Dr. James Weinstein-director of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice and co-founder of the new Dartmouth Center for the Science of Health Care Delivery.
Conversations on Health Care® focuses this week on the contributions Dartmouth College has made to health reform and innovation. Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Dr. James Weinstein, the leader driving the health policy and delivery research efforts at Dartmouth.
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare; I am Mark Masselli.
Margaret Flinter: I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: Margaret, we celebrate our one-year anniversary this week here
on Conversations and looking back it's been quite a run. I remember our first
guest was Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi. She was going to call in at 02:30
and guess what there was nobody here to record on that day but as it turned out
she didn’t call in for about another hour and our Radio Producer showed up so
those were some of the early beginnings of it but we had a great run, we had
wonderful people very dynamic speakers. Todd Park comes to mind who is just
enthusiastic about fusing data and technology to improve America’s healthcare
and certainly Dr. Brent James at Intermountain Healthcare a great model of
quality and efficiency.
Margaret Flinter: Oh we have certainly had a front row seat by talking to some of
those interesting thinkers in healthcare today. And it has been a very exciting
year with all of the pre and post health reform drama to say nothing of the actual
legislation that we now have. And yet, Mark I was thinking this morning nothing
happens in a vacuum, we can't look back at the first year of Conversations and
celebrate Health Reform but that also being very aware of the lagging economy
how many people are out of work, the environmental disaster in Louisiana and
then ever increasing partisanship divide both in DC and it seems across the
country which makes me think it's a very good thing that so much cost for
optimism when I look at the next generation including that freshman class that
just rolled into town in campus here at Wesleyan University.
Mark Masselli: And thanks to Health Reform, they can stay on their parents’
insurance policy till their age 26 but hopefully they are gainfully employed and
making the transformations that our country needs. Let’s take a minute to point
out some of the other benefits though that the reform legislation has and we will
beginning to roll out essential feature of the bill was that patient’s bill of rights
prohibiting insurers from setting lifetime limits on coverage, banning insurance
companies from denying coverage based on preexisting conditions preventing
insurers from dropping coverage after patient get sick and requiring plans to
cover a comprehensive preventative services. These five provisions take effect
rd
September 23 .
Margaret Flinter: And the new figures released by the census bureau in its
annual report support the need for these changes. The census is showing that
the percentage of people living in the United States without a health insurance
rose to 16.7% in 2009 now that’s the highest raise since the census bureau
began collecting data in 1987 and certainly goes along with the increased
demand that we were seeing for primary care by the uninsured.
Mark Masselli: Well, lawmakers and interest groups took the figures as an
opportunity to argue the law, democrats and the liker for expanding government
and employer sponsored Health Reform. Republicans say that they have a
better plan in mind. There is still a lot of confusion in unknowns about what the
plan is going to do especially if republicans win control of the Congress.
Margaret Flinter: We will be hearing much more about this in the coming months.
But let’s tune now to our interview with today’s guest, Dr. James Weinstein,
Director of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice. He is
also the President of the Dartmouth Hitchcock Clinic and the co-founder of the
New Dartmouth Center for the Science of Health Care Delivery. Dartmouth has
made important contributions to health reform and innovation. It's best known
perhaps the Dartmouth Atlas Project and we will be talking with Dr. Weinstein
about that and also about much more.
Mark Masselli: We are happy you can join today but no matter what the story,
you can hear all of our shows on our website www.chcradio.com . You can
subscribe to iTunes to get our show regularly downloaded or if you would like to
hang onto our every word and read a transcript of one of our shows, come visit
us at www.chcradio.com . You can become a fan of Conversations on Healthcare
on Facebook and also follow us on Twitter. We are also happy to announce that
Connecticut Station WNHU 88.7 FM in West Haven will broadcast our show on
Mondays at 2:00 p.m.
Margaret Flinter: And as always if you have feedback email us at chcradio.com.
We love to hear from you. Now before we speak with Dr. Weinstein let's check in
with our producer Loren Bonner for the headline news.
Loren Bonner: I am Loren Bonner with this week’s headline news. Newly
released figures from the census bureau are proving to be a prime opportunity for
the Obama Administration to sell the healthcare bill and tout some of the new
benefits that kick in this week. The percentage of people living in the US without
health insurance rose to 16.7%. In 2009 the highest rate since the census
bureau began collecting data in 1987, according to the report released last
Thursday. Health secretary Kathleen Sebelius in an interview on C-Span says
that the economy has taken a huge toll on uninsured Americans and she says
this underscores how important the bill was to enact this year.
Kathleen Sebelius: I think it makes it more important than ever that we rebuild
this market. There are some provisions in place to stabilize the current market,
to provide some help to employers and to early retiree plans, to keep coverage in
place and then a new market by 2014.
