Dr. Don Berwick, Recent Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services

Conversations speaks with Dr. Don Berwick, recent head of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) and a longtime advocate of patient safety and overhaul of the health care industry. Hosts Mark Masselli and Margaret Flinter speak with Dr. Berwick about transforming health care for all Americans and his focus on the triple aim of better quality, better health, and lower costs in health care.

(Music)

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Mark Masselli.

Margaret Flinter: And I am Margaret Flinter.

Mark Masselli: Margaret, there was a lot of news this week on the broader set of
the issues that affect health and health care in America from economics to
government policy to real health problems of Americans.

Margaret Flinter: Well it was a real range there Mark. On the one hand, there
was a report showing that the growth in health care spending was the lowest in,
do you believe this, 51 years. And a lot of that being attributed to the recession
and people just not spending money on health care they might have in the past.
Of course what we are worried about is they might be foregoing primary and
preventive care that will keep them healthy.

Mark Masselli: You know there was a very sobering study from Yale about the
impact that the dramatic rise in diabetes in young people is having today and the
impact it's going to have on our country in the future. The study showed young
people with diabetes were more likely to drop out of high school, less likely to
attend college, and stood to lose roughly $160,000 of income over the course of
their lifetime.

Margaret Flinter: That is an amazing figure and it reminds me Mark, you never
can separate physical health, economic health, the health of the country, and the
recession, it's just continuing to have a big impact on public health. I saw this
week a report from The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation saying that they
surveyed primary care physicians and 85% of the people they surveyed said
unmet social needs are worsening health for all Americans and most of them felt
they just didn’t have the power to do anything about it.

Mark Masselli: A majority of those physicians polled, said they wish they could
prescribe things like housing assistance, help with utility bills, healthy food
choices and easier access to good childcare, things they repeatedly see
negatively impacting their patients’ overall health. It reminds me of why we
started as a free clinic and then the Community Health Center here. This last
year, we started prescribing tokens to farmers market so we are doing some of
the things that many of the physicians really want to do.

Margaret Flinter: And one person who has been pivotal in understanding these
changes that need to be made to the delivery and the economics of health care
is Dr. Don Berwick, recent administrator of the Centers for Medicare and
Medicaid Services, and I think we would degree, a champion of better health for
all Americans.

Mark Masselli: He certainly is. Dr. Berwick carried out the first phase of the
Affordable Care Act directives for Medicare and Medicaid and is an advocate for
continued reform of the health care system. He will be speaking with us today on
Conversations on Health Care about his vision for a dramatic overhaul of health
care delivery in our country.

Margaret Flinter: And as always, if you have feedback, e-mail us at
www.chcradio.com . We love to hear from you. Now coming up, our conversation
with Dr. Don Berwick but first, lets hear from our producer Marianne O'Hare here
with this week’s Headline News.

(Music)

Marianne O'Hare: I am Marianne O'Hare with Headline News. The Obama
Administration has filed its first brief with the Supreme Court on the upcoming
challenge to the Affordable Care Act’s insurance mandate. Papers filed late last
week by the Justice Department argued the measure is protected under the
Constitutional Commerce Clause and this is accepted use of Congress’s taxing
powers. The Nation’s high court is scheduled to hear oral arguments in late
March. Customers seeking to fill prescriptions at the nation’s Walgreens or their
affiliates are out of luck if their insurance provider uses express scripts. The
company that negotiates prescription deals with the nation’s pharmacists was
unable to come to agreement with Walgreens on their prescription fees, alleging
the fees were about 20% higher than the competition. Walgreens fills about 90
million out of 750 million prescriptions issued each year. Preemies and painful
procedures; a recent study showed a little sugar water and gentle touch greatly
reduce discomfort in preemies who often receive numerous painful procedures in
their first weeks of life. Now that’s a sweet solution. I am Marianne O'Hare with
this week’s Headline News.

(Music)

Mark Masselli: Today, Margaret and I are speaking with Dr. Don Berwick, most
recently the Administrator for the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Service. Dr.
Berwick is also a Professor of Pediatrics and Health Policy at Harvard Medical
School. He is the founder of the Institute for Healthcare Improvement. Welcome
Dr. Berwick.

Dr. Don Berwick: Thanks. It's nice to be with you.

