart attack or a stroke or whatever, but his life

can be made pretty miserable and you weigh that against doing surgery or
radiation on a man where the tumor may never be a problem and that leaves him
incontinent or impotent. So how do you weigh this? It’s really a grey zone and I
think that patients are really in the term empowered when they understand that
there is no certainty here and the middle road is probably the wisest to try to
figure out for you as an individual how you weigh the potential risks and benefits
with information that is far from perfect.

Mark Masselli: I want to pull the thread a little on that because in your book you
recognize that sometimes treatments don’t work out as well as the doctor had
hoped and when a patient felt pressured to follow that treatment in the first place
they can wind up with feelings of regret and betrayal. But you argue that even
when a treatment is not effective it’s a better outcome for the patients when they
are full partners in the decision making process. Tell us a little more about that.

Pamela Hartzband: So in our book we discuss two patients who both had
orthopedic surgery for basically degenerative problems and problems that occur
with aging and both had an unsuccessful result in that they were still left with
pain. They were both disappointed but one had tremendous regret. So the
patient Lisa, that we call Lisa, had foot surgery and she felt that she was pushed
into this by the doctor and she wasn’t following her own medical mind, her own
way of doing things and when the surgery didn’t work she was consumed with
regret. Whereas Carl had a knee problem and had surgery for his knee and also
had a bad result, was left with a lot of pain and couldn’t do the things he wanted
to do, and he was disappointed too but he didn’t have regret because he had
followed his own medical mind, he did things the way he thought he should and
the process was right for him so he in the end felt it was the right thing to have
done even though it didn’t work.

Jerome Groopman: Regret is an enormous burden. I mean I can speak
personally I did not understand my medical mind. I at a very younger age was a
maximalist and a believer to the extreme and because I didn’t have the language
to understand myself and didn’t have a physician who might challenge my
thinking but just acted as a rubber stamp, I went ahead and had a back surgery
for lots of back pain, I was a distance runner and so on but I didn’t have a big
blown disk or anything like that and the surgery was a catastrophe; it left me in
more pain and debility than I was before. But as you say, you can't guarantee
the outcome on the surgery but the regret that I felt was that I really had not gone
through a process with my eyes open, I had made the decision blind. And what
we hope with the book and the reason we show this to people in this particular
chapter is that when you are not making decisions blindly, you really can
unburden yourself of this terrible sense of regret.

Margaret Flinter: You know a while back on this show we focused on the issue of
shared decision making and I think there is a general sense that that offers a lot
of potential to both make patients more satisfied with their decisions, maybe even

to improve cost when people look at relative benefits and risks. But I think as
clinicians, we have all had the experience of going through the relative risks and
benefits and the information the patient turns to you and says so what do you
think I should do, what would you do if you were me and that’s a hard thing. And
when we think about the diversity of our patients and I know Health Affairs is
focused on the persisting health inequities this month in their issue. We think
about patients who are challenged by speaking different languages, by low
literacy levels at least in English, maybe other challenges, cultural differences, it’s
a complicated thing to explain all of this. Maybe you can speak a little bit to your
experience, you are there in Boston it’s certainly one of the great melting pots of
the world. What's the experience in trying to work through these processes with
people who represent many different cultures, languages and backgrounds?

Jerome Groopman: By giving people terms, by giving people words, language,
and vocabulary to try to better understand their own thinking and how that
thinking fits in with their own background and culture, there is a very strong
naturalism orientation among people often who come from Asia and India. We
have been told this by physician colleagues who come from that cultural heritage
that you can connect with the patient in a much more direct way because you
find the common language, you find the common terms. And in terms of
someone saying to us well what would you do, often they say, “Well if I were your
mother, what would you say?” And as you can tell from reading the book
because Pam writes about her mother and I write about my own mother, my
mother was a believer and maximalist so I mean if she had a problem, she would
have taken care of it yesterday to the maximum.

Pamela Hartzband: My mother was a minimalist and a doubter. She was one of
those people who feels that less is more and possibly the treatment is going to
be worse than the disease. So the recommendation for her might be very
different from Jerry’s mother who was a maximalist and a believer. So you have
to tailor the recommendation to the mind of the particular patient and keep in
mind that doctors have medical minds too so the way they recommend things to
you reflects their own medical mind or how they approach medical problems
themselves.