Loren Bonner: As a series of tough insurance restrictions going to effect
rd
September 23 for new health plans the Obama administration will use every
platform available to communicate them. And to arbitrary recessions, lifetime
limits on coverage and preexisting conditions for kids among them. Hundreds of
events across the country are being organized to market the 6-month
anniversary of the law. Following secretary Sebelius’s declaration last week of
the zero tolerance for insurers falsely blaming premium increases for 2011 on the
patient protections in the Affordable Care Act several senate democrats send
letters to 5 insurance companies warning them against telling consumers their
rates are going up because of the new mandates in the healthcare law. State
regulators have said that some insurers seem to be guessing at the additional
costs. The most closely watched legal challenge facing the healthcare law went
before a federal judge in Florida last week. 20 states and an influential small
business group are challenging the constitutionality of the mandate over
coverage. Judge Robert Vincent indicated that he would allow parts of the
lawsuit to proceed, which parts are not yet specified. The hearings and oral
th
arguments and the motion for summery judgment will be held on December 16 .
Margaret Flinter: This week on Conversations on Healthcare we are looking at
how academic research has influenced healthcare reform. Dartmouth College
has been a leader on this front most notably with its findings from the Dartmouth
Atlas Project which maps geographic variations and care and the cost for
Medicare recipients across the country. A new report from the Dartmouth Atlas
maybe worth considering as we move toward a healthcare delivery system
focused on primary care. The findings in the Dartmouth report show that neither
higher amounts of primary care services nor making sure patients routinely see a
primary care clinician is by itself a guarantee that a patient will get recommended
care or better outcomes. The research also finds that patients access to primary
care, a quality of overall care and the likelihood of hospitalization very greatly in
different locations. In other words where patients live has a great influence on
the care they receive than the color of their skin. The authors of the report note
that despite the importance of primary care access is not enough to guarantee
high quality care. Achieving this requires better coordination between specialists
and hospitals. If you want to check out or download the new report, go to our
show web page chcradio.com. Let’s turn now to our interview with Dr. James
Weinstein who can tell us more about how Dartmouth is reforming and innovating
healthcare delivery.
( Music )
Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Healthcare. Today we are speaking
with Dr. James Weinstein, Director of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy
and Clinical Practice, home to the Dartmouth Atlas. He is also a president of the
Dartmouth Hitchcock Clinic and co-founder of the new Dartmouth Center for the
Science of Healthcare Delivery, welcome. Dartmouth College has been a leader
in the healthcare reform and innovation and particular with research that has
stemmed from the Dartmouth Atlas, set of studies that maps geographic
variations and how US regions and cities vary in care in cost for Medicare
recipients, what role in advancing or informing healthcare reform has the institute
for health policy and clinical practices home to the Atlas plate.
James Weinstein: I think it's been significant Mark. The Dartmouth Atlas work
the Jacqueline work started back in the 1970s. It really shined a light on this idea
of variation and practice. It's really enigmatic, meaning it's really puzzling to
people that think that healthcare knows exactly what it's doing and if you are
going to your doctor that they are the best doctor and you get the best care and
you know I think the work of the Dartmouth Atlas really so that’s not true. It's
hard to grab that, because people have great faith in the health profession as I
think they should but it's an industry that hasn’t had the measurement and the
feedback at a public level in a transparent way.
Margaret Flinter: Well Dr. Weinstein, it's certainly was clear during the debates
and health reform that the findings of the Atlas really became quite influential and
we understand that the New Yorker article writer by Dr. Atul Gawande that heavily
referenced the Atlas findings even became required reading for the White House
during the debate. And as a result I understand the administration his promise to
ask the institute of medicine to consider ways of putting the findings into action in
some way and the one suggested method is to actually set payment rates that
would reward efficient hospitals, hospitals that really had a handle on this cost
care balance. What’s the status of putting this into action and what do you see is
I am sure there are some big challenges there. But what do you see is the
challenges and obstacles to using the findings to really drive change?
James Weinstein: Living in both worlds as I do as a researcher in running a
hospital system, I understand the complexities of actually trying to make reality
out of what the institute shows and puts forward. I don’t know that there are
really any obstacles. I think what the Institute of Medicine’s challenge will be to
say what is value-based medicine. And then of course when there is money
involved it's always sensitive or politics involved. It's sensitive about how that
affects me or my state, and we know that from the Dartmouth Atlas that for
example, there is a 2 ½ -fold difference across United States and just rates of
reimbursement by Medicare. Is that really fair and some people would say well it
costs more to live in my state. But these things are adjusted for cost in states.
The hope is that, that the Dartmouth Atlas will at least be core information, it has
shine the light on where we have opportunities and that the institute of medicine
with great minds will use that information in ways to try to layout strategies
around what we hope will become a value based payment system.