Mark Masselli: Yeah, and it's a pleasure to have you on the show and great to
welcome a fellow native of the great State of Connecticut so it's good to connect
in. As the administrator for CMS, you are responsible for a significant chunk of
the total health care expenditures in this country. You serve at a catbird seat if
you will. It came into the position as the most sweeping health care reform

legislation in a generation, was being written and signed into law. It's hard to
separate all the elements of this complex legislation but when you look at the key
components, expanding coverage, changing delivery, or changing how we pay
for care, where is the greatest impact likely to come from?

Dr. Don Berwick: It's justice in American health care that’s what I think about it.
It means taking a big step toward health care as a human right by making sure
that people in our country have health insurance. So, under this law 32 million
Americans at least, who the lack health insurance now, will have it as a result of
this law. The second part is essential also and perhaps less understood which is
in order to make health care sustainable we have to improve it. That would be
true even if we didn’t add this third generation people to coverage. But the health
care, it's a pretty broken system right now. It costs far too much, twice as much
as in any other country per capita. It doesn’t perform anywhere near twice as
well and we know there are lots of quality defects in health care, things that go
wrong all the time and that add waste to the system. And basically the secret
sauce to actually making health care sustainable is to improve it. So my agenda
there, make health care affordable through improvement of care.

Margaret Flinter: Dr. Berwick, you might have been the best known person to the
health care provider community ever to take over the helm at CMS. And I think
it's safe to say that many cheer the arrival of a clinician, a pediatrician who knew
what it was to take care of people in the context of a health care system and also
pulled no punches about how big are shortcomings in patient safety and in
consistency in quality care. And recently you were quoted in the Times as saying
that the people who give the care, the health care provider community have got
to be the people who lead these things forward now. So let me ask you what's
your call to action to the health care community? What’s the health reform
equivalent of the 100000 lives campaign that you unveiled when you were
heading up IHI?

Dr. Don Berwick: That’s such an important question. I can see now having been
in Washington for a year and a half how powerful and generative good public
policy can be. The new law, the Affordable Care Act is that. It’s a magnificent
law actually despite the controversy. People don’t really understand how good it
is, I do now. So it sets the stage, it makes it possible to focus energies on
improvement of care and keeping the patient foremost in mind. But what they
really do is create a space and opportunity, support for people to give care, to
improve the care they give. I think they really want to do that, most doctors and
nurses and hospital leaders, they want the care to be great but things stand in
their way. Now a lot of those barriers are gone. But the fact of the matter is
nobody really can change the care unless the clinicians, the professionals and
the people that organize care do it. Who else could? So here is an opportunity.
Can we work together as an entire nation of professionals and caregivers to
address the opportunity for care improvement? That includes things that make
care better directly for patients like safer care. We now know how to eliminate a

lot of infections, let's do it everywhere. If one hospital’s eliminated central-line
infections let’s just make that the standard and everybody do it. The same goes
for continuity of care. We know how to craft much better journeys for patients
with chronic illness, smoothing the way inside and outside hospitals. While we
could do that we have to change information systems, habits, trainings, training,
become teammate you know better teammates. All of that lies with the health
care professionals. So the call to arms, the action there is let's make care better,
let's commit as a nation that the best care anywhere will be the care everywhere.

Now part of that is cost reduction. I don’t think I would choose this to be the
mandate if we could do otherwise. We can’t avoid it anymore. Health care just
plain costs too much in this country and there is going to be only two ways to get
cost under control, a bad one and a good one. The bad one is cutting stuff, just
taking things away from patients, limiting benefits, denying insurance to some
people, it’s a really bad move, shifting burdens on to patients who can’t afford
them. I don’t like that idea. But it’s going to win because of the economic
pressures unless we choose the other way which is to save money by making
care better. That’s up to us.

Mark Masselli: So it’s sort of a dual agenda of we have got to make it safer,
improve outcomes but also just pulling the thread on it costs too much. And you
have made the point before that we could perhaps save 20% to 30% of our
expenditures and you have I think outlines that waste comes in a lot of forms,
duplication, you list out some treatment but also complications that could be
prevented, ambitions that wouldn’t have happened if there were better primary
care provider available, and the list is long. A signature accomplishment at your
time at CMS was the release of the Accountable Care Organization legislation.
You wrote the rules and you re-wrote them and the final versions were really
widely embraced. What will an Accountable Care Organization mean to a
patient? What's their role in all this and two, what is accountable to the patient to
ensure that care isn’t sacrificed to cost?