Mark Masselli: And as you say that medical decisions are personal decisions
that patients make with their family that speak a common language and
understand each other. But on a personal note, in addition to working together at
Harvard and Beth Israel Deaconess and collaborating on this book in many
articles, you are also husband and wife, and in the beginning of your book, you
say we realize that each of us had started our careers with a different conception
of medical care, the old saying opposites attract applied to you. What did you
learn from writing this book together and what do you hope both patients and
doctors will learn about the role families play in making medical decisions?

Jerome Groopman: Well, I think what we hope is that people will understand
their medical mind and that insight will help them with their doctors make the
choice that’s right for them. My medical mind as you say, as I write, was a
believer and a maximalist so my mine initial inclination when offered a treatment
option is yes, let’s do it to the maximum, I am going to do it, let’s get on
underway. But by understanding myself, I can step back for a second and say
wait, is that really the wisest choice for me as an individual.

Mark Masselli: Today, we have been speaking with Dr. Jerome Groopman and
Dr. Pamela Hartzband about their new book Your Medical Mind: How to Decide
What Is Right For You published by Penguin Press. Thank you so much for
joining us today.

Jerome Groopman: Thank you.

(Music)

Mark Masselli: Each week Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives. This week’s bright
idea looks to churches to address disparities in health care. Immigrants tend to
avoid the US health care system for many reasons. It may be language barriers,
cultural differences, even fear. One health system in Virginia has been trying to
help by working with churches in the state to promote health and wellness for
Hispanic immigrant populations.

It is the best connection that we have because people rely on the faith
communities and they trust their leader and they trust the community so it's the
best way to communicate with them.

Mark Masselli: Most recently, Inova Health Systems has been training church
volunteers to reach out to pregnant women in the congregations. In Virginia,
one-third of Hispanic women don’t receive any prenatal health care during their
first trimester of pregnancy. In addition to teaching them about proper health and
nutrition during pregnancy, the volunteers are able to answer questions the
women have about documentation and where to go for care if they don’t have
insurance. Inova also helps congregations coordinate health fairs and
screenings and support groups for chronic conditions. Stepping outside of the
confines of the health system to connect with special populations who face
barriers to care, now that’s a bright idea.

(Music)

Loren Bonner: We close with the tech report, our weekly look at how people are
using technology to improve and wellness. I am Loren Bonner. Many patients
are going online to gather information about their conditions. These patients, or
e-patients as they are known, are more empowered to make choices about their

own health care by confront issues of finding quality information. This week we
want to highlight an individual who is bringing quality social media resources to
doctors and patients. Bertalan Meskó is a recent medical school graduate living
in Hungary, now a PhD candidate in clinical genomic and personalized medicine.
Meskó’s passion is to have e-patients and medical professionals know more
about social media and to get them the best resources to use it effectively. In
2009, while he was still in medical school in Hungary, he launched
Webicina.com, a social media guidance service for patients and medical
professionals. Meskó joined me by Skype. I asked him why he wanted to create
this service.

Bertalan Meskó: Whenever I tried to find quality cardiology blogs for genetic
podcasts, it would be so much time and effort to find the best ones that I thought
that there should be a service that does that hopefully for everyone.

Loren Bonner: Webicina seems to be paving the way. Mesko and his team go
through thousands of social media resources daily and come up with lists of the
most relevant ones in a medical specialty or a condition. They have covered
over 80 medical topics with over 4,000 social media resources ranging from
Twitter and YouTube videos to Facebook groups and blogs. On top of that, they
have made these services available in 18 languages. While the number of e-
patients is growing exponentially in many countries, the number of web savvy
doctors isn’t catching up. So Mesko is trying to fill this gap as well.

Bertalan Meskó: And the doctors maybe can do a (Inaudible 00:22:02) would like
to help these patients more effectively.

Loren Bonner: Mesko has created the very first university course to help
medical, pharma, and dental students know more about social media. He plans
to offer the course online so that medical students and doctors from around the
world can attend.

Bertalan Meskó: I am sure that they will be able to help daily patients or at least
they will know that there are solutions for the problems of visiting patients.

Loren Bonner: Mesko says these are the most important steps for the next few
years.

(Music)

Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.

Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.

Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the Campus of Wesleyan
University at WESU, streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.

(Song)