Mark Masselli: You co-founded with President Kim the new Dartmouth Center for
The Science of Healthcare Delivery, which promises I think to bring some real
new energy and to identifying strategies for healthcare transformation. What's a
mission of the new center and can you share with our listeners some of the initial
priority projects with the center?
Dr. James Weinstein: I think the Dartmouth with Dr. Weinberg we have invented
and started the evaluative sciences and looked at you know national data
through the Dartmouth Atlas but there is not been the science of healthcare
delivery. We know about the genes, we know about the drugs, we know about
the variation, how do we actually implement the change in a healthcare system
more broadly. Dr. Kim and I believe that this is really an opportunity for the nation
much like the National Cancer Centers that were started years ago that took on
the tremendous problem with cancer in our nation and we would like to see 40
centers of healthcare delivery science across the country, supported by federal
dollars at least in part just started to take on how do we actually deliver the best
diabetic care, how do we actually deliver the best breast cancer care. We have
one diabetic program that really works nationally from Utah with Brent James,
why aren’t we doing that nationally as a nation. Well you know Dr. Kim is famous
for his work outside United States in tuberculosis and AIDS, where people said
you know you can't treat drug resistant TB etc. The fact of the matter is that Paul
Farmer and Jim did that in countries with a lot less resources than we have and a
lot cheaper. We actually believe that we should take the lessons from those
kinds of work that German Paul did and bring him to United States, things don’t
have to cost a lot of money to do well. Let’s do the case study and see how we
do that in United States for the best price in the most sufficient way and replicate
that across the country.
Margaret Flinter: Well that is a very exciting, thrilling I would say agenda and we
look forward to participating in some of that with you and thank you for
mentioning Dr. Brent James because I was just about to mention it to you, Dr.
James the Chief Quality Officer at Intermountain Healthcare is someone that we
have spoken to about putting into practice Shared Decision Making, and you of
course founded, I believe the first in a country center for Shared Decision Making
back in 1999 and as Dr. James share with our listeners the benefits of Shared
Decision Making which involves presenting patients with the pros and the cons of
all the viable choices of treatments really promises a new level of involving
patients in their healthcare decision making, how do you see this model evolving
across the country and in particular we are curious are you seeing it carried into
the area of end of life care which certainly wasn’t incredibly galvanizing issue
throughout the healthcare reform debates.
Dr. James Weinstein: My belief in opening that center in 1999 was that we
haven't had the right people involved in decisions of healthcare all the time and
specifically the patient. It should be about the patient and their beliefs and their
values and what we have learned over the years in many, many studies now,
where patients are well informed by an independent source without conflict,
patients make really good decisions about their healthcare and often times
choose the lesson which has just effective treatment as opposed to the more
expensive and may be not as effective treatment. Of course doctors talk to their
patients. But the notion that we have actually studied this for years now and
found that about 30% of patients on average when given this kind of independent
information make a different decision than they do if they are just talking to their
doctor makes me think. And the reason why we started this center that there is
tremendous opportunity here. What's the solution? The doctors are worried
about taking away their autonomy, people are worried about reimbursements.
The end of life issues you mentioned people are worried that people are going to
keep them from having the treatments that they need to sustain their life for a
longer period of time, when in fact when they are well informed they would
choose not to die in a hospital, they would choose to be home with their loved
ones. They would choose not to be in intensive care unit having multiple tests to
prolong their life for a matter of weeks to months as opposed to being with their
loved ones and dying at home. End of life is a very expensive part of our
healthcare system and it’s not just dollars and cents it’s what it does to families
and their loved ones. We need to allow patients who are sharing these decisions
about things that matter to them most, their health.
Mark Masseli: Today we are speaking with Dr. James Weinstein, Director of the
Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice, President of the
Dartmouth-Hitchcock Clinic and cofounder of the New Dartmouth Center for the
Science Healthcare Delivery, should also note since you were talking about
spinal surgery that you were also the founder of the Spine Center at Dartmouth-
Hitchcock. You know few weeks ago we were talking with Dr. Fitzhugh Mullan
about our country’s effort to train the next generation of healthcare providers to
meet the evolving demands of the American population. And he spoke about the
many new innovations in medical education. Can you tell us what’s new at
Dartmouth around training the next generation and are you seeing a difference in
the focus of new medical students and maybe juxtapose that against your own
days as a student?