Dr. Don Berwick: Yeah, yeah good question. Well back to the premise. The way
to get care to be affordable is to get the waste out of care and the best people to
do that are people who give care. So waste comes in many forms but probably
one of the big ones is failures of coordination of care and every doctor, every
nurse, every patient knows what that feels like. It’s when they can't remember
your name, what your problem was, doesn’t move around with you, when doctor
number one prescribes a medicine that shouldn’t be given with a medicine
prescribed by doctor number two, when someone with chronic illness goes home
from the hospital and bounces back in six days because they had a complication
that nobody detected, all of that, everyone knows what failures of continuity and
coordination look like. So there has been a move toward a form of care, the
Accountable Care Organization, which actually is a pretty interesting idea. It’s to
encourage primary care providers to band together to take care of populations of
patients over time and space. But the patients don’t lose any choice; they still

can go anywhere they want. They are just normal fee-for-service Medicare
patients. So now this group of providers that said, well we will be accountable for
their care, they have got to now act through traction, they have to be such a great
place to get care that patients choose to stay there because they can feel the
continuity. If they manage to offer continuous care, avoiding readmissions,
reducing complications and so on, well costs will fall and the Accountable Care
Organization gets rewarded because it can share in the savings if the cost for
care of the population is less so they share in the savings. So the ACO is
watched closely. There are 33 quality measures, several of them include direct
feedback with patients. We are going to be watching quality really closely in the
ACO. So the only way they are going to be able to save money is by improving
care. If care gets worse, they won’t save any money and they won’t share in
anything.

Margaret Flinter: Dr. Berwick, it's been so sobering to note reports that as
Medicaid costs rise as a percent of state budgets, the budget share that can be
allocated to education is falling proportionately in some states and you know of
course the health of a community tends to rise directly in proportion to the level of
educational attainment so we don’t want to see this happen. Medicaid has such
big challenges, the cost of long term care for the elderly in nursing homes, the
cost of folks who are under age 65 but who are disabled and poor and on both
Medicaid and Medicare. It's also though in area where there is so much
innovation going on at the state level and the state Medicaid plans. What are
some of the promising areas of innovation at the state Medicaid plan level that
came across your desk while you were heading up CMS?

Dr. Don Berwick: A lot excited me. Better assistance for coordinated care,
getting especially dual eligible patients into really effective coordinated care
assistance but keep them home where they want to be, hiring health care
coordinators and others that really help people understand what's going on with
them and staying healthy. I also was really intrigued by innovations in
telemedicine. There are several projects, not just in the Medicaid realm, offering
consultations to primary care providers from university basis, there is a wonderful
program called the ECHO Program in New Mexico that’s just fantastic. It's
projecting technical care support to primary care providers all over the state. I
see lots of opportunities for using remote monitoring and for remote consultation
and for Medicaid population that’s crucial because these are largely people with
chronic illnesses.

Mark Masselli: Today, we are speaking with Dr. Donald Berwick, who recently
stepped down as administrator of the Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Dr. Berwick, I want to take you back to a thing, a speech you gave over a decade
ago, Escape Fire, and you told the gripping story of 13 young men who were
killed fighting a fire in Montana. The leader of the group, Wag Dodge, now you
couldn’t make up a name like that, survived by starting an escape fire essentially
creating an opportunity to find a route to safety. In your speech you talked about

the importance of sense-making in a critical situation, the essential qualities
needed to change old patterns and adopt effective ones. How has your work at
CMS advanced developing new leaders that can lead health care and help the
country escape the fire which I think you described as really a poorly performing
health care system?

Dr. Don Berwick: Well the story of Wag Dodge is that he invented a solution and
tried to get the other people to get into the escape fire area to save their lives and
they didn’t, they ran right past it and got killed. In health care, we have answers,
we have solutions, there are great programs all over the country and we can't run
past them, we have to say hey, wait a minute, if they know how to do it, we all
should do it. CMS now has tools for doing that. It has both incentives making it
more interesting financially for places to invest in better care. It also has the
ability to help people learn about what's new and what's possible through the
Innovation Center, the Center for Medicare & Medicaid Innovation. And before I
left, we introduced the Innovation Advisor Program which will support scores and
soon I hope hundreds of people around the country who would be in relationship
with the Innovation Center from their home base and will learn what's new, what's
coming along that they can adopt and use locally.