Dr. James Weinstein: Mark, I think the notion of training the next generation of
physicians is extremely challenging but extremely exciting. There is so much to
know today in medicine, the breadth and depth of knowledge is growing
exponentially compared to when I was a medical student. And yet at Dartmouth I
get like really excited about what we are going to be doing in that domain. We
are going to be looking at maybe a prolonged undergraduate experience and a
different medical school experience. We believe the Liberal Arts are extremely
important. We believe that we haven’t taken advantage as I was suggesting
before in our new center for healthcare delivery that we haven’t taken advantage
of engineering science as the business school sciences. We are going to look
for students who have a passion to change the world and we are going to
empower them with curricula that not just focused on the traditional basic
sciences and clinical science, it’s not enough to understand the mechanisms of
the scientific cycles of the cells or what drugs and how they work, but how do we
actually use your decision making with patients in a clinical practice, what kind of
Electronic Health Record systems need to be in place to help the patient through
this maze of healthcare that patients often get overwhelmed with. How do we
engage their families and their communities?
Margaret Flinter: Well Dr. Weinstein, I think one way in which you are already
making a great contribution, particularly to people already out there practicing in
the field whether in primary care or in the hospital is through the Green Books on
Clinical Microsystem Redesign. Now, that might not be a familiar term to a lot of
people but these are series of workbooks that provide as you say tools and
methods that busy clinical teams can use to improve the quality of and the value
of patient care as well as the work-life of the staff who contribute to that care.
And I thought the comment on your website was particularly important. It says
absent the intelligent and dedicated improvement work by all staff and all units,
quality efficiency and pride in work will not be made or sustained. So the
workbook sound like just that practical primers and how people practicing today
making sustained change. Can you just share with us a little bit about how you
see the Green Book helping practices to provide exceptional care and are you
helping them measure their improvement as well?
Dr. James Weinstein: Absolutely Margaret, the work by Paul Batalden and
Eugene Nelson and Mark Splaine and others in our organization have really
been leaders nationally in this notion of microsystem change where we actually
bring to bear all of the disciplines to manage patients care. People need to work
at the top of their license whether it’s a nurse, secretary, a nurse practitioner,
physician etc to coordinate the care for that patient in the most effective, efficient
way. And the Green Book asks people to understand their work within the
context of a whole in the management and to streamline that work to become the
most highly-valued, low-cost delivery system.
Mark Masselli: Dr. Weinstein, you have a great global view of the healthcare
transformations going on. What do you see in terms of innovations and who
should our listeners at conversations be keeping an eye on.
Dr. James Weinstein: One of the things I wanted to mention about a program
that Dr. Kim and myself are hoping that we will begin in July of 2011 here at
Dartmouth is very exciting. Dartmouth for the first time in its history will offer a
distance learning degree from Dartmouth College in healthcare delivery science.
It will be a synchronous and asynchronous learning experience meaning that
participants in the program will visit campus four times during the 18 months
period but most of the learning will occur back in their home state, their home
city, their home country. This will be an international project which we will provide
the tools and the knowledge that we have learned over the years to try to spread
it nationally.
Margaret Flinter: Today we have been speaking with Dr. James Weinstein,
Director of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice,
President of the Dartmouth-Hitchcock Clinic, and co-founder of the New
Dartmouth Center for the science of healthcare delivery. Dr. Weinstein, thank
you so much for joining us today on Conversations.
Mark Masselli: Each week Conversations highlights a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities in everyday lives. This week’s bright
idea focuses on a new project to combat obesity in several cities across the
United States. Armed with the new findings from a study that links community
violence with obesity rates and other chronic illnesses, the Prevention Institute
has partnered with local organizations in six of the most at-risk cities in the
country, Chula Vista, California, Denver, Colorado, Detroit, Michigan, Louisville,
Kentucky and Oakland, California as well as Philadelphia, Pennsylvania are part
of a six-month pilot project starting in January 2011. The project is run by the
Oakland-based Prevention Institute and is aimed at improving community health
through violence prevention by encouraging collaboration from many community
partners, ensuring adequate funding for initiatives and developing a multi-faceted
plan, with the goal of creating safe spaces and promoting community
development and social occasion. Reducing violence in these communities will
help make them healthier places to live in a variety of ways. When residents feel
safe in their neighborhood they are more likely to spend time outdoors and
exercise regularly which further improves neighborhood safety and health. In
addition to facilitating physical activity, reduced crime rates will also attract new
businesses to the area, including the full service groceries that many of these
communities lack. Residents’ access to fresh fruits and vegetables they need to
keep their family healthy will expand due to the increased number of local
grocery stores and the reduced anxiety of residents feel when walking through
their neighborhoods to the local store. To find out more information about this
project go to www.preventioninstitute.org . By working to improve neighborhood
safety, this pilot project will make regular exercise and healthy diet a realistic
option for residents and these crucial lifestyle changes will go a long way to
reducing obesity in cities across the country. Now that’s a bright idea.
Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Healthcare, I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Healthcare broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan University
at WESU streaming live at wesufm.org and brought to you by the community
health center.