Margaret Flinter: Dr. Berwick, I am glad you mentioned the Innovation Center
because I have to tell you that I think your time at CMS ended just as you were
about to have some real fun in the middle of all that hard work that you were
doing like just about everybody in health care with drive for creativity. We are
very aware of the Center for Innovation call for creative ideas that offer real
evidence that can reduce cost, improve quality, improve the care of patients and
the CMS Center of Innovation has a billion dollars appropriated under the
Affordable Care Act. Some big ideas give us a sense of kind of ideas that you
think will come pouring in and what would you be really excited to see?

Dr. Don Berwick: Well first the Innovation Center has $10 billion.

Margaret Flinter: Oh excuse me.

Dr. Don Berwick: It is the largest national investment in innovation of health care
that we are seeing, it’s really, really exciting. And it's already issued a number of
calls for proposals around Pioneer, Accountable Care Organizations, bundled
payment demonstrations, fairly qualified health centers, advance primary care,
just tremendous stuff going on. The most recent $1 billion solicitation was for
sort of any ideas that have the effect of reducing costs while improving quality
quickly and I think we are going to see thousands of proposals coming in. There
are inventors all over the country, some of those will be in the telemedicine area
that I mentioned earlier, I think there are great opportunities there. And we need
much better ways to develop teams in coordination of chronically ill, take care for
chronically ill patients in very local settings. I think we will see new job roles
emerge as we think about how to help people through their journeys and care, I

think we are going to see lots of inventions around new roles for people to help
them learn how to stay healthy. And I have seen some of those around the
country already, they are pretty exciting.

Mark Masselli: Now a new proposal on Medicare was released the other day by
a representative Paul Ryan a Republican in Wisconsin and Democrat Senator
Ron Wyden and I would say it's more of an outline. The plan would set up a
competition between traditional Medicare and regulated private insurance plans.
Now the Whitehouse has penned the initiative; any initial thoughts on this?

Dr. Don Berwick: I highly respect the people that are trying to come up with new
ideas but I have not studied those proposals particularly so I am going to have to
hold my comments till I have studied them further.

Mark Masselli: Sure.

Margaret Flinter: Dr. Berwick, we have heard a lot of concern over the last
several years voiced about our country’s ability to meet the demand for primary
care, health care in general, but particularly primary care both when 40 million
Americans get health insurance but even today we have certainly heard about
this in Massachusetts and I they think turned out to be well founded particularly in
the more rural western area of the state. Now the Affordable Care Act addresses
primary care shortages in a variety of ways through training and through
incentives to attract more people to primary care. But I would like to ask you
one, do you think are turning the tide with regard to the shortage of primary care
providers and two, is it possible that there are more efficient ways for fewer
primary care providers or physicians, nurse practitioners, PAs, to take care of
more people?

Dr. Don Berwick: Yes and yes. Of course, you understand you are talking to the
son of a primary care provider, to a primary care provider, and a father of a
primary care provider so this is close to my heart. All strong health care systems
are founded in primary care not just physician primary care but advance nurse
practice and other roles. Yes, I think the tide is turning. There are more
incentives now under the Affordable Care Act toward primary care. I think that
everyone is aware of this as a problem and I think we are going to see more and
more progress toward increasing the attractiveness of primary care as a
discipline.

But the other point is equally important, leveraging the time of those who want to
give primary care so that they can take care of more people more effectively with
more joy in their own work it’s very important. That includes new roles. I always
worked for example with nurse practitioners, I never saw patients without a nurse
practitioner helping me and I know the value of non-physician roles and
supporting more effective primary care. And this is by the way also supported by
the new wave of exciting work to help patients and families take more

responsibility for their own care, really why would we make people helpless when
instead we can give them tools to stay healthy, to monitor their own physiologic
status, their own medicines, to be more active participant in care and that will
leverage primary care too. So I am optimistic it's going a little too slowly but I
think we are going to see acceleration.

Mark Masselli: This is Conversations on Health Care. Our guest is Dr. Donald
Berwick, former administrator of the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
You spend a lot of time trying to change the framework of how people think about
the payment system from volume to value. Talk to us a little bit about outside of
government beyond the Medicaid and Medicare payment what’s happening in
the private commercial sector or what are employers doing to help create that
change?

Dr. Don Berwick: Well a lot. One of the constant sort of frustrations at Medicare
for me was for people to perceive Medicare to be somehow outside the American
health care system and kind of its own thing. But it’s not, it’s a stakeholder in the
whole system. So happily, what we are seeing is lot of the same innovation that’s
occurring in the Medicare, under Medicare hospices , it’s occurring perhaps even
faster in the private sector. So lots of insurers are now experimenting with new
ways to pay for value not volume, for outcomes more transparently and to reward
organizations that achieve better health for their populations while containing
cost. The Alternative Quality Contract from Blue Cross Blue Shield in
Massachusetts, which has become quite well known as one such form but by no
means the only one. There is lots of synergy between the federal payer
Medicare and Medicaid and the private sector moving toward paying for what we
really want, which is health and better outcomes, not just for spinning the wheel.

Margaret Flinter: Dr. Berwick, it's been very exciting over the past year to see
many elements of health reform in motion, certainly watching the 20 something
stay on their parent’s policies and how much the rate of un-insurance has fallen
in that group, the expansion in Medicaid in some states increased public health
funding and of course the work going on building the health insurance
exchanges. But that threat is still out there in front of us that the Supreme Court
could find the act unconstitutional particularly the individual mandate. Now
forward progress is hard to stop but if that fell, if the individual mandate fell, do
you think meaningful reform can still move forward?

Dr. Don Berwick: Oh definitely. I mean first of all I don’t think the law will fall. I
think it's constitutional. Everything I heard when I was in government makes me
optimistic that the Supreme Court will find that this was a properly constructed
law under the constitution. That said the movement toward a better health care
system I think is unstoppable now. I mean we really have no choice because we
are headed for a cliff. Unless we find a way to make health care better and
affordable at the same time, our country is much more serious trouble than it is
now. So I think we are headed for health care change no matter what. I don’t

think the repeal or disabling of the Affordable Care Act is a good idea, it's a
terrible idea, it's a tragedy for the country as people lose the kinds of coverage
we were just referring to, insurance companies begin to get away again with
withholding coverage from people with preexisting conditions and so on. So I
think we will be smart enough as public to realize that we need to keep this law in
place.

Mark Masselli: Dr. Berwick, we like to ask all of our guests this final question.
When you look around the country and the world, what do you see in terms of
innovations and who should our listeners at Conversations be keeping an eye
on?

Dr. Don Berwick: All over the world, health care is at last discovering the same
connection between quality and cost that other industries discovered decades
ago. There is misperception in health care that in order to have the care we want
to need, we have to pay an ever-increasing share of our Commonwealth. I think
that’s not true. As in all other sectors, better care and better quality is the best-
of-breed to lower cost, and when we mature as an industry and realize that and
when professionals lead it, we will have a solution.

Margaret Flinter: Today, we have been speaking with Dr. Donald Berwick, former
administrator for the--

Mark Masselli: Each week, Conversations highlight a bright idea about how to
make wellness a part of our communities and everyday lives.

Margaret Flinter: Today’s bright idea looks at a unique way to use simple
Smartphone technology to help HIV-positive mothers in Sub-Saharan Africa
safely feed their babies breast milk without transmitting the HIV virus to their
children. Researchers from the University of Washington in partnership with
PATH unveiled promising data from a project currently underway in South Africa
where 40% of new HIV infections in children happen through prolonged exposure
to breast milk from their HIV-positive mothers. PATH, a non-profit organization
dedicated to maternal and infant health worldwide is studying a low cost cell
phone based system which guides the user to flash-heat pasteurize the
expressed breast milk to just the right temperature to kill the HIV virus without
harming the nutritional value of the breast milk. The AIDS epidemic had led to a
huge drop in human milk bank donations which are used to treat undernourished
low birth weight or orphan children. Using a simple phone app that comes with a
water temperature sensor connected to a datacenter, HIV-positive mothers as
well as milk banks are guided to flash-heat the expressed milk to just the right
temperature without damaging the milk’s proteins. The technology is cheap,
portable and effective, a potentially life-saving nutrition intervention for infants
who are pre-term, low birth weight, born to HIV-positive mothers or orphaned.
Simple inexpensive phone apps being used to improve infant health for tens of
thousands of at-risk infants, now that’s a bright idea.

Margaret Flinter: This is Conversations on Health Care. I am Margaret Flinter.
Mark Masselli: And I am Mark Masselli, peace and health.
Conversations on Health Care, broadcast from the campus of Wesleyan
University at WESU, streaming live at www.wesufm.org and brought to you by
the Community Health Center.